Young Man’s Judicial Review Bid Over Repeated Police ID Checks Rejected; Judge Says Averted Gaze and Clenched Right Hand Were Suspicious
青年屢遭警查身份證 申司法覆核被拒 官指眼神迴避、緊握右手屬可疑
A 20-year-old man said he was stopped and asked to produce his identity card three times in total in November last year and January this year after police officers suspected that he was concealing drugs. He filed an application for judicial review in the High Court last year, challenging the constitutionality of police stop-and-search powers and arguing that the definition of “suspicious behaviour” in the Police Force Ordinance was too vague and infringed human rights guaranteed by the Basic Law. In a judgment handed down this afternoon, Judge Gou Hou-man refused leave to apply for judicial review, saying that requiring someone to produce an identity card was a “simple request” that would obstruct their journey for only one to two minutes, and that the threshold for police to consider someone’s behaviour suspicious was not high. The judge also found that the young man’s averted gaze and clenched right hand at the time constituted a sufficient threshold for suspicion.
一名20歲青年稱在去年11月及今年1月,共3次遭到警員懷疑藏毒,被截查並要求出示身份證。他去年入稟高院申請司法覆核,質疑警方截查權違憲,《警隊條例》對「行為可疑」一詞的定義亦太過空泛,侵害《基本法》賦予的人權。法官高浩文今午頒判詞拒絕批出司法覆核許可,認為截查要求出示身份證是「簡單要求」,只會阻礙行程1至2分鐘,滿足警方認為「行為可疑」的門檻不高。另外法官認為青年當時眼神迴避、緊握右手,已構成足夠的懷疑門檻。
