Lingnan student Lai Cheuk-yin disqualified from university elections; High Court rejects judicial review, accepts publicity limits ensure fairness
嶺大學生賴卓賢參選校董會等被DQ 高院駁回司法覆核 接納校方指限宣傳可保公平
Lai Cheuk-yin, external vice-president of the Lingnan University Students’ Union, was disqualified by the university’s election officer last November from standing in elections for the Council, Court and Senate after allegedly campaigning through “non-official channels”. He applied for judicial review, seeking to overturn the election officer’s decision and the election results. In a judgment handed down on Friday (the 4th), High Court judge Ko Ho-man dismissed his application and ordered Lai to pay the costs. Lai’s side argued that the election officer had exceeded his powers, misunderstood the relevant provisions and acted improperly in disqualifying him without giving him an opportunity to respond. The judgment said university elections differed from elections for public office and did not require publicity campaigns to be conducted in a complex or extensive manner. It also accepted Lingnan’s argument that restricting the forms of publicity could ensure that candidates received the same level of exposure and safeguard the fairness of the election. The judge said allowing candidates to publicise their campaigns only through the same methods was entirely fair, and ruled that the election officer had neither exceeded his powers nor acted improperly in procedural terms. Lai Cheuk-yin told The Witness that he was disappointed by the judgment but would respect it. Lingnan University said it welcomed the outcome.
嶺南大學學生會外務副會長賴卓賢,去年 11 月被指以「非官方渠道」宣傳,遭校方選舉主任 DQ 校董會、諮議會、教務會的參選人資格。他入稟申請司法覆核,要求推翻選舉主任的決定及選舉結果。高院法官高浩文周五(4 日)頒判詞,駁回其申請,賴兼須付訟費。 賴一方質疑,選舉主任越權、誤解條文內容,DQ 他時亦涉程序不當,沒有給予機會讓他抗辯。 判詞指,大學校內的選舉與公職的選舉不同,毋須複雜及廣泛地進行宣傳活動,亦接納嶺大一方指,限制宣傳方式可確保候選人獲相同曝光程度,確保選舉公平。官又指,候選人只能使用相同方式宣傳是完全公平的做法,裁定選舉主任沒越權,亦不涉程序不當。 賴卓賢回覆《法庭線》稱,對法庭判決感到失望,但會尊重。嶺大表示,歡迎裁決結果。
