Complaint Against Judge Lin Kam-hung over Yellow-Mask Order and “Reporters Were Part of the Riot” Remark Not Upheld
涉逐戴黃口罩人士離庭、稱記者是「暴動一部份」 法官練錦鴻收投訴被裁不成立
Judge Lin Kam-hung of the District Court was complained against after, while hearing the 2019 Kowloon Bay Amoy Plaza unlawful assembly case last year, he required lawyers and observers wearing yellow masks to change them or leave the courtroom, and described reporters present as “part of the riot”. The Judiciary announced yesterday (20th) that its investigation found both complaints unsubstantiated. A panel of three High Court judges said the courtroom should not be used to express political demands, and that Judge Lin had provided alternative masks through the court clerk, while those who did not change their masks could continue observing the proceedings in an adjacent courtroom. The panel also found that Judge Lin was merely providing commentary for a video and had not intentionally targeted the media.
區院法官練錦鴻去年初審理2019年九龍灣淘大商場非法集結案時, 要求戴着黃色口罩的律師及旁聽人士更換口罩,否則須離開法庭,又形容現場記者是「暴動的一部份」,因此被投訴。司法機構昨日(20日)公布調查結果,裁定兩項投訴均不成立。由三位高院法官組成的專責小組指,法庭不應被用作表達政治訴求,而練官已透過書記提供替代口罩,不換口罩者可到毗鄰法庭繼續旁聽;小組又認為練官只是為影片提供解說,非故意針對傳媒。
