Ho Kai-ming criticises LCSD for awarding Chinese book contracts to the lowest bidder, damaging publishing ecosystem and causing “involution”
霍啟剛批評康文署採購中文圖書靠「價低者得」 破壞出版生態製造「內卷」
The Government Logistics Department’s procurement of counterfeit bottled drinking water has prompted questions over whether there are loopholes in the tendering system. One of the main criticisms is that the government no longer uses a dual-track scoring system, and that the Director of Government Logistics can decide not to use a scoring system when handling tenders. During an oral question in the Legislative Council, Ho Kai-ming, representing the sports, performing arts, culture and publishing sectors, said the Leisure and Cultural Services Department’s public libraries had removed the previous scoring system for procuring Chinese-language books and replaced it with price as the sole criterion—in other words, “the lowest bidder wins”. Ho criticised the practice for damaging the healthy ecosystem of the publishing industry and causing “involution” in the local market. Secretary for Financial Services and the Treasury Christopher Hui denied that it was a case of “the lowest bidder wins”, saying that quality would not be sacrificed even without a scoring system. He said, “I don’t see this situation,” adding that the previous scoring criteria had become “basic technical requirements”: “No matter how low the price is, if the technical requirements are not met, I will not award the tender to them.”
政府物流署採購冒牌樽裝飲用水,公眾質疑招標制度是否存在漏洞,其中最令人詬病的是政府不再採用雙軌評分制,可以由物流署署長決定不採用評分制處理投標。在立法會口頭質詢,代表體育、演藝、文化及出版界的霍啟剛表示,康文署轄下公共圖書館採購中文書項目,剔除了以往評分制,改以價格水平為唯一標準,亦即「價低者得」。霍啟剛批評做法破壞出版業界的健康生態,亦令本地市場「內卷」。財庫局局長許正宇否認「價低者得」,稱即使不用計分制,也不會犧牲質量,「睇唔到呢個情況」,以往評分變成「基本技術要求」,他稱「無論價錢幾平,滿足唔到技術要求,我都唔會畀佢中標嘅」。 +F49
