July 1 LegCo riot case | 12 sentenced to 4 years 6 months to 6 years 10 months; Wong Chung-yao gets 6 years 2 months, Chow Ka-shing about 5 years 1 month
7.1立會暴動案|12人判囚4年半至6年10月 王宗堯囚6年2月 鄒家成約5年1月
In the July 1 Legislative Council riot case, four people, including Wong Chung-yao, were convicted of rioting after trial, while eight others in the same case pleaded guilty to rioting before the trial began. The 12 were sentenced on Saturday (the 16th) at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, sitting as the District Court, to between 4 years 6 months and 6 years 10 months in prison. Wong Chung-yao, who denied the charge, was sentenced to 6 years 2 months. Chow Ka-shing, who pleaded guilty, was sentenced to about 5 years 1 month; Hiu Laam Suen was sentenced to 4 years 9 months; and Lau Wing-kwong was sentenced to about 4 years 6 months. Two other defendants in the same case, who described themselves as journalists, were convicted of entering the Chamber without lawful authority and fined $1,000 and $1,500 respectively. Acting Judge Juleus Chee Ho Lee said the Legislative Council had a unique constitutional status and symbolic significance, and that the rioting in this case was extremely insulting and provocative. The protesters’ surrounding of the Legislative Council was also tantamount to an assault on the rule of law, making it one of the most serious riot cases. The seven-year sentencing starting point for some defendants, including Chow Ka-shing and Lau Wing-kwong—the District Court’s maximum sentence—was not excessive. As for the defence’s submission that Wong Chung-yao had stayed in the Chamber only briefly, the judge rejected it, saying that a person like him staying briefly could raise morale and cause the riot to continue. Taking into account that he was not involved in violence or destruction, the starting point was set at 6 years 6 months.
七一立法會暴動案,王宗堯等 4 人審訊後被裁定暴動罪成,同案 8 人則於開審前承認暴動罪。案件周六(16 日)在西九龍裁判法院(暫代區院)判刑,12 人分別判囚 4 年半至 6 年 10 月。 其中不認罪的王宗堯,判囚 6 年 2 個月;認罪的鄒家成判囚約 5 年 1 個月、孫曉嵐判囚 4 年 9 個月、劉頴匡判囚約 4 年半。同案另外兩名報稱記者的被告,「非法進入會議廳」罪成,罰款 1000 及 1500 元。 暫委法官李志豪指,立法會具獨特的憲制地位及象徵意義,本案暴動極其侮辱和挑釁,示威者包圍立會亦等同衝擊法治,屬暴動案中最嚴重。部分被告包括鄒家成及劉頴匡,以 7 年、即區院刑期上限為量刑起點不足為過。至於辯方指王宗堯僅短暫逗留在會議廳內,法官不接納,指「像他那樣的人」短暫留下,已能激起士氣,令暴動持續,考慮他不涉及暴力或破壞,以 6 年半為量刑起點。
