Fugitive Offenders Ordinance | ‘Privilege law’ cases add 7 and 20 days to Chu Hoi-dick and Chan Chi-chuen’s sentences; Lam Cheuk-ting pleads not guilty; Chan’s mother dies during imprisonment
逃犯條例|「特權法案」朱凱廸陳志全加監7及20天 林卓廷不認罪 陳服刑期間母離世
Three former Legislative Council members—Chu Hoi-dick, Lam Cheuk-ting and Chan Chi-chuen—who are serving sentences in the “47-person case”, appeared at West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Tuesday (11th) in connection with three cases alleging violations of the Legislative Council (Powers and Privileges) Ordinance involving clashes during Legislative Council meetings from 2019 to 2020. Chu and Chan pleaded guilty and were sentenced to 14 and 32 days’ imprisonment respectively. As both are serving sentences in the “47-person case”, the magistrate ordered parts of the sentences to run concurrently, meaning they effectively added 7 and 20 days respectively. Lam pleaded not guilty, and the trial was adjourned to September. In mitigation, the defence said that Chan’s mother, whom he “loved dearly”, had died while he was imprisoned. Although the Correctional Services Department made arrangements for him to see her once before her death, Chan regretted that he could not be by her side when she died. In sentencing Chu and Chan in the two cases respectively—the Fugitive Offenders Ordinance Bills Committee’s “twin meetings” case and the Legislative Council foul-water-splashing case—Acting Chief Magistrate Cheng Nim-chi said the cases did not involve extremely serious violence. However, the Legislative Council was a place for deliberation, where views had to be expressed peacefully, and the conduct of the two defendants could not be permitted. Their actions were also clearly politically motivated, resulting in the suspension or termination of meetings that should have continued.
正就「47 人案」服刑的 3 名前立法會議員朱凱廸、林卓廷及陳志全,周二(11 日)在西九龍裁判法院,就著 3 宗被指違「特權法」、涉 2019 至 2020 年的立法會會議期間衝突案件應訊。朱凱廸及陳志全認罪,判囚 14 天及 32 天,考慮 2 人正就「47 人案」服刑,官指部分刑期可同期執行,可視為加監 7 天及 20 天;林卓廷則不認罪,押後 9 月審訊。 辯方求情時提及,陳志全服刑期間,他「好錫」的母親不幸過身,雖獲懲教通融而在臨終前見到最後一面,但陳對過身當刻未能陪伴身旁抱憾。 署理主任裁判官鄭念慈判刑時,就朱、陳分別涉及的 2 案,即逃犯條例法委會「鬧雙胞」、「立會潑臭水案」指,案件不涉非常嚴重武力,但議會是議事地方,要和平表達,不容許兩名被告所作所為,二人行為亦顯然出於政治目的,致應有的會議暫停或終止。
