3 Sept 2024法庭線#4014
47人案 林景楠求情信:深切反思發現受海外勢力或網媒渲染 間接成反中亂港分子
The 47 pro-democracy figures were charged with conspiracy to subvert state power. On Tuesday morning (the 3rd), the court completed hearing the mitigation submissions for Hendrick Lui Chi-hang and Mike Lam King-nam, who stood in the New Territories East constituency. Alex Hoi Kit Fan, counsel for Lam, read out part of a mitigation letter written by Lam.
In the letter, Lam said that while awaiting trial, “through exposure to information and commentaries expressing different views from other friends, and through repeated argument and analysis”, he came to understand that taking part in the primary election had been “a very childish and foolish act”, which would only deepen divisions in society and could even lead to consequences endangering national security.
Lam continued that he realised taking part in the primary election, which might ultimately result in the Chief Executive stepping down, “was in fact falling into the schemes of other countries, groups and people with ulterior motives”. Through deep reflection, he became aware that he bore “considerable responsibility” for the divisions in society since 2019, as he was a leading figure in the yellow economic circle, for which he felt deep regret and engaged in deep reflection.
Lam also quoted President Xi Jinping as saying in public remarks on July 1, 2022, that “Hong Kong cannot be chaotic, nor can it afford to be chaotic”. He said that after deeply reflecting on everything he had done in the past, he “found that many Hong Kong people, myself included, had constantly been influenced by the embellishment and propaganda of many overseas forces or online media, and had indirectly become members of the anti-China and Hong Kong-disrupting camp”. He subsequently took the initiative to contact the police to plead guilty, and also thanked the prosecution for allowing him to become a witness, “so that I could disclose everything I knew and had heard”.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪,周二(3 日)早上完成處理參選新東的呂智恆、林景楠求情陳詞。林的代表大狀范凱傑,在庭上讀出林親撰求情信的部分內容。
林在信中表示,在候審期間,「通過接觸其他朋友不同觀點的資訊和評論,透過反覆論證」,明白到當初參加初選,「是非常幼稚及愚蠢的行為」,只是會令到社會更加撕裂,甚至會造成危害國安的後果。
林續指,認識到參與初選而最終或會令到特首下台,「其實是中了其他別有用心的國家、團體和人的計謀」,而透過深切反省,意識到要為自 2019 年起社會撕裂「負上不少責任」,因為他是黃色經濟圈的領頭者,對此深深悔疚和反省。
林又引述國家主席習近平,2022 年在七一公開發言時提及「香港不能亂,也亂不起」。他深切反思過去所做一切,「發現很多香港人包括我自己,一直受到很多海外勢力或網絡傳媒的渲染,間接成為反中亂港的一分子」。其後主動聯絡警方希望認罪,亦感謝控方讓他成為證人,「讓我可以把我的所知所聞一一供出」。
15 May 2023法庭線#6441
47人案|林景楠解釋一度欲轉新東參選 選舉主任供稱DQ何桂藍前政制局曾供料
The 57th day of the trial in the case involving 47 democrats charged with conspiracy to subvert state power began on Monday (15th). During cross-examination, the pleading guilty defendant Mike Lam King-nam agreed that he had considered factors including the chances of winning, and had planned to switch from the Legislative Council Import and Export functional constituency to contest New Territories East. After performing poorly in the primary, he announced that he would return to contest the Import and Export constituency. Lam also explained that, because of the social atmosphere, he used the word “rotten” to describe the functional constituency electoral system.
Huixin Yang, who was the Returning Officer for New Territories East at the time, gave evidence about the process of ruling Gwyneth Ho’s nomination invalid. Under questioning by the defence, she disclosed that the Constitutional and Mainland Affairs Bureau had provided two of Ho’s Facebook posts and asked Ho to explain their contents. She also agreed that the reasons for the decision had been written by someone else, and that she had agreed to and signed them.
The defence also revealed during cross-examination that the Facebook account used by a National Security Department officer to obtain evidence through online screenshots had commented under a post on Benny Tai’s page: “Even if you haven’t broken the law, wait for heaven to punish you!!!!!” The testifying officer admitted that the account was used only by police officers, but had no recollection of making the comment. He also agreed with the judge that the comment could have provoked others to make further comments.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周一(15 日)展開第 57 天審訊。認罪被告林景楠接受盤問時同意有考慮勝選機會等,擬由立法會進出口界轉至新東參選,後在初選表現不好,再宣布回到進出口界參選。林又解釋,因社會氣氛而以「敗壞」形容功能組別選舉制度。
時任新東選舉主任楊蕙心供述裁定何桂藍提名無效的過程,在辯方盤問下透露政制及內地事務局曾提供兩則何的 Facebook 帖文,她要求何解釋帖文內容。她又同意,裁決理據是由他人撰寫,自己同意並簽署。
另外,辯方盤問時揭露,國安處警員用於網上截圖搜證的 FB 帳戶,曾在戴耀廷的專頁帖文下留言「唔犯法都等天收啦你!!!!!」。作供警員承認帳戶只有警員使用,但自己沒印象曾發留言,又同意法官指,該留言有可能激起他人進一步留言。
17 Jan 2023法庭線#5962
47人案|林景楠改認罪 16不認罪被告排期2.6開審
The case against 47 pro-democracy figures accused of organising and participating in a primary election and charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” has lasted nearly two years since their first appearance in March 2021. At a pre-trial review at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, acting for the High Court, on Tuesday (the 17th), Mike Lam King-nam’s legal representatives said that he would change his plea to guilty and might record a witness statement. The number of defendants pleading not guilty fell to 16, and the case was adjourned for trial to begin on February 6.
The prosecution told the court that three defendants in the case would testify as prosecution witnesses, but did not disclose their names.
47 名民主派涉組織及參與初選,被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」案,由 2021 年 3 月首提堂起計至今近兩年,原有 17 人不認罪,林景楠周二(17 日)在西九龍裁判法院(暫代高等法院)處理審前覆核時,經法律代表指他會改為認罪,並可能錄取證人供詞。不認罪被告減至 16 人,案件押後至 2 月 6 日開審。
控方庭上透露,本案有 3 名被告將以控方證人身分作供,未有透露姓名。
25 May 2022獨媒#2026
阿布泰創辦人林景楠選舉廣告違例 入稟申免除刑罰獲批
AbouThai lifestyle goods founder Mike Lam King-nam, who was charged with conspiracy to subvert state power in connection with the primary election case, was accused of failing to comply with election laws when standing for election to the Legislative Council two years ago by not displaying the printer’s particulars in election advertisements and failing to retain copies of the advertisements. Mike Lam King-nam filed an application with the High Court last year for relief from the penalty, explaining that the breaches were due to negligence and a lack of election experience. The High Court handed down its judgment today, agreeing that Mike Lam King-nam had not acted maliciously and that no election-expense irregularities were involved, and granted the application.
涉初選案被控串謀顛覆國家政權的阿布泰生活百貨創辦人林景楠,前年參選立法會時,被指未遵從選舉法例,無在選舉廣告中顯示印刷人的資料,以及備存選舉廣告文本。林景楠去年入稟高院申請免除刑罰,解釋指是因為疏忽及欠選舉經驗。高院今頒下判辭,認同林景楠非出於惡意,亦無涉及選舉開支錯誤,批准其申請。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.