13 Jun 2024法庭線#3687
47人案|律政司確認已就劉偉聰無罪裁決提出上訴 沒就李予信提出上訴
The 47 democrats were charged with conspiracy to subvert state power. Sixteen defendants pleaded not guilty. At the verdict on 30 May, only Lawrence Wai Chung Lau and Yue Shun Lee were acquitted, becoming the first two defendants to be acquitted since the National Security Law came into effect. The prosecution said on the same day that it intended to appeal and asked that the two acquitted defendants remain on bail under their existing conditions. The Court of First Instance ultimately ordered that they continue to be released on bail, while reducing the frequency of their police reporting.
The Department of Justice confirmed to The Witness that on Thursday (13th), the final day of the 14-day period following the verdict, it had appealed against Lawrence Wai Chung Lau’s acquittal under section 81DA of the Criminal Procedure Ordinance. The department also confirmed that it had not appealed against the acquittal of the other defendant, Yue Shun Lee. Lee is currently the only defendant in a national security case who was acquitted at trial and against whom the Department of Justice did not appeal.
Yue Shun Lee’s current bail conditions include surrendering all travel documents and being prohibited from participating in elections at any level, among other conditions. The Witness also asked the Department of Justice about Lee’s bail arrangements and was told that it would handle the case in accordance with the law and the court’s directions, and would not comment further on the details of the case.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪,16 名被告不認罪,案件 5 月 30 日裁決,僅劉偉聰、李予信無罪,成為《國安法》後首兩名無罪被告。控方即日稱有意提出上訴,要求無罪兩人維持原有條件保釋。原訟庭終下令兩人繼續擔保,減少警署報到次數。
律政司回覆《法庭線》時確認,於周四(13 日)即裁決後 14 天限期的最後一日,已根據《刑事訴訟程序條例》第 81DA 條,就劉偉聰的無罪裁決提出上訴。律政司又確認,沒有就另一被告人李予信的無罪裁決提出上訴。李為目前唯一國安案被告,原審獲裁定無罪而律政司沒上訴。
李予信目前的保釋條件包括交出所有旅遊證件、禁止參與或任何級別選舉等。《法庭線》亦向律政司查詢李的保釋安排,獲回覆指會依法及按法庭的指示處理案件,不會對案件細節作進一步評論。
22 Aug 2023法庭線#8226
47人案|李予信完成作供 稱公民黨不支持攬炒 理解黨對否決預算案有彈性
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” entered its 111th day on Tuesday (22nd). Yue Shun Lee completed four days of testimony, while the defence case has so far taken 46 days (see table in the article). Yu Wai-ming, who is standing in the Health Services constituency, is expected to begin testifying on Wednesday.
Yue Shun Lee testified that she had seen the “No Regrets Once the Ink Is Spilled” statement but had not examined it closely. The prosecution cited a forum document prepared by the Civic Party for primary election candidates, which said that vetoing the budget could force the government to implement the five demands. Yue Shun Lee testified that the document was not binding and reflected flexibility that “existed very vaguely”, and that she had not mentioned vetoing the budget or related matters at the primary election forum.
The prosecution also cited a Civic Party Facebook post, noting that it did not mention that there was flexibility over vetoing the budget, and asked whether Yue Shun Lee had asked Jeremy Tam about it and confronted him. She said she had not: “But he encouraged me to continue holding to the platform I originally wanted to talk about.” She also said that when Bill Yan Piau Lay called to invite her to stand in the New Territories West constituency, “he did not put any pressure on me or tell me that I had to make certain promises.”
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周二(22 日)展開第 111 天審訊,李予信完成共 4 天作供,辯方案情至今處理 46 天(見內文表),預料參選衛生服務界的余慧明周三開始作供。
李供稱,有看過〈墨落無悔〉聲明但沒深究。控方引用公民黨為初選參選人準備的論壇文件,寫有可透過否決預算案逼使政府落實五大訴求等。李予信供稱,文件沒約束力,並反映彈性「好模糊地存在」,而自己於初選論壇沒說過否決預算案等。
控方又引用公民黨 Facebook 帖文,指沒提及否決預算案是有彈性,問李有否問譚文豪,與他對質?李稱沒有,「但係佢鼓勵我繼續去持有我本來想講嘅政綱」,並指獲賴仁彪致電參選超區時,「佢亦都無俾任何嘅壓力,叫我一定要去講某啲嘅承諾」。
21 Aug 2023法庭線#8225
47人案|李予信稱不會跟隨公民黨「莊嚴承諾」否決預算案 法官屢質疑
The trial of 47 pro-democracy defendants charged with conspiracy to subvert state power entered its 110th day on Monday (21st), with Yue Shun Lee beginning cross-examination by the prosecution. The prosecution cited Alvin Yeung as saying at a Civic Party press conference that, if the government did not respond to the “five demands”, it would vote down every bill and funding proposal, describing this as a “solemn promise”.
Lee said he understood that the promise might not be honoured, and that he would not follow the party’s position in voting down the budget because this was related to his original reason for standing for election. The prosecution questioned Lee on not having publicly said that he would not follow the party’s position. Lee confirmed this, but reiterated that legislators had previously voted differently from the party, and that if his application for an exemption from voting along the party line was not approved, he “would still vote according to my own intention”.
Lee also testified that Alvin Yeung had instructed him to register to stand in the Hong Kong Island direct election, and that he understood he was not Cheng Tat-hung’s “Plan B”. He said he had not asked the primary election organisers about the coordination consensus, and had only asked senior party members about the rules for the super-district constituency. He did not know how the consensus was related to the remarks at the party press conference. Separately, counsel representing Yau Wai-ming said that, following Yau’s latest instructions, she would testify, which was expected to take several days.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周一(21 日)展開第 110 天審訊,李予信開始接受控方盤問,控方引楊岳橋於公民黨記者會稱政府若不回應「五大訴求」,會否決每個法案及撥款,並稱為「莊嚴承諾」。
李稱,理解該承諾未必會兌現,而自己不會跟隨黨立場否決預算案,因與參選初衷有關。控方質疑,李沒公開提及不跟從黨立場;李確認沒有,但重申過往曾發生議員投票與黨不一致,而若屆時申豁免隨黨立場投票不獲批,「都會照跟自己嘅意向投票」。
李又供稱,曾獲楊岳橋指示報名參選港島區直選,並理解自己不是鄭達鴻的「Plan B」。他又指,沒向初選組織者查詢協調共識,僅向黨高層問及超區規則,不知共識與黨記者會的發言有何關聯。另外,余慧明代表大狀稱,獲余最新指示將會作供,料需時數天。
18 Aug 2023法庭線#8210
47人案|李予信稱街頭被捕後獲公民黨准出選 曾向譚文豪表達想爭取撥款
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” entered its 109th day on Friday (18th). Yue Shun Lee gave evidence for a second day, saying that after Wong Man-hyun decided not to contest the super-district constituency, the Civic Party sought someone to fill the vacancy. He applied, but the party rejected him because of funding and his chances of winning.
Li continued that after he was arrested in Causeway Bay on suspicion of unlawful assembly on the first anniversary of 12 June, the party said it had received donations and eventually approved him to represent it in the super-district primary. He ultimately lost with few votes and announced that he would not contest the general election (see the chronology table in the full article). Li said he did not take part in discussions about whether the party should sign “No Regrets After the Ink Is Cast”, or repost related posts, and that he did not mention rejecting the budget bill at the primary-election forum.
Li also said that before applying to contest the super-district seat, Jeremy Tam had asked about his intention to run. Li told Tam that he wanted to seek funding, which might differ from the Civic Party’s position of rejecting funding. Li considered Tam’s remarks at the time to imply that there was flexibility and that the matter could be dealt with after he successfully secured the nomination. The trial will continue next Monday.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周五(18 日)展開第 109 天審訊,李予信第二日作供,稱黃文萱不參選超區後,公民黨找人填補,而自己提出申請惟公民黨因資金及勝算而拒絕。
不過李續稱,自己於 6.12 一周年在銅鑼灣被指涉非法集結拘捕後,黨稱獲捐獻,終批准由他代表參與超區初選;他最後低票落敗,宣布不參加正選(時序請看內文表)。李稱,沒參與黨簽否〈墨落無悔〉的討論或轉發有關帖文,而在初選論壇上亦沒提及否決預算案。
李另提及,他申請參加超區前,譚文豪曾問他出選意向,李向譚提及他欲爭取撥款,與公民黨否決撥款的立場或有出入,認為譚當時說法,「言下之意」是有彈性、成功出線再算。案件下周一續審。
17 Aug 2023法庭線#8208
47人案|李予信:公民黨記者會有混合訊息 有人提否決所有撥款、有人似乎不會
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with conspiracy to subvert the state power entered its 108th day on Thursday (the 17th), when Yue Shun Lee, who had run in the super district council constituency in the primary election, began giving evidence. Yue Shun Lee said they had studied social work at The Chinese University of Hong Kong, became a social worker in 2019, and aspired to work in the community and with young people.
The prosecution said in its opening that Li had attended a Civic Party press conference in March 2020, at which Alvin Yeung mentioned vetoing every government bill and financial appropriation. Li testified that the speakers had conveyed “mixed messages”: Li heard Alvin Yeung and others talk about vetoing all funding, but Kwok Ka-ki appeared not to support vetoing all funding.
Li also testified that they met Cheng Tat-hung and others in 2016 while assisting with the Civic Party’s Legislative Council election campaign, and later joined the party and stood for election to the District Council after being lobbied by Cheng. Li was elected as an Eastern District councillor. Cheng later proposed that Li be placed second on his list for the 2020 Legislative Council election, but Li declined and subsequently stood in the super district council constituency under the party’s “drafting mechanism”. The trial will continue on Friday.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周四(17 日)展開第 108 天審訊,初選參選超區的李予信開始作供,稱修讀中大社工學系,2019 年成為社工,有志做社會、青年工作。
控方開案稱李有份出席 2020 年 3 月公民黨記者會,而楊岳橋發言提及否決每個政府議案、財政撥款。李供稱,發言者當時表達「混合訊息」,他聽到楊岳橋等人否決所有撥款的說法,但郭家麒的說法又似乎不會否決所有撥款。
李又供稱,2016 年因協助公民黨立會選舉而認識鄭達鴻等人,後獲鄭遊說入黨並出選區議會,並當選東區區議員。鄭曾提出 2020 年立會選舉時,李排其名單第二,惟李拒絕,李其後響應黨內「徵召機制」出選超區。案件周五續。
2 Mar 2023法庭線#6120
47人案|日前因李予信留院休庭 法官關注出院時間 控方讀出13被告承認事實
In the case involving 47 democrats charged with conspiracy to subvert state power, the court adjourned the trial after the defence said Yue Shun Lee had been injured while practising Muay Thai on Wednesday and was hospitalised. The 18th day of the trial began on Thursday (the 2nd). The defence said Yue Shun Lee had been discharged on Wednesday morning. The judge questioned whether public funds had been wasted; defence counsel said they had not known this at the time and said Lee apologised to the court.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,法庭因應辯方指李予信周三打泰拳受傷留院而押後審訊。案件周四(2 日)展開第 18 天審訊,辯方指李予信周三早上已出院,法官質疑浪費公帑;辯方大狀指當時並不知情,並指李向法庭致歉。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.