San Tin Technopole EIA Conditionally Approved; Green Groups Accuse Authorities of Distorting Facts for Development Plan
新田科技城環評獲有條件批准 環團批疑為發展計劃扭曲事實
The Environmental Protection Department accepted the Advisory Council on the Environment’s recommendations and conditionally approved the environmental impact assessment report for the San Tin Technopole. Responding to criticism that the assessment was riddled with errors and omissions and could face a judicial review, Director of Environmental Protection Tsui Ho-kwong said every judicial review causes harm to society, adding that the time lawyers spend preparing materials and arranging a court hearing is often measured in years. Asked whether the department had considered a possible conflict of interest arising from the fact that the council’s chairperson, Johnny Yat Chiu Chai, is a director and alternate chairperson of the Hong Kong-Shenzhen Innovation and Technology Park near the San Tin Technopole, Tsui did not respond. Three environmental groups expressed extreme disappointment at the decision. They accused the department of allegedly distorting facts for the development plan, claiming that it had suddenly said it had referred to environmental and ecological data from the groups, exaggerated the effectiveness of mitigation measures without a scientific basis, and claimed publicly that it had communicated with the groups and responded to them, which they said could mislead the public.
環保署接納環諮會建議,有條件批准新田科技城的環評報告。對於環評被批錯漏百出、有機會遭司法覆核,環保署署長徐浩光稱每一個司法覆核都對整個社會造成傷害,單單律師做資料排期上庭的時間往往以年計。至於環保署接納環諮會建議時,有沒有考慮到環諮會主席查逸超是新田科技城附近的港深創科園董事兼候補主席,或涉利益衝突?徐浩光則未有回應。 三個環團對決定表示極度失望,批評環保署疑為發展計劃扭曲事實,突然聲稱有參考環團的環境生態數據,在沒有科學根據下涉誇大緩解措施成效,又對外聲稱與環團溝通並已作出回應,有誤導公眾之嫌。
