3 Jul 2025集誌社#6986
考評局|補習導師四度質疑「錯答案」 局方堅持「設題無誤」 學者:題目有缺陷、答案不合理
With the release of the DSE results imminent, a tutor for Business, Accounting and Financial Studies found that the answer to a question in last year’s examination appeared to be wrong. The tutor contacted the Hong Kong Examinations and Assessment Authority (HKEAA), expressing concern that users might continue to apply an incorrect concept and have their learning affected, and requested a review. The HKEAA initially replied that it did not comment on individual questions and would not consider an appeal. After the teacher raised questions four times, the authority continued to insist that the question had been set correctly, but did not explain its reasoning.
《集誌社》 approached the HKEAA and accounting scholars for comment. The authority said that after receiving the inquiry, it had reviewed the question’s reference answer, which was accepted by the chair of the paper and the markers after review. It stressed that there had been no unusual circumstances during the marking process, but did not repeat that the question had been set without error. Zhaoyang Gu, a professor at the Chinese University of Hong Kong’s accounting school, described the question as having been set with “flaws” and said the reference answer was unreasonable.
DSE 文憑試放榜在即,有企業、會計與財務概論科目(下稱企會財科)導師發現,去年文憑試一條題目的答案疑出錯,向考評局查詢,表明擔心使用者沿用錯誤概念影響學習、要求局方覆核。局方最初回覆稱「不評論個別題目」、「不考慮上訴」,老師四度質疑下,仍堅持「設題正確無誤」但沒解釋理據。
《集誌社》向考評局和會計學學者查詢。局方指收到查詢後,已檢視題目參考答案,經檢視後獲試卷主席及閱卷員接納,強調閱卷過程未有異常情況,但未有再提「設題無誤」。中大會計學院教授顧朝陽則形容該題目出題「有缺陷」,參考答案不合理。
3 Apr 2024Channel C#3300
DSE首設內地考場約110人應試 考評局稱標準同樣嚴謹 強調公民科無損認受性
The Diploma of Secondary Education Examination (DSE) will begin next week. The Hong Kong Examinations and Assessment Authority (HKEAA) earlier announced that, on a pilot basis, examination venues would be established in the Greater Bay Area. The two mainland venues introduced this year are in Shenzhen and Guangzhou, with about 110 candidates sitting the examination at the two locations. HKEAA Chairman Samuel Wing Ki Yung said the standards at the mainland venues were equally rigorous as those in Hong Kong. He also said replacing Liberal Studies with Citizenship and Social Development did not affect the examination’s recognition by overseas institutions, saying he had “never heard” of any university requiring applicants to sit another public examination instead.
中學文憑試(DSE)將在下周開考,考評局早前宣佈以「先行先試」模式,在大灣區設考場。今年首設的2個內地考場分別在深圳及廣州,約有110名考生在兩場地內應試。考評局主席容永祺表示,內地考場標準與香港一樣嚴謹,又指以公民科取代通識科不影響海外院校對該試的認受性,指「從未聽聞」有大學要求申請者須考其他公開試取代。
22 Aug 2023獨媒#8231
DSE考生投訴「買卷」太貴違私隱條例 考評局:收回成本、用者自付原則
DSE candidates may apply to the Hong Kong Examinations and Assessment Authority (HKEAA) for copies of their answer scripts and marking records, commonly known as “buying scripts”. The first subject costs $380, with each subsequent subject charged at $104. Obtaining copies of their scripts helps candidates understand whether any marking errors were made. A current-year candidate complained to the Office of the Privacy Commissioner for Personal Data that the fees for “buying scripts” were too high. The HKEAA had previously not offered a lower-cost electronic option for obtaining scripts. Although it introduced an electronic option this year, it reduced the fee for the first subject by only $20. The candidate questioned whether this complied with the Personal Data (Privacy) Ordinance, which prohibits charging fees for accessing personal data that are “excessive”.
DSE考生可向考評局申請取回答卷複本及評分紀錄,俗稱「買卷」,首科申請要支付380元,其後每科以104元計算,考生取得答卷複本後,有助了解答卷有無改錯。有應屆考生向私隱公署投訴「買卷」收費過高,考評局過往未提供價格較低的電子取卷方式,今年即使提供電子選項,但只在首科申請減20元。考生質疑不符《私隱條例》不得收取「超乎適度」的查閱資料費用。
21 Dec 2020眾新聞#1089
【首度開腔】專訪離職考評局經理楊穎宇博士 親述歷史科試題風波內情始末「最可恥時刻」「香港墮落嘅指標性事件」
Former Hong Kong Examinations and Assessment Authority manager Hans Yeung Wing-yu, who was previously caught up in the controversy over a Diploma of Secondary Education Examination History question, said in an interview that he resigned because of political pressure and revealed that in 2017 he heard he was being monitored by the Liaison Office.
早前捲入文憑試歷史考題風波的前考評局經理楊穎宇,接受採訪時指因政治壓力辭職,並透露2017年聽聞自己已被中聯辦監察。
21 Dec 2020眾新聞#1093
Former HKEAA Manager Tells Insider History Exam Controversy Story –“Incident Indicative of HK’s Fall”
A former HKEAA manager tells an insider story about the controversial history examination question concerning Sino-Japanese relations and his subsequent resignation.
Former HKEAA manager tells insider story of the controversial history exam question abt Sino-JP relation & his subsequent resignation.
1 Dec 2020HKFP#976
Hong Kong official who resigned over history exam question reveals ‘immense political pressure’
An HKEAA official resigned under immense political pressure after a Hong Kong Diploma of Secondary Education history question was heavily criticised by state-backed media. He revealed that his personal social media account had been hacked twice and suspected that the question had been leaked before the examination took place.
HKEAA official resigns under immense political pressure after the HKDSE history question being heavily criticized by state-backed media. He reveals his personal social media account has been hacked twice and suspects the said question had been leaked before the exam took place.
17 Aug 2020立場新聞#769
任內取消歷史科試題惹爭議 考評局秘書長蘇國生完成任期不續約
The Hong Kong Examinations and Assessment Authority announced that Secretary General So Kwok-sang will not renew his contract after completing his term in March 2021, saying that So had taken the initiative to indicate that he would not continue in the post. During his tenure, an unprecedented controversy arose over an examination question. A question on Sino-Japanese relations in the History subject of the Diploma of Secondary Education Examination was accused of “hurting national feelings”. The HKEAA ultimately decided to cancel the question, affecting several thousand candidates.
香港考試及評核局宣佈,秘書長蘇國生在 2021 年 3 月完成任期後將不續約,考評局表示是蘇主動表示不續任。蘇國生任內發生史無前例試題風波,文憑試歷史科一條有關中日關係的題目被指「傷害國民感情」,考評局最終決定取消涉事題目,數千名考生受影響。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.