26 Jun 2024法庭線#3734
反恐首案|警員稱涉案電話檢取遙控裝置照片 被告TG談及製炸彈裝置
The first case under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance entered its 41st day at the High Court on Wednesday (26th), with seven defendants pleading not guilty. The prosecution called the police officer responsible for extracting data from the phones of defendants Lai Chun-pong and Lee Ka Tin, Christian. He testified that, after police decrypted and recovered the data, they recovered photos of Lai Chun-pong, photos of remote-control devices and other items from the phones involved. He also confirmed that the Telegram username “Have you finished folding the paper crane?” had discussed making a bomb remote-control device with another defendant, Choi Hoi-ming. The prosecution had earlier said that Lai’s Telegram name was “Have you finished folding the paper crane?”.
The prosecution also played extracted voice messages from the phone, including “How are you now? Your voice sounds a bit better,” and asked the officer to identify whose voice it was. The officer said he believed some of the messages had been sent by Lai Chun-pong, describing the voice in the conversation as similar to Lai’s voice. However, after the adjournment, the judge instructed the jurors to forget the relevant evidence and reminded them not to search social media content on their own.
《反恐條例》首案,不認罪的 7 人周三(26 日)在高等法院踏入第 41 天審訊。控方傳召負責擷取被告賴振邦及李家田電話資料的警員出庭,他供稱經警方破解及復原資料後,在涉案電話檢取賴振邦的照片、遙控裝置照片等,另確認 Telegram 用名「接完紙鶴未?」,曾與另一被告蔡凱明談及製作炸彈遙控裝置。控方早前提及,賴的 Telegram 名稱為「接完紙鶴未?」。
另外,控方播放手機中擷取的錄音訊息,包括「你依家點呀,聽你把聲好咗啲喎」,著警員辨認聲線屬誰。警員稱相信部分訊息由賴振邦發出,形容語音對話聲音與賴的聲線相似。惟法官休庭後,著陪審員忘記有關證供,並提醒他們不要自行翻查社交媒體內容。
26 Jun 2024法庭線#3735
理大衝突|警方事隔逾4年半重新拘捕5男 控告暴動等罪7.11提堂
In connection with the PolyU clash in November 2019, police re-arrested five men more than four and a half years later. Police said that following further investigation and additional legal advice, the five were each charged with one count of rioting. One of them was also charged with one count of criminal damage. The case will be brought before the court on July 11.
2019 年 11 月理大衝突,警方事隔 4 年半重新拘捕 5 名男子,指經跟進調查及進一步索取法律意見後,落案起訴 5 人一項暴動罪,其中一人同時被控一項刑事毀壞罪,案件將於 7 月 11 日提堂。
25 Jun 2024法庭線#3732
反恐首案|黃振強拘捕警否認曾威嚇及襲擊 稱其自願提供手機密碼、沒留意黃受傷
The seven defendants who have pleaded not guilty in the first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance entered the 40th day of their trial at the High Court on Tuesday (25th). The prosecution called arresting police officer Victor Chun Keung Wong, who identified himself as captain of “Dragon Slaying Brigade”, to testify. Wong had earlier said during cross-examination by the defence that he was assaulted with an officer’s hands and baton when arrested, and confirmed that he subsequently completed a complaint-against-police document through his legal representatives. The arresting officer told the court that Wong reacted violently and lunged at him when arrested, so he held Wong tightly, causing him to fall onto a bed. Colleagues then helped restrain him, after which the arresting officer handcuffed him.
The officer denied slapping Wong, verbally threatening him or forcing him to unlock his phone during the process, saying Wong was willing to provide the passcode. The defence showed photographs taken by Wong the following day, which showed injuries on his face. The officer said he had not noticed at the time that Wong was injured.
《反恐條例》首案,不認罪的 7 人周二(25 日)在高等法院踏入第 40 天審訊。控方傳召自稱「屠龍」隊長黃振強的拘捕警員出庭,早前黃曾在辯方盤問下指,被捕時曾被警員用手、警棍施襲,確認隨後經法律代表填寫投訴警察文件。拘捕警於庭上指,黃被捕時反應激烈撲向他,於是他緊抱著黃,令他跌在床上,由同袍協助制服,再由拘捕警鎖上手銬。
警否認過程中曾掌摑及言語威嚇黃、逼黃解鎖手機,指黃願意提供密碼。辯方展示黃翌日拍攝的照片,可顯示黃臉上傷勢。警則指,當時沒有留意他有受傷。
24 Jun 2024法庭線#3728
反恐首案|控方財務專家確認劉佩凝戶口獲多筆小額存款 曾向黃振強轉帳24.5萬元
In the first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 39th day at the High Court on Monday (24th). The prosecution called a financial expert to testify. He analysed the transaction records and flow of funds involving the accounts of defendant Lau Pui-ying, Victor Chun Keung Wong, the self-styled leader of the “Dragon Slaying Brigade squad”, and another man. He confirmed that an account in Lau’s name received multiple small deposits and that HK$245,000 had been transferred to Wong. Under questioning by the defence, he also confirmed that police had mentioned to him a TG channel called “Yuk Lung” and that he learned it was related to crowdfunding, but he did not know who managed the channel or what it was used for. Police had also not asked him to analyse whether the TG channel was related to the crowdfunding.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周一(24 日)在高等法院踏入第 39 天審訊。控方傳召財務專家作供,他分析被告劉佩凝、自稱「屠龍小隊」隊長黃振強及另一男子的戶口交易紀錄、資金流向,確認劉名下戶口獲多筆小額存款,曾向黃轉帳 24.5 萬元。他另在辯方盤問下確認,警方曾向他提及 TG 頻道「育龍」,得知與眾籌相關,但不清楚頻道由誰管理或用途,警方亦沒要求他分析該 TG 頻道與眾籌是否相關。
22 Jun 2024法庭線#3722
11.18油麻地|8人暴動罪成囚37至50月 官考慮疫情影響審期酌情減刑2月
On 18 November 2019, police cordoned off the Polytechnic University. A total of 213 people were charged with rioting in connection with the “besiege Wei to rescue Zhao” action in Yau Ma Tei, and the cases were split for trial. The final case to go to trial involved nine people. Five pleaded guilty before the trial began, three were convicted after trial, and the remaining defendant was acquitted. Acting District Court Judge LEUNG Ka-kie sentenced the eight people to between 37 and 50 months’ imprisonment at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, sitting as the District Court, on Saturday (22nd).
2019 年 11 月 18 日,警方圍封理工大學,213 人涉在油麻地「圍魏救趙」被控暴動,分拆成多案審理。最後一宗開審的案件涉及 9 人,5 人開審前認罪,3 人經審訊後被裁定罪成,餘下一人罪名不成立。區院暫委法官梁嘉琪周六(22 日)在西九龍裁判法院(暫代區域法院)判 8 人監禁 37 至 50 個月。
有被告案發時任職救護員,辯方指他以救援目的到場,又曾於當值時為警長療傷。但法官認為,當時被告身上沒有專業救援裝備,案發時亦不見他有救助他人。官另考慮本案曾因疫情而需重新排期,額外為 8 人扣減兩個月。
20 Jun 2024法庭線#3713
反恐首案|辯方透露同謀者張堅順為賴振邦姊夫 早前證供稱負責接載「槍手」
In the first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants pleaded not guilty as the trial entered its 38th day at the High Court on Thursday (20th). While cross-examining a police officer, the defence disclosed that accomplice Cheung Kin-shun is the brother-in-law of defendant Lai Chun-pong. Another officer confirmed the relationship but said he did not know that Cheung also worked at Lai’s “3C Repair Workshop”.
According to earlier testimony from an accomplice witness, Cheung had taken part in military training in Taiwan, burgled a university laboratory, and transported the “gunman” to and from the scene on the day of the plan to kill police officers.
The defence also put it to police officers that, when arresting Lai, they had attempted to force him to drink Dettol and threatened him at the police station to make him confess, saying they would “definitely get you jailed for more than ten years”. The officers all denied this.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周四(20 日)在高等法院踏入第 38 天審訊。辯方在盤問警員時披露,本案同謀者張堅順,為被告賴振邦姊夫;另一警員確認兩人關係,但不知張同在賴的「3C 維修工作室」工作。
據早前從犯證人證供,張曾參與台灣軍訓、爆竊大學實驗室,並在殺警計劃當日接載「槍手」到場及離開。
辯方另向警員指出,拘捕賴時企圖逼其飲滴露、在警署內威嚇作招認,否則「一定整到你坐十幾碌」;警員均否認。
19 Jun 2024法庭線#3707
反恐首案|辯方指嚴文謙被捕時遭毆打 警嘗試逼賴振邦飲滴露 警否認
In the first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants pleaded not guilty. The trial at the High Court reached its 37th day on Wednesday (the 19th). The prosecution called police officers who were involved in arresting defendants Cheung Ming-yu and Yim Man-Him to testify. The defence said Yim Man-Him was assaulted by police during the arrest. Officers demanded to know “where the others had gone”; after Yim Man-Him firmly insisted that they did not know, officers allegedly beat them again. The officers denied this.
An officer who arrested defendant Lai Chun-pong testified that, while escorting Lai back to the police station, Lai loudly stated their personal particulars, saying, “I’m not injured at the moment; I don’t know what will happen later,” and asking passers-by to film the incident and help find a lawyer. The defence said officers had tried to force Lai to drink Dettol and disinfectant alcohol, and repeatedly called Lai a “cockroach”. The police denied all the allegations.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周三(19 日)在高等法院踏入第 37 天審訊。控方傳召有份拘捕被告張銘裕和嚴文謙的警員作供。辯方指,嚴文謙被捕時曾被警員施襲,逼問「其他人去咗邊」,嚴稱不知後,再遭警員毆打;警員否認。
拘捕被告賴振邦的警員則供稱,將賴押返警署期間,賴曾高聲說出其個人資料,稱「我宜家身體冇受傷,唔知一陣會點」,著途人拍片及協助找律師。辯方指,警員曾嘗試逼賴飲滴露和消毒酒精,不斷罵他為「曱甴」;警一概否認。
18 Jun 2024法庭線#3703
逃出理大案|17人妨礙司法公正、暴動等罪成 囚20至70月 官斥理大生被告毀校園
In November 2019, a large number of protesters inside Hong Kong Polytechnic University were surrounded by police. Nineteen people were accused of helping others escape from PolyU and charged with offences including intending to pervert the course of justice and rioting. Five pleaded guilty to rioting, while the remaining 14 denied the charges and stood trial. They were previously found guilty of all charges, and two of them had already been sentenced.
Judge Wong Sze-lai dealt with the sentencing of the other 17 defendants at the District Court on Tuesday (18th). Five defendants identified as drivers were sentenced to between 20 and 24 months in prison. The other 12 defendants involved in the riot were sentenced to between 60 and 70 months in prison.
The judge criticised the PolyU protesters for acting recklessly and showing disregard for the law, saying they must bear criminal responsibility for their wrongdoing. She also said that some defendants were PolyU students or had previously studied there when the offences occurred, and that they had taken part in destroying their own campus. Regarding the defendants identified as drivers, the judge said that without the police operation, the defendants charged with rioting might have successfully left, describing their conduct as undermining the administration of justice.
2019 年 11 月,理工大學內大批示威者被警方包圍,19 人被指協助他人逃出理大,被控「意圖妨礙司法公正」、「暴動」等罪。當中 5 人承認暴動罪,餘下 14 人不認罪受審,早前被裁定所有罪名成立,其中兩人早前已處理判刑。
法官王詩麗周二(18 日)在區域法院處理其他 17 名被告的判刑,當中被指為駕駛者的 5 名被告,被判監 20 個月至 24 個月。至於另外 12 名涉及暴動的被告,則被判監 60 個月至 70 個月不等。
法官批評,理大示威者胡作非為、目無法紀,要為惡行負上刑責,又指有部分被告案發時是理大生,或曾就讀理大,他們有份摧毀自己的校園。至於被指為司機的被告,法官指若非警方行動,涉及暴動罪的被告可能已成功離開,形容被告行為打擊司法公義的執行。
18 Jun 2024法庭線#3706
反恐首案|辯方質疑警與黃振強會面25分鐘撰21頁口供 警:證供只涉財產、沒牽涉太多人
The first case under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance, involving seven defendants who have pleaded not guilty, entered its 36th day of trial at the High Court on Tuesday (the 18th). In relation to the charge under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance of conspiracy to provide funds for terrorist acts, Victor Chun Keung Wong, who had pleaded guilty and became a prosecution witness, was arrested and interviewed by police officer Pok Man Lo that day. The defence questioned how Lo could have written a 21-page statement after meeting Wong for only 25 minutes to take a “without prejudice statement”. Lo said Wong’s evidence did not involve many people, and that he recorded it in bullet points before drafting the statement, but the relevant document had since been destroyed.
A police officer from the Complaints Against Police Office confirmed that Victor Chun Keung Wong had complained of being assaulted and threatened by police officers during the arrest, and agreed to defer the complaint until the end of the criminal case. A firearms forensic expert also confirmed that the pistols involved used bullets of the same calibre and had a similar appearance.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周二(18 日)在高等法院踏入第 36 天審訊。就《反恐條例》下串謀籌錢作恐怖行為罪,已認罪、轉任控方證人的黃振強,當日由警員盧博文拘捕及錄取口供。辯方質疑盧向黃錄取「無損權益口供」時,僅會面 25 分鐘,但能撰寫 21 頁口供。盧表示,黃所述證供沒牽涉太多人,以點列方式記錄再撰寫口供,惟有關文件已銷毀。
投訴警察課警員確認,黃振強曾投訴被捕時遭警員毆打和威嚇,並同意暫緩投訴至其刑事案件結束。軍械法證專家則確認,涉案手槍均用同一口徑子彈及外貌相似。
17 Jun 2024法庭線#3699
陳真遭「私了」案 20歲學生申請推翻認罪答辯 法官拒絕
Middle-aged unemployed man Joe Chen allegedly bit off the left ear of former Eastern District councillor Chiu Ka-yin and wounded someone with a knife outside Cityplaza on November 3, 2019, and was subsequently subjected to vigilante justice. Six men were charged with rioting, wounding with intent and other offences. One of them, a 20-year-old university student, initially pleaded not guilty and stood trial, later changed his plea to guilty, and subsequently applied to overturn it.
Acting Judge Ko Wai-hung rejected the defendant’s application at the District Court on Monday (the 17th), upholding his guilty plea and refusing his bail application. He was remanded in custody until July 20, when he will make mitigation submissions together with the other defendants in the case.
The defence argued that the defendant’s guilty plea had been affected by attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder, causing him to plead guilty involuntarily. But the judgment said that his affidavit and testimony in court were inconsistent. In response to the defence’s emphasis that the defendant’s ADHD might have affected his testimony, the judge said he had experienced no problems with concentration or other faculties while giving evidence, and there was no evidence that his ADHD had affected his testimony.
中年無業漢陳真涉於 2019 年 11 月 3 日,於太古城中心外,咬甩前東區區議員趙家賢左耳及持刀傷人,其後遭「私了」。6 男被控暴動、有意圖而傷人等罪,其中一名 20 歲大學生原不認罪受審,及後一度改認罪,之後又申請推翻認罪答辯。
暫委法官高偉雄周一(17 日)在區院駁回被告申請,維持其認罪答辯,並拒絕其保釋申請,被告須還押至 7 月 20 日與同案被告一同進行求情。
辯方爭議被告認罪時受過度活躍症影響,令他不自願下認罪。但判詞指,被告誓章與庭上供詞不相符。至於辯方強調被告患過度活躍症,可能影響庭上證供。法官反駁指被告作供時,專注力等沒有問題,沒證供顯示受過度活躍症影響。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.