Eric Tat Ming Cheung loses judicial review bid over Law Society complaint process; judge says independent panel appropriate
張達明被指洩律師會內部資料 質疑投訴處理程序不公申覆核敗訴 官:成立獨立小組恰當
Eric Tat Ming Cheung, a principal lecturer at the University of Hong Kong’s Faculty of Law, was accused of twice disclosing internal Law Society matters while serving as a member of the Law Society Council in 2020. The allegations included prematurely disclosing a letter from the president to former Civic Party Legislative Council member Kwok Wing-hang, and disclosing on Facebook a statement issued by the Law Society that had been approved by the Council by a “large majority”, while also saying that some members held different views. The Law Society passed a no-confidence motion that year and referred the complaint to the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal. Cheung Chun sought judicial review, challenging the Council’s bypassing of normal procedures when referring the complaint, and arguing that the Council had simultaneously acted as the decision-maker, complainant and purported victim, creating a conflict of roles. Mr Justice Ko Ho-man dismissed the application on Wednesday (the 12th), saying the Council had recognised the sensitivity of the case and had therefore referred it to an independent panel comprising three former presidents. This showed that the Council had been trying to handle the matter in a fair and appropriate manner, and the arrangement had also sufficiently offset the risk of possible bias by the Council against the person concerned.
港大法律學院首席講師張達明,2020 年出任律師會理事會成員期間,被指兩度洩露內部事宜,包括向前公民黨立法會議員郭榮鏗提前披露會長信件,及在 FB 披露律師會發出的聲明,獲理事會「大比數通過」,又指當中有人持不同意見。 律師會同年通過不信任動議,轉介投訴至律師紀律審裁組。張循司法覆核,挑戰理事會轉介投訴時繞過正常程序,又批評理事會同時是決策者、投訴人及所謂的受害方,角色有衡突。 法官高浩文周三(12 日)駁回申請,指理事會意識到案件敏感,因而交由 3 名前會長組成的獨立小組跟進,反映理事會一直嘗試以公平、恰當方式處理,做法亦充分抵銷理事會可能對當事人偏頗的風險。
