Registration Proposed for Observing Remote Criminal Hearings; Law Society Questions Compliance with Open Justice Principle
旁聽刑事案遙距聆訊擬要登記 律師會質疑有違公開原則
The Judiciary earlier published the Courts (Remote Hearing) Bill, which would allow remote hearings in criminal cases, although it specifically advises against their use in criminal trials. At a Legislative Council committee meeting, Law Society representative Stephen Wan Shun Hung questioned the Judiciary’s requirement for observers of remote hearings to register, saying that the arrangement contravened the principle of open justice. The Judiciary replied that, for the vast majority of remote hearings, members of the public could attend court in the usual manner, and that identity registration and distribution of a link would only be required when people were unable to go to court because of a pandemic or public-order considerations. The Judiciary also added that remote hearings would not apply to jury trials.
司法機構早前公布《法院(遙距聆訊)條例草案》,容許刑事案件採用遙距聆訊,但特別不建議在刑事審訊中採用。在立法會一個委員會上,律師會代表熊運信質疑司法機構要求遙距聆訊的旁聽者登記,做法有違司法公開的原則。司法機構回覆指,絕大部分的遙距聆訊,市民都可以按常在法庭旁聽,只有在疫情或公共秩序下無法前往法庭,才會要求登記身份並分發連結。司法機構又補充,遙距聆訊不適用於陪審團審訊。
