Man jailed 24 months for inciting wounding after posting “stab the small-intestine area”; leave to appeal sentence refused, judge says remarks were inciting
男子七一刺警案後留言「插小腸」煽惑傷人罪成囚24月 申刑期上訴許可遭拒 官指發言具教唆性
On the night of the 2021 July 1 police stabbing in Causeway Bay, a 23-year-old man was alleged to have posted comments on LIHKG including, “Next time, the part in the middle of the body where the small intestine is should be stabbed.” After trial, he was convicted of inciting another to wound with intent and sentenced to 24 months’ imprisonment. He applied for leave to appeal against the sentence. After a hearing in July this year, Court of Appeal judge Poon Man-ki dismissed the application on the same day, with the judgment handed down this Monday (25th). The judgment stated that the applicant’s sole ground of appeal was that, by adopting 24 months’ imprisonment as the sentencing starting point, the trial judge had failed to take proper account of the Court of Appeal’s judgment and the circumstances in the Cheung King-sang case, resulting in a sentence that was manifestly excessive. The judge rejected that argument, saying that comparing the relative seriousness of the two cases served little substantive purpose. She also noted that, just 12 minutes after the police officer was stabbed, the applicant had already posted his first comment, effectively “seizing the opportunity to encourage further attacks”, and had defiantly responded to others with remarks such as, “So you can’t even teach people where to stab?” The judge found that his comments were not made in jest, but were purpose-driven, graphic and brutal, and highly inciting in nature. The judgment held that the proposed ground of appeal was not reasonably arguable. The court also made a loss-of-time order. This means that the applicant may still renew his application for leave to appeal before the Court of Appeal, but if that application is ultimately refused, the Court of Appeal may order that some or all of the time he spends in custody pending determination of the appeal not count towards his sentence.
2021 年銅鑼灣七一刺警案當晚,23 歲男子被指在「連登」發布「下次應該插身體中間小腸嘅部位」等留言,經審訊後被裁定「煽惑他人有意圖而傷人」罪成,判監 24 個月。他不服判期提上訴許可申請,今年 7 月聆訊後,被上訴庭法官潘敏琦即日駁回,至本周一(25 日)頒判詞。 判詞指,申請方提出的唯一上訴理據,是指原審法官以判監 24 個月為量刑起點,忽略上訴庭就「張敬生案」的判詞及情節,判刑明顯過重。官於判詞反駁,指比較兩案嚴重性沒實質意義,又提到申請人在警員被刺後 12 分鐘,已發首個留言「乘勢狙擊」,且理直氣壯回應他人「教人點插都唔得呀」等,認為其留言並非開玩笑,而是「目標為本」、血腥兇殘、極具教唆性。 判詞稱上訴理據不具合理爭拗之處,另下達「減時命令」,即他有權再向上訴法庭提出上訴許可申請,但假如申請最終被駁回,上訴法庭有權命令他在聽候上訴裁定時間的扣押期,不計算在他所受刑罰的刑期之內。
