Article 23 legislation | Comparison with 2002 draft: provisions protecting academic work and reporting disappear, while concealed treason offence is “revived”
23 條立法|對比 02年草案 保障學術、報道條文失蹤 隱匿叛國罪「復活」
The Government today (the 30th) explained its public consultation on legislation under Article 23 of the Basic Law. Chief Executive John Lee Ka-chiu described the consultation document as detailed, while Secretary for Justice Paul Lam Ting-kwok stressed that the Government would consider providing appropriate exceptions in the legislation so that members of the public would not have to worry about inadvertently breaking the law. With Article 23 legislation returning after many years, how does the consultation document released by the Hong Kong Government today differ from the consultation document issued 22 years ago? After comparing the two documents, The Collective found that the Hong Kong Government had clearly stated at the time that academic research or news reporting would constitute a reasonable defence to the offence of publishing seditious publications. It had also proposed that prohibition and declarations of organisations as unlawful should be subject to an appeals procedure. However, these proposed safeguards no longer appear in the latest consultation document.
政府今( 30 日)交代《基本法》第 23 條立法公眾諮詢,特首李家超形容諮詢文件內容詳細,律政司司長林定國亦強調會考慮就《條例》提供適當例外情況,讓市民毋須擔憂會誤墮法網。23 條立法事隔多年捲土重來,究竟港府今日公布的諮詢文件,與 22 年前的諮詢文件有何分別?《集誌社》比對兩份文件後發現,當年港府有清楚列明,學術研究或新聞報道屬「煽動刊物」罪的合理辯解;亦有提出禁制及宣布非法組織,應受上訴程序約制,然而,這些建議保障條文,在最新的諮詢文件亦已不復存在。
