Chan Wen-min says new vehicle registration mark search rules conflict with Court of Final Appeal interpretation and can definitely be judicially reviewed
陳文敏指車牌查冊新制與終院解釋有衝突 絕對可被司法覆核
The Transport Department has revised arrangements for searching vehicle registration marks. Applications for news purposes must be treated as an “exceptional circumstance” and supported by a written statement explaining that they involve a significant public interest, with the Director deciding whether to approve them. Chan Wen-min, a visiting professor at the University of Hong Kong’s Faculty of Law, said on a radio programme this morning that the department had imposed numerous hurdles, conflicting with the Court of Final Appeal’s interpretation in the Choy Yuk Ling, Bao case, and that the arrangements could definitely be challenged by judicial review. Chan also said frankly that the 7.21 incident involved a large number of people attacking members of the public with weapons in a public place, causing many injuries. If vehicle registration marks were linked to the identities of the attackers, he said: “If this does not involve the public interest, I would find it very difficult to see what would.” Executive Council member and Senior Counsel Ronny Tong said yesterday that it was difficult to say whether the 7.21 incident involved a significant public interest.
運輸署修改車牌查冊安排,新聞需要被視為「例外情況」,須徑書面申述涉及重大公眾利益,由署長決定是否批准。港大法律學院客席教授陳文敏今早在電台節目表示,署方設下重重關卡,與終院就蔡玉玲案的解釋有衝突,絕對有機會受司法覆核挑戰。陳文敏又直言,7.21事件涉及大量人士在公眾地方持武器襲擊市民,令不少人受傷,若車牌牽涉施襲者身份:「如果咁樣樣都唔涉及公眾利益,我就好難先睇到乜嘢先係公眾利益。」行政會議成員兼資深大律師湯家驊昨日曾稱難言7.21事件是否涉及重大公眾利益。
