Blank-vote Incitement Case: High Court Refuses Certificate for Appeal to Final Court; Judgment Says Charge Was Reasonable in Light of Historical Background
蘇浚鋒煽惑投白票案 高院拒批上訴至終院證明書 判詞:考慮歷史背景認為控罪合理
Former Chinese University of Hong Kong Students’ Union president So Tsun-fung was accused of reposting online in 2021 a message by former Legislative Council member Ted Hui Chi-fung calling on voters to cast blank ballots in an election. He was prosecuted by the Independent Commission Against Corruption for violating the Elections (Corrupt and Illegal Conduct) Ordinance. After the trial magistrate ruled that the charge was constitutional, So changed his plea to guilty and was sentenced to two months’ imprisonment, suspended for 18 months. His subsequent appeal was dismissed. On Tuesday (24th), Deputy High Court Judge Yiu Fun-chi handed down reasons for his decision last month refusing to grant So a certificate to appeal to the Court of Final Appeal. The judgment stated that the appellant argued the court had wrongly assumed that inciting others not to vote or to cast invalid ballots would be detrimental to an election. He relied on overseas case law suggesting that prohibiting citizens from boycotting an election amounted to an unreasonable restriction on freedom of expression. He also argued that persuading others was at the core of freedom of expression, and that criminalising the advocacy of a lawful political viewpoint would bring no benefit to society. The Department of Justice, meanwhile, reiterated that the defendant’s conduct could exert improper pressure on voters’ freedom to vote. It also argued that there had been loopholes in the electoral system and that, if they had not been rectified in a timely manner, they could have obstructed the principles of “patriots administering Hong Kong” and “One Country, Two Systems”, thereby seriously undermining Hong Kong’s prosperity and stability. The court ultimately held that the charge in this case was, without doubt, manifestly reasonable. It noted that, when the offence was introduced, Hong Kong had experienced serious unrest and social incidents that endangered the constitutional and political order. This led the Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress to improve Hong Kong’s electoral system, followed by local legislation enacted by the Legislative Council after extensive debate and discussion.
前中大學生會會長蘇浚鋒,被指 2021 年在網上轉載前立法會議員許智峯倡選舉投白票帖文,被廉署起訴違反《選舉(舞弊及非法行為)條例》。蘇在原審裁判官裁定控罪合憲後改為認罪,判囚兩個月、緩刑 18 個月,其後提上訴被駁回。高院暫委法官姚勳智周二(24 日)就其上月,拒向蘇發出上訴至終院證明書之決定頒判詞。 判詞提到,上訴方認為法庭錯誤假設,煽惑他人不投票或投無效票會不利選舉,但海外案例指禁止市民杯葛選舉,屬不合理限制言論自由,又認為說服他人是言論自由的核心,若視宣揚合法政治觀點為犯罪,不會為社會帶來效益。 律政司一方則重申,被告行為可能對選民自由投票施加不當壓力,又指選舉制度有漏洞,若不及時糾正,或礙「愛國者治港」、「一國兩制」,嚴重損害香港繁榮安定。 法庭最終裁定,本案控罪毫無疑問是顯然合理的,因控罪制定時,本港經歷了危及憲制、政治秩序的嚴重動亂和社會事件,引致全國人大常委會為本港完善選舉制度,再由本地立法會經充分辯論和討論制定立法。
