Man alleges police assault in station caused brain haemorrhage, sues for damages; bid to bar destruction of CCTV footage and disclose police information rejected
指警署內遭警打頭致腦出血、市民入稟索償 申禁警方銷毀CCTV片、披露警資料被拒
A man filed a claim against the Commissioner of Police last Wednesday (16), alleging that when he went to the report room at Mong Kok Police Station this month to complain about an officer’s rudeness, the officer instead said he would arrest him for criminal intimidation and struck the back of his head. He was later taken to hospital, where he was found to have suffered a brain haemorrhage. He is seeking 1.2 million in compensation from the police force. The case came back before the District Court on Friday (25). The man said the case involved a criminal offence and applied for an injunction to prohibit the police from destroying the police station’s closed-circuit television footage. He also sought disclosure of information about the officers and the CCTV footage, and indicated that he intended to bring a private prosecution. Judge Leung Kwok-on dismissed the plaintiff’s application, saying: “The court cannot force the government to do this or that, or not do this or that; the court does not have such power.” The judge also said that the plaintiff’s request for disclosure before the issues in dispute had been defined was “vague” and that he “cannot cast the net like a fisherman and take all the officers’ personal information”. The judge further said the case should be commenced as a personal injury claim rather than as an ordinary civil action. The case was adjourned to allow the plaintiff to consider whether to continue the proceedings or bring a separate case in another manner.
一名市民上周三(16 日)入稟控告警務處長,指本月赴旺角警署報案室,投訴警員不禮貌時,反遭警員稱要以刑事恐嚇罪拘捕,又拍打其後腦。男子送院後證實腦出血,民事入稟索償,要求警務處賠償 120 萬元。 案件周五(25 日)在區域法院再訊,男子指本案涉刑事罪行,因此申請禁制令,禁止警方銷毀警署閉路電視片段,又要求警方披露警員資料、閉路電視片段,另透露有意提出私人刑事檢控。 法官梁國安駁回原告申請,指「法庭唔可以強制政府做乜、唔做乜,法庭冇咁嘅權力」。官又指,在本案未定下爭議點時,原告便要求披露資料,是「虛無飄渺」,「唔可以咁漁翁撒網,攞晒警員個人資料」。官又提到,案件應以「人身傷亡」而非一般民事訴訟立案。官押後案件,待原告考慮是否繼續提控,或會否其他方式另立案件等。
