14 Jun 2024獨媒#3691
張國鈞稱香港法治從不建基於海外法官 不點名指岑耀信犯「法治大忌」
The case involving 47 people has attracted attention in Hong Kong and overseas. Jonathan Sumption, who resigned as a non-permanent judge of the Court of Final Appeal, described the matter as the “last straw”. In the latest development, Lawrence Wai Chung Lau and Yue Shun Lee, who were acquitted, were involved in an appeal by the Department of Justice against only Lawrence Wai Chung Lau. Deputy Secretary for Justice Cheung Kwok-kwan commented to the media today on Sumption’s resignation. He said that Hong Kong’s rule of law had never been based on the system of non-permanent judges, and, without naming Sumption, criticised him for interfering with legal proceedings by making comments, calling this a “major taboo” of the rule of law. He believed that non-permanent judges of the Court of Final Appeal “coming and going” was entirely normal.
Deputy Secretary for Justice Cheung Kwok-kwan met reporters after concluding his visit to Beijing. He said Xia Baolong, director of the Hong Kong and Macao Work Office, had “affirmed” the spirit of “fearlessness, impartiality, selflessness and honesty” among judges at all levels in Hong Kong. Cheung also quoted Xi Jinping as saying at the 20th Party Congress that “unity is strength”. He said Hong Kong’s judicial and legal sectors would stand united, uphold the rule-of-law principle, safeguard Hong Kong’s “golden signboard” of the rule of law, and promote the city’s development “from stability to prosperity”.
47人案惹來中外關注,辭任終審法院非常任法官的岑耀信形容事件是「最後一根稻草」。事態最新發展,是被判無罪的劉偉聰和李予信,只有劉偉聰被律政司上訴。律政司副司長張國鈞今向傳媒評論岑耀信辭職一事,他指香港法治從來「不是基於非常任法官制度上」,他又不點名批評岑耀信作出評論干預法律程序是「法治大忌」,他相信終院非常任法官「進進出出」,是非常正常的事情。
律政司副司長張國鈞在結束訪京後見記者,他表示港澳辦主任夏寶龍「肯定」香港各級法官的「無懼、無偏、無私、無欺」精神。張又引述習近平在二十大提到「團結就是力量」,稱香港司法法律界團結一致,堅守法治理念,定維護香港法治「金漆招牌,推動香港「由治及興」的發展。
13 Jun 2024法庭線#3682
港澳辦、建制派發文斥攻擊抹黑法治 岑耀信續受訪稱香港民主處「維生狀態」
After former UK Supreme Court justice Jonathan Sumption resigned early as an overseas non-permanent judge of Hong Kong’s Court of Final Appeal, he gave a series of interviews criticising Hong Kong’s rule of law and the verdict in the Hong Kong 47 case.
The Hong Kong and Macao Work Office published an article on Wednesday (12th), accusing Sumption of attacking and smearing Hong Kong’s rule of law. It said that “putting politics above facts and the law is biased political speculation and malicious political hype”, and accused him of making a “180-degree turn” from his position in 2021, criticising him for “willingly serving external forces to interfere in Hong Kong affairs”. The pro-establishment camp also rebutted Sumption in newspaper articles.
Sumption also gave an interview to the UK’s Sky News, saying that after the National Security Law, life had become difficult in Hong Kong for those who opposed government policies and pursued democracy. He again denied that he was discussing politics, saying he was pointing out how politics affected the judiciary. He described Hong Kong’s democracy as not having disappeared, but as being “on life support”.
英國最高法院前法官岑耀信(Jonathan Sumption)提早辭任香港終審法院海外非常任法官後,接連受訪批評香港法治及 47 人案裁決。
港澳辦周三(12 日)刊載文章,指岑耀信攻擊及抹黑香港法治,「以政治淩駕事實和法律,是充滿偏見的政治臆斷和惡意的政治炒作」,又指他與 2021 年時「180° 大轉彎」,批評「心甘情願為外部勢力干預香港事務效力」。建制派亦在報章反駁岑耀信。
岑耀信亦接受英國《天空新聞台》訪問,指《國安法》後,在香港反對政府政策、追求民主者的生活變得艱難,他再次否認自己談論政治,稱是要點出政治如何影響司法。他又形容,香港的民主雖未消逝,但處於「維生狀態」(it is on life support)。
11 Jun 2024集誌社#3666
回應岑耀信批法治倒退 特首:不干預法官審訊是香港的基因
Lord Sumption, who earlier resigned as an overseas non-permanent judge of the Court of Final Appeal, wrote an article criticising the decline of Hong Kong’s rule of law. Responding to reporters’ questions on the 11th, Chief Executive John Lee said that not interfering with judges’ trials is part of Hong Kong’s “gene”. He also said that British officials and politicians, as well as anti-China and anti-Hong Kong media, had openly threatened to impose sanctions on judges before, during and after trials, trampling on the rule of law.
Andrew Li, the Court of Final Appeal’s first Chief Justice, and Chief Justice Andrew Cheung also issued statements in response. Li said he regretted the retirement of the three overseas judges, but said that “more importantly, everyone should uphold their responsibilities and continue moving forward, rather than dwelling on the past”. Cheung said that any claim that judges’ decisions had been influenced by political or other external considerations “constitutes a serious allegation, which must be made on specific and sufficient grounds and should never be made lightly”.
較早前請辭的終審法院海外非常任法官岑耀信,撰文批評香港法治倒退,特首李家超今(11日)回應記者提問時表示,不干預法官審訊是香港的基因,又指英國官員、政客,反華反港媒體,在審訊前、期間、審訊後,公然恐嚇制裁法官,踐踏法治。
終院首任首席法官李國能、現任首席法官張舉能亦發聲明回應事件。李國能對三名海外法官引退表示遺憾,但指「更重要的是大家要秉持承擔繼續前行,而非沉溺過去」;張舉能則指任何指稱法官裁決,受到政治或其他外來考慮影響的說法,「都屬嚴重指控,必須理據具體且充分,絕不應輕率作出」。
11 Jun 2024明報#3667
前終院海外法官岑耀信指本港變「極權社會」 李家超:法官專業應在法律而非政治
Jonathan Sumption, who announced his resignation as a non-permanent overseas judge of the Court of Final Appeal last week, wrote in the Financial Times that he had previously remained on the court in the hope of helping to uphold the rule of law, but that this was “probably no longer realistic”; he added that others were less pessimistic and that he hoped they would prove to be right. He described Hong Kong as once having been a vibrant and politically pluralistic society, but as slowly becoming a “totalitarian society”. The HKSAR Government said it strongly disagreed with Sumption’s remarks, and that the claim that Hong Kong is “totalitarian” was absolutely untrue. Chief Executive John Lee, speaking before this morning’s Executive Council meeting, said judges’ professionalism lay in their legal knowledge and experience, not politics. He said judges might like or dislike a particular political system or law, but they must correctly interpret legislation according to legal principles and the evidence, rather than from the standpoint of their political positions.
上周宣布辭任終審法院非常任法官的岑耀信(Jonathan Sumption)在《金融時報》撰文,稱之前留任終院是希望有助維護法治,惟「恐怕已不再現實,其他人沒有那麼悲觀,我希望他們會證實是對的」;並形容香港曾是充滿活力和政治多元的社會,但正慢慢變成「極權社會」。特區政府表示極不同意岑耀信言論,「極權」說法絕非事實。特首李家超今早出席行會前回應事件,指法官專業在於法律知識同經驗而非政治,稱法官可喜歡或不喜歡某一政治制度或法律,但法官要按法律原則和證據正確詮釋法例,而非從其政治立場出發。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.