12 Aug 2024法庭線#3898
涉2020年參與非法集結 「踢保」4年後外地返港被檢控 20歲男生認罪囚8周
On the eve of the National Security Law for Hong Kong coming into force in 2020, netizens organised a “Sing with You” event at APM mall in Kwun Tong. Police subsequently entered the mall and dispersed the crowd, arresting four people that day. More than four years later, a male student who was 16 at the time and had previously abandoned bail was arrested when he returned to Hong Kong in July 2024. He was accused of holding a blue flag bearing the words “Hong Kong independence” and a Lion Rock design. He pleaded guilty that month to one count of participating in an unlawful assembly and was sentenced to eight weeks’ imprisonment at Kwun Tong Magistrates’ Courts on Monday (the 12th).
2020 年《港區國安法》生效前夕,有網民發起在觀塘 APM 商場「和你 Sing」,警方其後入商場驅散,當日有 4 人被捕。事隔逾四年,一名案發時 16 歲、曾「踢保」的男學生,2024 年 7 月返港時被捕,指他涉當天舉「香港獨立」字眼和獅子山圖樣的藍旗。他同月承認一項參與非法集結罪,周一(12 日)在觀塘裁判法院被判囚 8 周。
法庭為被告索取 3 項俗稱「3C」的報告,看能否以禁閉式刑罰替代監禁;惟辯方求情指被告正在英國讀書,冀服刑後順利開學,故不希望判入更生中心、勞教中心或教導所。
9 Aug 2024法庭線#3893
反恐首案|嚴文謙一方結案指黃振強有如「爛牌」 且有動機作出對自己有利證供
In the first case under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance, all seven defendants pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 69th day at the High Court on Friday (the 9th), with Yim Man-Him’s defence making its closing submissions.
The defence said the prosecution witness Victor Chun Keung Wong, who claimed to be the captain of Dragon Slaying Brigade, had As One “bad cards” in his testimony, but the prosecution still had to rely on it because Wong’s evidence was needed to show that, on the day of the operation, Dragon Slaying Brigade intended to cooperate with the Ng Chi-hung team, thereby establishing the conspiracy in this case. Wong had also received a plea agreement, immunity from prosecution and a reduced sentence, with some serious charges withdrawn, giving him a motive and considerable incentive to give evidence favourable to himself.
As for the evidence against Yim Man-Him, the defence said Yim had repeatedly been absent from previous operations, making remarks such as “I’m with my girlfriend” and “I have to go home”. He “did not look like the most active team member”. Before the operation on 8 December, Yim again said he “would be late” and “was not free”, and only appeared after Wong and his teammates complained. The case resumes next Monday, when the defence will continue its submissions.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周五(9 日)在高等法院踏入第 69 天審訊。由被告嚴文謙一方作結案陳詞。
辯方指,自稱為「屠龍」隊長的控方證人黃振強,證供有如一張「爛牌」,但控方仍要採用,因為需借助黃的口供以說明行動當天,屠龍打算配合吳智鴻團隊,才可構成本案的串謀。而黃又獲認罪協議、豁免起訴書、減刑,獲撤銷部分嚴重控罪,有動機及莫大誘因作出對自己有利的證供。
至於針對嚴文謙的證據,辯方指在過往的行動中,嚴多次缺席,例如表示「陪緊條女」、「要返屋企呀」等,「睇落都唔似係最積極嘅隊員」及至 12 月 8 日行動前,嚴又一度表示「會遲到」、「唔得閒」,隨後遭黃及隊友埋怨才現身。案件下周一續,辯方將繼續陳詞。
8 Aug 2024法庭線#3889
反恐首案|辯方指黃振強非誠實可靠 向「屠龍」隱瞞殺警計劃
The first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, involving seven defendants who have pleaded not guilty, entered its 68th day of trial at the High Court on Thursday (8th). The defence for defendant Cheung Ming-yu said Cheung had rarely participated in the “Dragon Slaying Brigade” group’s conversations and could not have known about the police-killing plan, and had also stated beforehand that he was unwilling to kill police officers. The defence said accomplice witness Victor Chun Keung Wong had previously breached the consensus of “Dragon Slaying Brigade” by privately planning to use firearms, asking, “So was what happened on 8 December also like that?” The defence said Wong had never told the team members about the plan, and the members did not know that it was “very serious, that many people would die and that the consequences would be unimaginable”, leaving them unable to decide whether to participate.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周四(8 日)在高等法院踏入第 68 天審訊。被告張銘裕一方指,張極少參與「屠龍」群組對話,不可能知悉殺警計劃,事前亦表明不願殺警。辯方指,從犯證人黃振強曾違反「屠龍」共識,私下策劃用槍,「咁 12 月 8 日發生嘅事係咪又係咁呢?」辯方指,黃從沒向隊員講述計劃,隊員不知計劃「好大鑊、會死好多人、後果不堪設想」,無法決定是否參與。
8 Aug 2024法庭線#3891
《立場》案三度押後裁決 主審法官郭偉健屆退休之齡 政府延長其任期至2025年
The Stand News case, in which the news outlet is charged with conspiracy to publish seditious publications, has spanned more than two and a half years since the formal charges were brought in December 2021. After three postponements, the verdict will be delivered on the 29th of this month. Presiding District Court Judge Kwok Wai-kin reaches retirement age this year, but the District Court Ordinance provides that a judge may remain in office as necessary if a case is being heard.
According to the May 2024 Government Gazette, Chief Executive John Lee, acting under the District Court Ordinance and on the recommendation of the Judicial Officers Recommendation Commission, extended Kwok’s tenure by 18 months, from 15 May 2024 to 14 November 2025.
The Judiciary told The Witness that, generally speaking, during an extension of tenure, judges at all levels may continue to receive fringe benefits and allowances apart from their salaries, such as housing, medical and dental benefits, and children’s education allowances.
《立場新聞》被控「串謀發布煽動刊物」案,由 2021 年 12 月正式起訴至今橫跨逾 2 年半,經三度押後,將在本月 29 日裁決。主審的區院法官郭偉健今年屆退休之齡,惟《區域法院條例》訂明,如有案件正在審理,可按需要留任。
翻查 2024 年 5 月的政府憲報,特首李家超按《區域法院條例》及司法人員推薦委員會建議,延長郭的任期 18 個月,由 2024 年 5 月 15 日起至 2025 年 11 月 14 日止。
司法機構回覆《法庭線》指,一般來說各級法官在延任期間,可繼續享有除薪金外的附帶福利和津貼,例如房屋福利、醫療及牙科福利、子女教育津貼等。
7 Aug 2024法庭線#3886
23條|涉6.12穿「光時」衫、戴黃口罩 27歲男擬認「新煽動罪」9.16答辯
On June 12 this year, a 27-year-old man was accused of wearing clothing bearing the words “Liberate Hong Kong; Revolution of Our Times” and a yellow “FDNOL” mask, loitering at Shek Mun MTR station and refusing to produce his identity card. He was charged with three offences, including the “new sedition offence” under the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance, and appeared again at West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Wednesday (the 7th).
The defence said the defendant intended to plead guilty to the new sedition offence. He was further remanded until Sept 16 for plea. The prosecution was represented by Senior Prosecutor Ting Wai Lee, and the defence by barrister Steven Kwan. The case was handled by Chief Magistrate Su Wai-tak. The defence also said that the charge of refusing to produce an identity card was brought under the Public Order Ordinance, but stressed that the defendant had not intentionally refused to produce his identity card. If the prosecution amended the charge to failing to produce an identity card under the Immigration Ordinance, the defendant would plead guilty.
The case was adjourned to Sept 16 for plea, pending discussions between the prosecution and defence.
今年 6 月 12 日,27 歲男子被指穿著印有「光復香港 時代革命」衣物、戴黃色「FDNOL」口罩,在石門港鐵站遊蕩及拒出示身份證,被起訴《維護國家安全條例》下「新煽動罪」等 3 罪,周三(7 日)在西九龍裁判法院再訊。
辯方透露,被告擬認新煽動罪,續還押至 9 月 16 日答辯。控方由高級檢控官李庭偉代表,辯方由大律師關文渭代表,案件由總裁判官蘇惠德處理。辯方指,被告打算承認「新煽動罪」。另外,辯方指本案的拒出示身份證罪,屬於《公安條例》下的控罪,但強調被告非故意不出示身份證,若控方改控《入境條例》下的沒出示身份證罪,被告將會認罪。
案件押至 9 月 16 日答辯,候控辯雙方商討。
7 Aug 2024法庭線#3887
反恐首案|辯方結案:仇警與串謀殺警是兩回事 「勇武唔代表係殺人犯」
In the first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants have pleaded not guilty. On Wednesday (7th), the 67th day of the trial at the High Court, the defence made its closing submissions, arguing that although defendant Cheung Ming-yu had participated in military training and test-firing guns, among other activities, the conspiracy had not yet taken shape at that time and therefore did not form part of the conspiracy in this case.
The defence also said that members of “Dragon Slaying Brigade” were from the militant camp, but “being militant does not mean wanting to kill people, and being militant does not mean being a murderer”. It said that although many people were hostile towards the police in 2019, conspiring to murder police officers was another matter. The use of petrol bombs by the “Dragon Slaying Brigade squad” during protests also could not be equated with using bombs to kill police officers. Even if Victor Chun Keung Wong had participated in the conspiracy, that did not mean other “Dragon Slaying Brigade” members had taken part, as “Hong Kong has no law of collective punishment”.
The defence said that Victor Chun Keung Wong had decided on his own to cooperate with the “police-killing plan” without the authorisation or consent of his teammates. It also said Wong had not told defendant Cheung Ming-yu about the plan: “How can you say he took part in the conspiracy when he did not even know what you were up to?”
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周三(7 日)在高等法院踏入第 67 天審訊,辯方結案陳詞指,即使被告張銘裕曾參與軍訓、試槍等,當時串謀計劃尚未形成,故不屬本案串謀之事。
辯方又指,「屠龍」成員是勇武派,但「勇武唔係等於想殺人、勇武唔代表係殺人犯」,指 2019 年時不少人仇警,但串謀殺警是另一回事,「屠龍小隊」示威時使用汽油彈,亦不能與炸彈殺警相比;而即使黃振強有份參與串謀,亦不代表其他「屠龍」成員有參加,「香港係冇連坐法的」。
辯方指,黃振強未經隊友授權及同意,自行決定配合「殺警計劃」,又指黃沒向被告張銘裕講述計劃,「點可以話有參加個串謀,都唔知你搞邊科。」
7 Aug 2024法庭線#3888
23條|涉網上提「革命無罪」男子被控「新煽動罪」 辯方稱將爭議控罪合憲性
A 58-year-old man was accused of posting seditious statements or photographs on online platforms including YouTube between March and June this year. The wording allegedly involved included “revolution is not a crime; rebellion is justified”. He was charged under the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance with knowingly publishing a publication with a seditious intention, and appeared again at West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Wednesday (the 7th). The defence said the new sedition offence does not require proof of an intention to incite violence and violates the freedom of expression guaranteed by the Basic Law, and will challenge the constitutionality of the charge. Chief Magistrate So Wai-tak noted that the Tam Tak-chi case would address the same issue and asked whether the proceedings should await the Court of Final Appeal’s judgment. The defence said the two sedition offences were not completely the same and that the ruling was “not 100 per cent applicable to this case”. The prosecution and defence will make submissions on the issue on 20 September. The defendant was remanded in custody. The prosecution was represented by Senior Public Prosecutor Ting Wai Lee, and the defence by barristers Steven Kwan, Yvonne Lai Kwok Leung and Sze To Tsz-long. The case was handled by Chief Magistrate So Wai-tak.
今年 3 月至 6 月期間,58 歲男子被指在 YouTube 等網上平台,發布煽動陳述或相片,據悉涉案字眼包括「革命無罪造反有理」,被控《維護國家安全條例》下的「明知而發布具煽動意圖的刊物」罪,周三(7 日)在西九龍裁判法院再訊。
辯方表示,新煽動罪毋須證明煽暴意圖,違反《基本法》賦予的言論自由,爭議控罪合憲性。總裁判官蘇惠德關注,「譚得志案」將處理同一爭議,應否等候終院判決,辯方則稱兩項煽動罪不完全相同,「唔係百分之百可以適用於本案」。
控辯雙方訂於 9 月 20 日就此陳詞,被告續還押。控方由高級檢控官李庭偉代表,辯方由大律師關文渭、梁麗幗及司徒子朗代表,案件由總裁判官蘇惠德處理。
6 Aug 2024法庭線#3882
反恐首案|辯方結案:黃振強砌詞狡辯 隊員被蒙在鼓裡、成「替死鬼」
In the first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, seven people pleaded not guilty. On Tuesday (the 6th), the trial entered its 66th day at the High Court, and the defence began its closing submissions. It said it did not deny that defendant CHEUNG Chun-fu had taken part in a riot, but that this did not mean the defendant had participated in the serious offences of planting bombs and murder alleged in the case.
The defence also said the evidence of the accomplice witness, Victor Chun Keung Wong, the self-styled captain of “Dragon Slaying Brigade,” was not credible. It said he fabricated excuses and quibbled when giving evidence, leaving people “unable to tell which of his statements were true and which were false”, and was an opportunist who was “very good at exploiting people”. The defence further said he ignored the consensus that “Dragon Slaying Brigade” would not use guns or bombs, secretly planned an operation to kill police officers, and kept his teammates in the dark, turning them into “scapegoats”. The defence stressed that Wong’s evidence contained too many doubts, that the benefit of the doubt should go to the defendants, and that the jury should find the defendants not guilty.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周二(6 日)在高等法院踏入第 66 天審訊,辯方開始結案陳詞,指不否認被告張俊富參與暴動,但不代表有參與本案涉放炸彈、謀殺的嚴重罪行。
辯方又指,從犯證人、自稱「屠龍」隊長黃振強的證供不可信,指他作供時砌詞狡辯、「唔知佢邊句真邊句假」,是「好識得利用人」的機會主義者;又指他漠視「屠龍」不用槍、炸彈的共識,私下策劃殺警行動,隊友蒙在鼓裡、成「替死鬼」。辯方強調,黃證供存有太多疑點,疑點利益應歸與被告,陪審團應裁定被告無罪。
6 Aug 2024法庭線#3883
涉街頭奏《願榮光》 七旬翁認無牌演奏及籌款囚18日、充公二胡 官斥冥頑不靈
Between September and October 2023, Li Xiexin, a man in his seventies, was accused of performing “Glory to Hong Kong” on the erhu in Kwun Tong, Kwai Chung and other locations. He was charged by summons with 12 offences, including unlicensed performance and fundraising. He pleaded guilty to eight offences at West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Tuesday (the 6th); the remaining four were filed with the court. He was sentenced to 18 days’ imprisonment. The case facts stated that the National Security Department conducted a “pre-emptive” investigation and secretly observed the defendant, who was also arrested once on suspicion of sedition.
Chief Magistrate Esther Tsu Kui-wai said the defendant committed the offences in this case while he was being tried for similar cases, showing that this was not an isolated incident, and criticised him as obstinate and unrepentant. The prosecution also said there was a risk that the defendant would continue offending, and its application to confiscate the erhu seized from his residence was approved.
2023 年 9 月至 10 月期間,七旬翁李解新被指在觀塘、葵涌等地,以二胡演奏《願榮光》,被票控無牌演奏及籌款等 12 罪,周二(6 日)在西九龍裁判法院承認 8 罪,餘下 4 罪存檔法庭,被判監禁 18 日。案情提到,國安處展開「先發制人」的調查,暗中觀察被告,並一度以煽動罪拘捕他。
主任裁判官徐綺薇指,被告就同類案件受審時干犯本案,顯示非單一事件,斥他冥頑不靈。另外,控方指被告有機會「死心不息」犯案,申請充公在住所檢取的二胡獲批。
5 Aug 2024獨媒#3879
【國安法四年.數據分析】至今逾300人被捕 定罪率首跌破100% 23條下至少7人未能提早獲釋
In June 2020, the Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress passed the Hong Kong National Security Law, ushering Hong Kong into a “new era”. The authorities have repeatedly used the National Security Law and sedition charges to make arrests and bring prosecutions. Before four years had passed, the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance, enacted under Article 23 of the Basic Law and referred to as Article 23, also formally came into effect in March this year. Together with the National Security Law, it has become what the authorities call the “two laws” that effectively safeguard national security, protect Hong Kong’s system, and target only an extremely small minority.
2020年6月,全國人大常委會通過《港區國安法》,香港進入「新時代」,當局屢次動用國安法和煽動罪名作拘捕檢控。不足四年,按《基本法》第23條制定的《維護國家安全條例》(下稱23條),今年3月亦正式生效,與《國安法》一同成為當局口中,有效維護國安、保障香港制度、只針對極少數人的「雙法」。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.