One convicted of conspiracy to defraud over $4.73 million through 100% guarantee loans using false information; judge says evidence showed multiple coincidences
涉以假資料詐騙473萬百分百擔保貸款 一人串謀詐騙罪成 官:證據出現多重巧合
Four men and women were accused of providing false information to defraud banks into approving more than $4.73 million in loans under the SME 100% Guarantee Loan Scheme. They were charged by the Police National Security Department with four offences, including conspiracy to defraud and money laundering. Defendant Cheung Ho-yeung had earlier pleaded guilty in the “Gwong Sing Ze” case and had the charges in this case withdrawn. Two other defendants subsequently pleaded guilty, while the remaining defendant, Chow, was convicted on Tuesday (30th) in the District Court of one count of conspiracy to defraud. Acting judge Jason Siu Ming Wan said WhatsApp records showed that the defendant had asked the mastermind to transfer $500,000 earned from trading watches into the company’s income so that the amount could be increased when applying for a 100% guarantee loan for a second time. On the day the two discussed the matter, the mastermind instructed an employee to forge documents claiming that the company had received a $500,000 deposit. The judge found that the “multiple coincidences” in the evidence could not have occurred, and convicted the defendant of conspiracy to defraud. As for another conspiracy-to-defraud charge, the judge said the defendant had proposed that the mastermind alter the company’s rental records when applying for a loan, and the conversation was suspicious. However, the charge alleged that the defendant had altered the company’s salary records and turnover, so the defendant was acquitted. Of the three convicted defendants, the female defendant who had pleaded guilty earlier was granted bail, while the other two were remanded in custody. The case was adjourned to 14 October for sentencing.
4 名男女涉提供虛假資料,透過中小企百分百擔保貸款計劃,詐騙銀行批出逾 473 萬元貸款,被警方國安處起訴串謀欺詐、洗黑錢等 4 罪。其中被告張昊揚早前在「光城者案」認罪,在本案獲撤控。另兩名被告先後認罪,餘下 1 人周二(30 日)在區域法院被裁定 1 項串謀詐騙罪成。 暫委法官溫紹明指, WhatsApp 紀錄顯示,被告曾著主謀將炒賣手錶所得的 50 萬元,撥入公司收入,以便第二度申請「百分百貸款」時將金額提高。而在兩人討論當日,主謀指示員工偽造單據,報稱公司收到 50 萬元訂金。官認為證據間出現「多重巧合」,不可能發生,串謀詐騙罪成。 至於另一項串謀詐騙罪,官指被告雖曾提議主謀申請貸款時,修改公司租金紀錄,對話可疑,但控罪是指控被告更改公司薪金紀錄及營業額,故裁定罪名不成立。3 名罪成被告,除早前認罪的女被告獲准保釋,其餘兩人均須還押,案件押後至 10 月 14 日判刑。
