16 Mar 2023法庭線#6173
47人案|新東協議寫「會運用」否決權 區諾軒稱庭上剛看到、感被戴耀廷騎劫
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” entered its 26th day on Thursday (16th). The defence disclosed in court that a New Territories East primary election agreement document issued by Benny Tai included wording that the Basic Law veto power “would be used.”
Au Nok-hin testified, “I only just saw it myself.” Asked whether Tai had hijacked the opposing views, Au said, “I certainly had that feeling.” He also confirmed that League of Social Democrats member Chan Po-ying and he had both questioned the proposal to veto the budget at the meeting. Au further confirmed that neither he nor Tai had consulted Ray Chan about the primary election, and that he did not know whether Chan was aware of the dispute at the meeting over vetoing the budget.
In his testimony, Au also said he believed the “five demands” would be difficult to achieve in full, saying, “Politics ultimately requires negotiation and compromise.” He described the situation as “close to a deadlock.” As an example, he said that, according to his understanding, a group of university presidents had discussed the “establishment of an independent commission of inquiry” with the Chief Executive, but it ultimately failed to materialise. The trial will continue on Friday.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周四(16 日)展開第 26 天審訊。辯方庭上披露,由戴耀廷發出的初選新界東協議文件中,有「會運用」《基本法》否決權的字句。
區諾軒供稱「我都係啱啱睇到」。被問及戴是否騎劫了反對意見時,區稱「我確實係有呢個感覺」,他亦確認,會上社民連陳寶瑩及他本人都曾對否決預算案一事提出質疑。區又確認,他與戴均沒就初選諮詢陳志全,亦不清楚陳知否會上就否決預算案的爭議。
區作供時,另提到認為「五大訴求」難以完全實現,稱「政治始終係要有談判同埋妥協」,又指情況「接近一個死局」。他舉例指,按他理解一班大學校長曾與特首商討「成立獨立調查委員會」,但終未能實現。案件周五續審。
14 Mar 2023法庭線#6157
47人案|區諾軒同意積極用權否決預算案非共識 黃碧雲、林卓廷沒簽〈墨落〉
The 24th day of the trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with conspiracy to subvert state power began on Tuesday (the 14th). Under questioning by the barrister representing Wong Pik-wan and Lam Cheuk-ting, Erik Ignatius Sze Man Shum, Au Nok-hin confirmed that Wong and Lam had not attached to their primary-election nomination forms a joint manifesto containing wording on vetoing the budget, and that neither they nor “the entire Democratic Party” had signed the “Ink Falls Without Regret” declaration.
Au had earlier testified that Tai Yiu-ting added the wording “actively use the powers under the Basic Law to veto the Appropriation Bill” to coordination-agreement documents for the various districts. Citing video footage of Au’s meeting with police, Erik Ignatius Sze Man Shum questioned Au, who said Tai had stated that the wording “actively use” left political parties room not to veto the bill. Au also agreed that Tai had added the wording to facilitate discussion and balance differences, and that it was not a consensus among those attending.
While testifying, Au also volunteered that the Democratic Party, the League of Social Democrats and others had entrusted him with responsibilities, and that he “felt very guilty” at being unable to preserve diverse voices in the primary election. The judge asked further about Au’s and Tai’s roles. Au said Tai had “handled a very large part” of the work, including advocacy and organisational work, while Au was responsible for liaison, communication and forums. He also said “Three Votes, Three No Votes” was not part of the assembly, and that its expenditure was not included in the primary-election finances.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周二(14 日)展開第 24 天審訊。區諾軒在代表黃碧雲及林卓廷的大狀沈士文盤問下,確認黃、林沒在初選提名表夾附含否決預算案字句的共同綱領,而兩人與「成個民主黨都無簽」〈墨落無悔〉聲明。
區早前供稱戴耀廷在各區協調協議文件,加入「積極運用《基本法》權力,否決《財政預算案》」字句,沈士文引用區與警會面錄影盤問下,區指出戴曾稱「積極運用」字眼能為政黨保留不否決的空間。區又同意字句是由戴為促進討論、平衡分歧而加入,並非與會者的共識。
區作供時,又主動提及民主黨、社民連等託付於他,他對未能維護初選多元聲音「覺得好內疚」。法官追問區與戴角色,區稱戴「負責咗好大部分」,包括論述及組織工作,自己則負責聯絡溝通、論壇等。他又稱「三投三不投」不屬大會,其支出亦不包括在初選財政之中。
10 Mar 2023獨媒#6140
【初選47人案】區諾軒稱辦初選「初心」與戴耀廷不同、民主黨「墨落無悔」後維持不無差別否決預算案立場
The 47 defendants were charged with conspiracy to subvert state power over organising and participating in the pro-democracy primary election. Sixteen have pleaded not guilty, and today (the 10th) marked the 23rd day of the trial. Au Nok-hin was cross-examined by counsel representing Democratic Party members Lam Cheuk-ting and Wong Pik-wan. He agreed that he and Benny Tai differed over the primary’s objectives: his “original intention” was only to coordinate the pro-democracy camp in seeking a majority in the Legislative Council, while Tai placed greater emphasis on using veto power. He also acknowledged that the organisers “could not agree on an effective strategy” for pursuing the five demands. Asked whether he agreed that veto power should be linked to “35+”, Au acknowledged that he “ultimately did not object”, saying that the National Security Law had not yet been enacted and, “I indeed did not realise at the time that these propositions would violate the law.” Au also agreed that after the Democratic Party issued “Ink Without Regrets”, it maintained its position that it would not indiscriminately veto budget bills. He also did not know whether Lam Cheuk-ting and Wong Pik-wan had received the relevant coordination-mechanism documents.
47人涉組織及參與民主派初選,被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪,16人不認罪,今(10日)踏入審訊第23天。區諾軒接受代表民主黨黃碧雲和林卓廷的大狀盤問,同意與戴耀廷就初選目標有分歧,他的「初心」只是協調民主派爭取立會過半,惟戴耀廷則較着重運用否決權,亦承認組織者對如何爭五大訴求「傾唔到一個有效嘅策略」。被問是否同意將否決權與「35+」綑綁,區承認「終歸冇反對」,指當時未立《國安法》,「我的確冇為意到當時候呢一啲嘅主張,係會觸犯法例。」區又同意,民主黨在「墨落無悔」發布後,仍維持不會無差別否決預算案的立場,他亦不知道林卓廷和黃碧雲有否收到相關協調機制文件。
10 Mar 2023法庭線#6141
47人案|區諾軒:楊雪盈落敗後參選有違共識 不排除記錯劉偉聰有出席協調會議
The 23rd day of the trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with conspiracy to subvert state power began on Friday. Six more defendants confirmed that they had completed cross-examining Au Nok-hin (see the table in the main text for key points of Au’s testimony). Au testified that Yang Hoi-ying ran for the Legislative Council after losing the primary election, contrary to the “35+” consensus, because she was not the designated substitute candidate.
Lawrence Wai Chung Lau, who ran in Kowloon West and is representing themself, said during cross-examination that, contrary to Au’s earlier testimony, they had not attended a district coordination meeting at which vetoing the budget was discussed. Au said he “could not rule out” having misremembered. Under cross-examination by senior counsel representing Ho Kai-ming, who also ran in Kowloon West, Au testified that Benny Tai “unilaterally introduced” veto power at that meeting, while the four Kowloon West consensus points were all unrelated to vetoing the budget.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周五展開第 23 天審訊,再多 6 名被告確認完成對區諾軒的盤問(區作供重點見內文表)。當中,區供稱楊雪盈於初選落敗後參選立法會,有違「35+」共識,指因她非指定的替補人選。
出選九西、自辯的劉偉聰,盤問時指自己沒如區早前供稱,有出席提及過否決預算案的一次地區協調會議,區稱「唔排除」是自己記錯。區接受同屬九西的何啟明代表大狀盤問時,供稱該次會議戴耀廷「單向介紹」否決權,而九西的 4 項共識,均與否決預算案無關。
8 Mar 2023法庭線#6135
47人案|區諾軒:戴耀廷〈真攬炒〉文「挑動國家情緒」 致初選「質性變化」
The 21st day of the trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with conspiracy to subvert state power began on Wednesday afternoon (8th). It was previously disclosed in court that Au Nok-hin had said in a written statement that the primary election campaign and Benny Tai’s articles should be “considered separately”. In response to questions from the judge, Au said he was referring to Tai’s article “Ten Steps to Genuine Mutual Destruction: This Is Hong Kong’s Fate”.
Au also testified that the “original intention” of organising the primary election was that participants should not be bound by a position to veto the budget. However, Tai subsequently published several articles about “mutual destruction”. “I began to feel that his views had brought about a qualitative change in the primary election. That is also why, after he published the article on the ten steps to mutual destruction, I said the ideas in his article were too crazy.”
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周三下午(8 日)展開第 21 天審訊。庭上早前披露,區諾軒曾於書面口供,提及初選活動與戴耀廷的文章「應分開審視」。區在法官詢問下,稱是指戴〈真攬炒十步 這是香港宿命〉一文。
區又供稱,辦初選的「初心」是不應該綑綁否決預算案的立場,但戴其後陸續發布數篇有關「攬炒」的文章,「我開始覺得佢嘅睇法,令到初選有質性上面嘅變化,亦係點解喺佢發表咗攬炒十步曲嘅文章後,我話佢篇文章嘅想法太瘋狂。」
6 Mar 2023法庭線#6129
47人案|區諾軒:中聯辦發聲明後「盡力解散初選」 望退出後情節為同案覓求情基礎
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” entered its 20th day on Monday (the 6th). Under questioning by the defence, Au Nok-hin set out the timing of his withdrawal from the primary election (see table in the main text). He said he had always believed the primary was legal until Secretary for Constitutional and Mainland Affairs Erick Tsang Kwok-wai issued a warning: “Legally, I trusted Benny Tai’s view; politically, question marks began to arise.”
After the Liaison Office issued a statement on the day after the vote saying the primary was illegal, Au said he decided that day to withdraw and “do everything in my power to dissolve the entire primary”. He consulted political assistant Kenneth King Tsun Ng on whether it was feasible for the organisers to withdraw together, and Wu said they “could only do our best”. Au went to the University of Hong Kong that afternoon to raise the matter with Benny Tai in person, and he and Andrew Chiu Ka-yin announced their withdrawals over the following two days.
Au volunteered that, after reading the National Security Law provision on “automatically abandoning a crime”, he made the political decision to withdraw. He also said the successive withdrawals of the organisers left no one to take over the primary’s work. “I hope the circumstances mentioned above can provide a good basis for mitigation and lenient treatment in law for all the co-defendants in the case.”
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周一(6 日)展開第 20 天審訊。區諾軒接受辯方盤問時指,透露退出初選的時序(見內文表)。他指,一直相信初選合法,直至政制及內地事務局局長曾國衞警告,他「法律上信任戴耀廷觀點,政治上則開始響起問號」。
及至中聯辦於投票日後發聲明指初選非法,區稱當日決定退出並「盡我全力解散整個初選」,曾徵詢政治助理吳璟儁,組織者一齊退出是否可行,而吳稱「只能夠盡量做」。區同日下午到港大向戴當面提出,而自己與趙家賢隨後兩日宣布退出。
區庭上主動補充,是在看過《國安法》「自動放棄犯罪」條文後,作出退出的政治決定,又指組織者相繼退出令初選工作無人接手,「我希望上述嘅情節能為整體嘅同案,搵到好嘅求情同埋從輕發落嘅法律基礎。」
4 Mar 2023法庭線#6124
47人案|區諾軒盤問下稱 難推論公民黨對否決預算案立場 庭上首展示口供內容
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” began its 19th day on Friday (the 3rd). Prosecution witness Au Nok-hin, who has pleaded guilty, was cross-examined by senior counsel Hectar Hei Pun, representing Leung Kwok-hung and Cheng Tat-hung. The contents of Au’s statement were shown in court for the first time. It referred to “key disputes” between Benny Tai and the pro-democracy camp over how to implement the “five demands”.
Au confirmed under cross-examination that Civic Party legislator Tanya Chan and Shui Wah Lam had expressed reservations in early 2020 about vetoing the budget, while the same concern among pro-democracy parties continued until mid-May that year. However, when asked whether the Civic Party had maintained the same position throughout the year, Au said it would be “too categorical” to say so. He added that he could only describe what occurred at meetings between the parties and that it was difficult to infer whether the party’s views later changed.
Au also confirmed that after his arrest, he gave seven statements between July and August 2021, during which police arranged for him to inspect his phones. The prosecution also read out the agreed facts admitted by Wong Pik-yin, Ho Kwai-lam and Lam Cheuk-ting. Their accounts differed from those of the other 13 defendants in areas including the background to the primary election and press conferences held by the protest camp (see table in the full article). The case will continue next Monday (the 6th).
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周五(3 日)展開第 19 天審訊。控方證人、已認罪的區諾軒,接受代表梁國雄、鄭達鴻的辯方資深大狀潘熙盤問。庭上首次展示區的口供,提及戴耀廷與民主派曾就如何落實「五大訴求」有「重點爭議」。
區在盤問下確認,公民黨陳淑莊及林瑞華,2020 年初曾表達對否決預算案有保留,而民主派政黨的同樣關注延伸至同年 5 月中,惟被問及公民黨整年是否持同一立場時,區稱「唔能夠咁武斷」,又稱只能說雙方會面上的情況,難推論該黨往後看法有否轉變。
區亦確認被捕後,在 2021 年 7 月至 8 月錄取共 7 份口供,期間獲警方安排查閱電話。此外,控方亦讀出黃碧雲、何桂藍及林卓廷承認事實,3 人版本在初選背景和抗爭派記者會等方面,與另 13 被告的版本有別(見內文表)。案件下周一(6 日)續。
2 Mar 2023獨媒#6118
【初選47人案】庭上披露:警方據國安法取得提交物料令 要求蘋果、立場和獨媒交出資料
Forty-seven people were charged with conspiracy to subvert state power over organising and participating in the pro-democracy primary election. Sixteen pleaded not guilty, as the trial continued today (the 2nd) at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, sitting as the High Court. Yue Shun Lee, who was earlier injured while practising Muay Thai and was hospitalised, was absent from yesterday’s hearing but appeared in court as scheduled today. He appeared to be in good spirits, although the judge warned that if a similar situation occurred again, he would no longer be allowed to remain on bail. There are four versions of agreed facts between the prosecution and defence. The prosecution read out one version agreed by 13 defendants, which disclosed that police obtained a production order from the High Court on 24 December 2020 under Article 3 of Schedule 7 to the Implementation Rules for Article 43 of the National Security Law, requiring InMedia, Stand News and Apple Daily to provide or hand over case-related materials to police.
47人涉組織及參與民主派初選,被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪,16人不認罪,今(2日)於西九龍裁判法院(暫代高院)續審。李予信早前打泰拳而受傷留院,缺席昨日審訊,他今日如期出庭應訊,庭上所見精神不俗,不過法官警告若果類似情況再度發生,他便不會繼續獲准保釋。本案共有4個版本的控辯雙方同意事實,控方讀出其中一份由13名被告所同意的事實,當中披露警方根據《國安法第四十三條實施細則》附表7第3條,於2020年12月24日獲高院簽發提交物料令,要求《獨立媒體》、《立場新聞》、《蘋果日報》向警方提供或交出與案相關物料。
2 Mar 2023法庭線#6120
47人案|日前因李予信留院休庭 法官關注出院時間 控方讀出13被告承認事實
In the case involving 47 democrats charged with conspiracy to subvert state power, the court adjourned the trial after the defence said Yue Shun Lee had been injured while practising Muay Thai on Wednesday and was hospitalised. The 18th day of the trial began on Thursday (the 2nd). The defence said Yue Shun Lee had been discharged on Wednesday morning. The judge questioned whether public funds had been wasted; defence counsel said they had not known this at the time and said Lee apologised to the court.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,法庭因應辯方指李予信周三打泰拳受傷留院而押後審訊。案件周四(2 日)展開第 18 天審訊,辯方指李予信周三早上已出院,法官質疑浪費公帑;辯方大狀指當時並不知情,並指李向法庭致歉。
24 Feb 2023法庭線#6095
47人案|第15日審訊 控方播放初選記者會片段 戴耀廷稱看不到初選如何違反《國安法》
The 15th day of trial in the case involving 47 pro-democracy figures charged with conspiracy to subvert state power began on Friday (24th), with the testimony of Au Nok-hin continuing. During Thursday’s (23rd) hearing, the prosecution said it agreed to let Au read transcripts of parts of the press conference, without playing all the footage. It said, however, that one clip needed to be played because some defendants had remained silent, and the clip could show their reactions at the time.
The footage showed Benny Tai saying at the press conference that the primary election candidates had not made remarks relating to secession. He reiterated that they were exercising the constitutional powers conferred on the Legislative Council by the Basic Law and demanded that the HKSAR Government be held accountable: “This is a power conferred on the Legislative Council by the Basic Law ... I cannot see how this constitutes the ‘unlawful means’ referred to in Article 22 of the National Security Law.”
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周五(24 日)展開第 15 天審訊,續傳區諾軒作供。控方周四(23 日)審訊時表示,同意讓區閱讀部分記者會的謄本,毋須播所有片段,但提到需要播放其中一段片段,解釋指有部分被告保持沉默,片段可顯示他們當時的反應。
片段見到戴耀廷在記者會稱,初選參選人沒提出涉及分裂國家的言論,重申行使《基本法》賦予立法會的憲制權力,要求特區政府問責,「呢個係《基本法》所賦予畀立法會嘅權力嚟嘅⋯我見唔到點樣符合《國安法》第廿二條所講嗰個非法手段。」
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.