Final Court rules that a framework recognising same-sex couples must be established; less than a year remains before deadline — what are LGBT groups thinking?
終院裁須設同性伴侶承認框架 距離限期不足1年 同志團體在想甚麼?
Shum Tsz-kit, a member of Rainbow Action and former convenor of the Civil Human Rights Front, earlier brought a final appeal over Hong Kong law’s failure to recognise same-sex relationships. He won the appeal in part at the Court of Final Appeal last September, when the court ruled that the Government’s failure to recognise same-sex relationships violated the Hong Kong Bill of Rights and required the Government to establish an alternative legal framework within two years to meet their basic social needs and provide legal recognition of their status. With less than a year remaining before the deadline, no specific legislative framework has yet emerged. The Policy Address released in the middle of the month also made no mention of the issue, prompting disappointment from some LGBT groups. In response to enquiries from The Witness, the Constitutional and Mainland Affairs Bureau said the Government was conducting detailed studies and drawing up implementation arrangements in different areas covered by the court’s ruling. Secretary Erick Tsang said in response to a Legislative Council member’s question in May that, given the complexity and wide-ranging nature of the issue, the bureau was conducting detailed studies with the relevant policy bureaux and would consult the Legislative Council at an appropriate time. The Witness interviewed LGBT groups and lawyers. Several described the Court of Final Appeal’s ruling as meaning that the Government must recognise same-sex relationships comprehensively, or that it could prompt Hong Kong to establish civil unions for same-sex couples. They said it was undoubtedly a historic step in the city’s progress towards LGBT equality, while some groups urged the Government to use the opportunity to promote same-sex marriage. Others, however, noted that the judgment left room for the executive authorities to determine the details. What form the final framework will take and whether its protection will be comprehensive remain unknown.
「彩虹行動」成員、前民陣召集人岑子杰,早前就香港法律不承認同性伴侶關係提終極上訴,去年 9 月獲終審法院裁定部分勝訴,指政府不承認同性伴侶關係,違反《人權法案》,要求港府於兩年內訂立替代法律框架,以滿足他們的基本社會需求及獲取合法身分認同。 距離限期不足一年時間,暫未見具體立法框架,月中公布的《施政報告》亦未有著墨,有同志團體對此表示失望。政制及內地事務局回覆《法庭線》查詢時指,政府正按法院裁決,就有關議題所涉及的不同範疇進行詳細研究及制定落實安排。局長曾國衞今年 5 月則曾回覆立法會議員提問指,鑑於議題複雜且牽涉廣泛,局方正與相關政策局進行詳細研究,會適時徵詢立法會。 《法庭線》訪問了同志團體及律師,多人形容,終院判決意味政府須整全地承認同性伴侶關係,或促使香港訂立同性伴侶民事結合,對本港同志平權進程無疑是歷史性一步,更有團體倡政府趁機推動同婚;但亦有人關注,法院判詞留下空間,具體細節由行政當局釐定,最終框架將以何種形態出現、保障是否全面,仍屬未知之數。
