3 Jul 2023法庭線#7912
47人案|何啟明首日作供 稱支持〈墨落無悔〉內容 指理解為可用「一系列權力」
The trial of 47 democrats charged with conspiracy to subvert state power entered its 77th day on Monday (3rd). Ho Kai-ming began giving evidence. He acknowledged that he had read the “No Regrets Once the Ink Is Spilled” statement before signing it and supported two points in the statement. He said he understood it to refer to “a series of powers”, including changing the agenda and vetoing the budget, and that signatories had room to choose whether to use them.
Ho also said that the Association for Democracy and People’s Livelihood focused on grassroots livelihood issues such as the Comprehensive Social Security Assistance scheme, and that he would not define himself as belonging to the protest camp. The judge questioned why a Facebook post about the statement did not use the words “moderate pan-democrats’ statement”. Ho replied that the statement sought to find common ground while reserving differences: “It used ‘protest camp’, so I used its wording. Being moderate is demonstrated through actions, not claimed by oneself; the Association for Democracy and People’s Livelihood has a track record.”
The judge also asked about the meaning of “Liberate Hong Kong” in the Association’s meeting minutes. Ho explained: “I hoped to restore Hong Kong’s former values, freedom and the rule of law.”
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周一(3 日)展開第 77 天審訊。何啟明開始作供,他承認簽署〈墨落無悔〉聲明前有看過內容,他亦支持當中兩點聲明。他認為聲明所指的是「一系列權力」,包括調動議程、否決預算案等,且簽署者有選擇用否的空間。
何又指,民協關注基層民生如綜援議題,他亦不會介定自己是抗爭派。法官一度質疑,他 FB 上的〈墨〉帖文,為何用字不是「民主派溫和派聲明」?何回答聲明是希望求同存異,「佢用抗爭派所以我用返佢嘅字,溫和係做出嚟嘅,唔係自己講,民協有往績可尋。」
法官另問及,民協會議紀錄上提到「光復香港」的意思,何解釋「我係希望回復返香港以往價值,自由同埋法治。」
29 Jun 2023法庭線#7883
47人案|彭卓棋完成作供 引葉劉淑儀曾指不認同初選違法 稱「令我放心」
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with conspiracy to subvert state power entered its 76th day on Thursday (29th). Michael Cheuk Kei Pang, the second defendant to testify, completed four days of testimony. Under cross-examination by the prosecution, he said he knew the primary organisers had held a press conference after the National Security Law came into effect, but at the time he was only focused on canvassing and did not know its content.
In response to questions from the judges, Pang said he had not seen Secretary for Constitutional and Mainland Affairs Erick Tsang warn before the primary voting day that the primaries might violate the National Security Law. He also said he learned from news reports that Regina Ip, then an Executive Council member and chairwoman of the New People's Party, had said the primaries were legal. He said frankly, “Because of Regina Ip, that made me feel more reassured for a second time.”
Pang reiterated that after the National Security Law came into effect, he had torn up election leaflets and notified Power for Democracy to remove the manifesto, and therefore believed he had “done everything possible” to avoid breaking the law. He also said, “I gave up my manifesto; I really never imagined that something would still happen.” The trial will resume next Monday, when another defendant, Ho Kai-ming, is expected to testify.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周四(29 日)展開第 76 天審訊。第二名作供被告彭卓棋完成共 4 天作供。他在控方盤問下供稱,知悉初選組織者於《國安法》後有舉行記者會,但當時只關注拉票,不知道內容。
彭在法官提問下,指沒看到政制及內地事務局局長曾國衞,初選投票日前警告初選或違《國安法》,又稱從與新聞得知,當時行會成員兼新民黨主席葉劉淑儀,曾指初選合法,直言「因為葉劉淑儀就又令我放心多第二次」。
另彭重申,他在《國安法》後曾撕選舉單張,並通知「民主動力」移除政綱,故認為為免違法已經「做盡咗」。他又表示,「我放棄政綱,我真係萬估不到,都係會出事」。案件下周一續審,另一被告何啟明料將作供。
28 Jun 2023法庭線#7875
47人案|彭卓棋指因梁晃維已簽、為免輸陣勢而簽〈墨〉 稱從沒說要特首下台
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” entered its 75th day on Wednesday (28th). Michael Cheuk Kei Pang completed examination-in-chief and began cross-examination. Pang testified that Benny Tai had said veto power was “optional”, depending on whether the government was “doing a good job”; the judge asked what “good” meant and whether Tai had mentioned the government responding to the “five demands”. Pang said he had not.
Pang added that another reason he signed the “Ink Falls Without Regret” declaration was that he saw Leung Wong-wai, who planned to stand in the same constituency, had already signed it. He said he had thought that “if I didn’t sign, I would lose momentum”. He also said that after his arrest, he reread “Ink” and found that it did not mention an “indiscriminate” veto, prompting the judge to tell him not to quibble over wording.
Pang also said during examination-in-chief that he had never said the Chief Executive should step down. If he had known that “35+” meant the Chief Executive would step down and that the regime would be subverted, he would not have agreed. Under prosecution cross-examination, he said that when he met Tai before the primary election, he was concerned about whether he could win a seat and had no interest in whether the pro-democracy camp could secure “35+”. The trial will continue on Thursday.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周三(28 日)展開第 75 天審訊。彭卓棋完成主問,開始接受盤問。彭供稱,戴耀廷曾說否決權是「可用可不用」,視乎政府「做得好唔好」;法官追問何謂「好」、問戴曾否提及政府回應「五大訴求」?彭稱沒有。
彭又補充簽署〈墨落無悔〉聲明的另一原因,是看到擬在同區參選的梁晃維已簽署,當時認為自己「唔簽就會輸陣勢」。他又稱,被捕後再看〈墨〉,並沒提「無差別」否決,被法官促勿捉字蝨。
彭另在主問下稱,從沒說過要特首下台,若知「35+」是要特首下台、顛覆政權,自己不會同意。他又在控方盤問下稱,初選前與戴會面時,關心自己是否可取議席,沒興趣理會民主派可否取「35+」。審訊周四續。
27 Jun 2023法庭線#7864
47人案|彭卓棋形容〈墨落無悔〉為「鬥黃書」 同意為取悅選民「扮黃」
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” began its 74th day on Tuesday (27th). Michael Cheuk Kei Pang continued giving evidence, saying the primary’s “target voter segment” was made up of “deep-yellow” voters. He therefore used “election language” on different occasions to win voters’ approval, including saying at a forum that “the enemy is the Communist Party”; he also admitted that he “pretended to be yellow” to please voters.
The judge at one point asked why Pang had not joined the Democratic Alliance for Betterment and Progress (DAB). Pang replied, “Because in that electoral atmosphere, the DAB would lose,” and said he did not necessarily fully agree with the mainstream pro-establishment camp. Pang also said that the social atmosphere in 2019 was one of “ambition and high aspirations”, with many newcomers stepping forward: “I admit that I was a beneficiary of this wave.”
Pang also explained why he signed the “No Regrets After Putting Pen to Paper” declaration, saying that he only examined its contents closely after he was charged. Even if he had read it carefully beforehand, he said, “I have to be very frank with the court: I would still have signed it, because this is a document for competing to be more yellow.”
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周二(27 日)展開第 74 天審訊。彭卓棋續作供,指初選的「目標選民層」是「深黃」者,故在不同場合用「選舉語言」以爭取選民認同,包括在論壇稱「敵人是共產黨」;他另承認為取悅選民而「扮黃」。
法官一度反問,彭何不加入民建聯?彭答,「因為喺嗰個選舉氣氛,DAB(民建聯)會輸」,又指未必完全同意主流建制派。彭又指,2019 年社會氣氛「雄心壯志」,很多素人出來,「我承認我係依一個浪潮嘅得益者」。
彭又解釋,簽署〈墨落無悔〉聲明的原因,稱有案在身時才細看內容,而就算事前有細看,「我要好坦白同法庭講,我都會簽,因為依一份係鬥黃嘅書嚟嘅」。
26 Jun 2023法庭線#7858
47人案|彭卓棋供稱大學時創業、想在大陸做生意 不會「不予區別否決預算案」
The 73rd day of the trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” began on Monday (the 26th). After Cheng Tat-hung completed his testimony, Michael Cheuk Kei Pang began testifying under examination by the defence. Peng said he started a business while at university and founded the Hong Kong Youth Entrepreneurship Alliance in 2017 to promote information about entrepreneurship in the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area. During the primary election, he was mocked as a “Greater Bay Area pawn”.
In response to questions from the judges, Peng confirmed that he wanted to do business on the mainland. The judge asked whether he wanted to tell the court that he was “not anti-Communist and not anti-government”. Peng replied that he wanted the court to fully understand his thought process. Under examination by the defence, Peng also said that his original intention in running for the Legislative Council was to promote youth entrepreneurship, adding: “I wouldn’t indiscriminately veto (the budget); I would definitely consider (its contents).”
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周一(26 日)展開第 73 天審訊。鄭達鴻完成作供後,彭卓棋開始在辯方主問下作供。彭供稱讀大學時創業,2017 年成立「香港青年創業聯盟」,推廣粵港澳大灣區創業資訊,初選期間曾「俾人笑我係大灣棋」。
在法官提問下,彭確認想在內地做生意。法官追問他是否想告知法庭,他「不反共、不反政府」?彭答想讓法庭全面了解其心路歷程。彭在辯方主問下另稱,參選立法會初心是想推動青年創業,又稱「我唔會不予區別(否決預算案)嘅,我一定考慮(內容)」。
23 Jun 2023法庭線#7849
47人案|公民黨改政綱沒公布 鄭達鴻:相信公關上憂予人「縮得好勁」印象
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” resumed on Friday (the 23rd), entering its 72nd day. The judge questioned why the Civic Party had changed its platform after the National Security Law came into force but did not announce the change. Cheng Tat-hung said the party did not disclose it, “but I believe it was a public relations consideration,” adding that the party was concerned about giving people “the impression that it had backed down dramatically.”
Cheng also testified that his former party colleague Yue Shun Lee was invited into a police station after taking part in a street activity on 12 June 2020. The Civic Party subsequently discussed finding Li to stand in the super-district constituency. The judge asked whether the party wanted someone who appeared to be a “street fighter.” Cheng denied this, saying, “It was just that when people wanted to attack them, they could bring this up.” The judge then asked whether it would be best if he had been arrested before. Cheng answered, “Yes.”
Cheng also disclosed that he had “some disagreements” with Yue Shun Lee. He quoted Li, who had recently won a district council election at the time, as saying that he did not want to take part in “such mechanical work” as going into districts to distribute leaflets, and wanted to focus on district work. The trial will continue next week.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周五(23 日)展開第 72 天審訊。法官追問公民黨於《國安法》後更改政綱,但沒公布的原因。鄭達鴻稱黨沒透露,「不過我相信係一個公關嘅考慮」,又指黨憂慮「畀人哋嘅一個印象係佢哋縮得好勁。」
鄭又供稱,前黨友李予信 2020 年 6 月 12 日參加街頭活動被邀請入警署,其後公民黨討論找李參選超區。法官問黨是想找一個看似為「街頭戰士」的人?鄭否認,稱「只係佢哋想畀人攻擊嘅時候,可以有呢樣嘢講出嚟。」官其後再問,最好他有被捕過?鄭答「係。」
鄭又透露,曾與李予信「有啲拗撬」,又引述當時勝出區選不久的李稱,不想參與落區派傳單「咁機械性嘅工作」,並稱想專注地區工作。案件下周續審。
21 Jun 2023法庭線#7842
47人案|控方指公民黨一直立場是以否決迫特首回應「五大訴求」 鄭:非統一立場
The 47 democrats charged with conspiracy to subvert state power began the 71st day of their trial on Wednesday (21st). Under questioning by the prosecution, Cheng Tat-hung said he disagreed that the Civic Party had a unified position to veto the budget and force the Chief Executive to respond to the “five demands”, but acknowledged that he knew the party held such a position.
The prosecution also cited an election leaflet by defendant Michael Cheuk Kei Pang, which said that “the pro-democracy camp ... advocated ... vetoing the budget and forcing those in power to respond to the five demands”. It suggested that, since the Civic Party was part of the pro-democracy camp, this also amounted to the Civic Party’s position. Before Cheng could answer, the judge and both sides held a discussion. Cheng subsequently replied: “I think this was his [Pang’s] understanding of the pro-democracy camp.”
Cheng earlier said that, if elected, he intended to apply for an “exemption mechanism” in relation to voting against the budget, so that he would not have to vote in line with the party’s position. In response to questions from the judge, Cheng said he had mentioned the idea to his election manager, but could not remember how she had responded. The trial will continue on Friday.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周三(21 日)展開第 71 天審訊。鄭達鴻接受控方盤問時,指不同意公民黨有統一立場,要否決財政預算案、迫使特首回應「五大訴求」,但承認知悉黨有此立場。
控方另引被告彭卓棋的選舉單張提及「民主派…提倡…否決財政預算案,逼使當權者回應五大訴求」,指公民黨是民主派一員,因此單張所指亦等同公民黨立場?鄭未及回答,法官及控辯雙方作一輪討論,其後鄭答「我認為呢個係佢(彭)對民主派嘅理解」。
另外,鄭早前稱若當選,擬就否決預算案一事用「豁免機制」,申請免跟隨黨立場投票。法官追問下,鄭稱曾對其選舉經理透露該想法,但忘記她有何回應。案件周五續審。
20 Jun 2023法庭線#7832
47人案|鄭達鴻完成主問 稱按《基本法》 否決預算案不會致癱瘓政府
The trial of 47 pro-democracy defendants charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” entered its 70th day on Tuesday (20th). Defendant Cheng Tat-hung completed four days of examination-in-chief, outlining the chronology from his bid to stand for election to the Legislative Council to being deemed ineligible (see table in full article).
During examination-in-chief, Cheng testified about the Civic Party’s and his views on whether the primary election or rejecting the Appropriation Bill was unlawful. He said he had read the relevant provisions of the Basic Law and that, even if the Legislative Council were dissolved after rejecting the budget, the Chief Executive could approve temporary short-term funding. He therefore did not believe rejecting the budget would paralyse the government, and said he had no intention of subverting state power. He also said he left the party because he was “disheartened”.
Cheng also began being cross-examined on Tuesday, starting with two defendants for the defence, Michael Cheuk Kei Pang and Yue Shun Lee. He testified that his former party colleague Yue Shun Lee was initially not on the list of candidates and might also have been placed second on his list. Yue Shun Lee was later recommended to stand for election by Yeung Yuk-kiu and Alvin Yeung under the “drafting mechanism”. The trial continues on Wednesday.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周二(20 日)展開第 70 天審訊。被告鄭達鴻完成為時 4 日主問,證供勾勒出其爭取參選立會至被指不符資格的時序(見內文表)。
主問下,鄭供述公民黨與他對初選或否決《財政預算案》是否違法的觀點,提及曾看《基本法》條文,指就算立法會否決預算案後被解散,特首可批准臨時短期撥款,故不認為否決會造成癱瘓政府,自己亦沒意圖顛覆國家政權;他另提到因「心灰意冷」而退黨。
鄭周二亦開始接受盤問,由辯方兩名被告彭卓棋、李予信開始。他供稱,前黨友李予信原不在出選名單中,亦曾有可能排自己名單第二,其後李獲楊岳橋、譚文豪按「徵召機制」推薦參選。案件周三續。
19 Jun 2023法庭線#7824
47人案|鄭達鴻指因應《國安法》實施 公民黨召緊急會議、三度改政綱
The trial of 47 democrats charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” entered its 69th day on Monday (19th). Defendant Cheng Tat-hung gave evidence for a third day, testifying about the Civic Party’s response and changes in its positions before and after the National Security Law took effect (see table in the article).
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周一(19 日)展開第 69 天審訊,被告鄭達鴻第三日作供,供稱其所屬公民黨,在《國安法》生效前後的應對及其立場取態變化(見內文表)。
據鄭供詞,公民黨於 2020 年 3 月記者會,由黨魁楊岳橋稱如政府不回應「五大訴求」會否決所有議案後,同年 6 月內部發出「論壇天書」,要鄭在初選論壇上跟從「否決財政預算案、迫使特首回應五大訴求」的黨立場。
鄭續供稱,至 6 月底《國安法》實施,黨召開緊急會議達成 3 點共識,包括不再否決一切議案,但認為否決預算案合法,梁家傑稱否決絕非癱瘓政府。7 月初,公民黨 3 度更改政綱,包括刪去「根本上反對《國安法》」、改為僅 8 字的「無字政綱」。審訊周二續。
16 Jun 2023法庭線#7813
47人案|鄭達鴻續作供:在公民黨內兩度反對簽〈墨落無悔〉、信政府會拋橄欖枝
The 68th day of the trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” began on Friday (the 16th). Defendant Cheng Tat-hung testified that, during internal Civic Party discussions over whether to sign the “Ink No Regrets” statement, some legislative assistants and veteran party workers believed it should be signed, while he opposed it twice, saying, “We should not sign just because we say so; the party’s dignity would be lost.” His view was not adopted.
Cheng also described his position on vetoing the budget, saying he believed the government was rational and that, even if it did not respond to the “five demands”, it would offer an “olive branch” or sweetener in the budget. If the benefits to the public outweighed the drawbacks, he said, “there would be no way not to agree.” He said that if the Civic Party insisted on vetoing the budget, he would apply for an exemption from the mechanism requiring legislators to vote in line with the party’s position, adding that “the worst-case scenario is that I could leave the party”.
Cheng also said he had not received either the draft or final version of a Hong Kong Island coordination agreement document issued by Benny Tai, and believed that achieving 35+ was “extremely unlikely”. The trial will continue next week.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周五(16 日)展開第 68 天審訊,被告鄭達鴻供述公民黨內部討論是否簽署〈墨落無悔〉聲明時,有議助和資深黨工認為要簽,而自己兩度反對,認為「唔應該話簽就簽,個『黨格』會無咗」,惟意見不獲採納。
鄭又提到自己對否決預算案的立場,指相信政府理性,即使不回應「五大訴求」都會在預算案拋出「柑欖枝」或甜頭,若對市民益處多於缺失,「到時無可能唔同意」。他又稱,若公民黨堅持否決預算案,會申請「議員豁免跟隨黨立場投票機制」,而「最壞嘅情況係可以退黨」。
鄭並稱,沒有收過由戴耀廷發出、港島區協調協議文件的初稿及最終版本,他亦認為 35+「十分之不可能」達成。案件下周續審。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.