Affiliated union members handed out masks at street booth; four fined HK$6,000 each for violating gathering restrictions
職工盟屬會街站派口罩等 4人違限聚罪成各罰6,000元 官指非為防疫、不獲豁免
On 6 May 2020, the Construction Site Workers General Union, an affiliated union of the Hong Kong Confederation of Trade Unions, set up a street booth titled “Admiralty With You Lunch: Collecting Supplies” at the Admiralty Harcourt Road footbridge and handed out masks and other anti-epidemic supplies. They were subsequently prosecuted. Four people, including union officer Lam Siu-wai, denied one charge of “participating in a prohibited group gathering”. Magistrate Edward Ching Yu Wong ruled at the District Court, sitting in place of the Magistrates’ Court, on Thursday (the 3rd) that all the summons charges were proven, and fined each defendant HK$6,000. The magistrate said the street booth displayed slogans such as “Reclaim the Construction Sites” and “Union Front” in prominent positions, and repeatedly played recordings referring to “resistance” and other content. The location was also not a place where more members of the public could be reached. The magistrate ruled that the gathering was not intended to prevent disease and was not covered by the statutory exemption. The magistrate also said the gathering restriction only limited the form of gatherings and did not restrict the content of people’s expressions of their demands. Moreover, even if the defendants were exercising their freedoms of assembly and association, they did not need to participate in a gathering of more than four people. The charge therefore struck a balance between the public interest and individual rights. The magistrate also questioned why the defendants had not chosen to hold the gathering at a later date, given that the government relaxed the gathering limit to eight people just days after the incident.
2020 年 5 月 6 日,職工盟屬會「建築地盤職工總會」,於金鐘海富天橋設「金鐘和你 Lunch 之攞物資」街站,派發口罩等防疫物資,之後被票控。4 人包括工會幹事林小薇,否認一項「參與受禁羣組聚集」,裁判官王證瑜周四(3 日)在區院(暫代裁院)裁定所有傳票罪名成立,所有被告罰款各 6,000 元。 裁判官指,涉案街站於當眼位置展示標語如「光復地盤」、「工會戰線」,又重複播放關於「抗爭」等內容的錄音,選址亦非可接觸較多市民的地方,裁定涉案聚集並非旨在防疫,不獲法例豁免。裁判官又指,限聚令僅限制集會形式,並無限制表達訴求的內容,加上即使被告行使集會、結社自由,亦毋需參與多於 4 人的聚集,故控罪已平衡社會利益和個人權利。 官另質疑,政府於案發後數日便放寬至 8 人限聚,被告卻不選擇於較遲日子聚集。
