HONG KONG · NEWS RECORDS

Search the archive

Explore news reporting in English and traditional Chinese.

Results JSON

Statistics

13matching records

of 7107 in this collection

Records over time

Monthly distribution

0
Feb 20
0
Mar 20
0
Apr 20
0
May 20
0
Jun 20
1
Jul 20
0
Aug 20
0
Sep 20
0
Oct 20
0
Nov 20
0
Dec 20
0
Jan 21
0
Feb 21
0
Mar 21
0
Apr 21
0
May 21
0
Jun 21
0
Jul 21
0
Aug 21
1
Sep 21
0
Oct 21
0
Nov 21
0
Dec 21
0
Jan 22
0
Feb 22
0
Mar 22
0
Apr 22
0
May 22
0
Jun 22
0
Jul 22
0
Aug 22
0
Sep 22
0
Oct 22
0
Nov 22
0
Dec 22
0
Jan 23
0
Feb 23
0
Mar 23
0
Apr 23
0
May 23
0
Jun 23
10
Jul 23
0
Aug 23
0
Sep 23
0
Oct 23
0
Nov 23
0
Dec 23
0
Jan 24
0
Feb 24
0
Mar 24
0
Apr 24
0
May 24
0
Jun 24
0
Jul 24
0
Aug 24
0
Sep 24
0
Oct 24
1
Nov 24
0
Dec 24
0
Jan 25
0
Feb 25
0
Mar 25
0
Apr 25
0
May 25
0
Jun 25
0
Jul 25
0
Aug 25
0
Sep 25
0
Oct 25
0
Nov 25
0
Dec 25
About this collection

14 Feb 2020 - 24 Dec 2025

English translations accompany the original Chinese records.

Results 13

何桂藍Clear all
Showing 1-10 of 13 recordsEN
29 Nov 2024法庭線#4309

47-person case | Ho Kwai-lam files appeal; no hearing date yet; fifth not-guilty defendant to appeal

47人案|何桂藍提上訴 暫未有聆訊日期 至今共5不認罪被告提上訴

Forty-five of the 47 defendants in the pro-democracy primary election case who were convicted were sentenced last Tuesday to between four years and two months and 10 years in prison. High Court records on Friday (29th) showed that Ho Kwai-lam, who was convicted after trial, had also appealed against her conviction and sentence, making her the fifth defendant in the case to lodge an appeal. The records did not yet indicate whether she had legal representation. The four defendants who earlier this week filed appeals against their convictions and sentences had also pleaded not guilty and were convicted after trial: Zau Ka-ching, Wong Pik-wan, Yeung Suet-ying and Yu Wai-ming. The Judiciary’s website had not yet listed a hearing date.

民主派初選 47 人案上周二判刑,45 名罪成被告被判囚 4 年 2 個月至 10 年。本周五(29 日)高院資料顯示,審訊後被裁定罪成的何桂藍亦提出定罪及刑期上訴,是案中第五名提出上訴的被告,暫未顯示她有否律師代表。 本周較早時已提出定罪及刑期上訴的 4 人,亦為不認罪、受審後罪成,包括鄒家成、黃碧雲、楊雪盈及余慧明。司法機構網頁暫未顯示聆訊日期。

31 Jul 2023法庭線#8112

47-defendant case | Gwyneth Ho completes 10 days of testimony, at one point questions prosecution’s questioning as “a waste of time”

47人案|何桂藍完成10日作供 一度質疑控方提問「好嘥時間」

The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with conspiracy to subvert state power entered its 95th day on Monday (the 31st). Gwyneth Ho completed a total of 10 days of testimony. Another defendant, Ray Chan, who planned to stand for election in New Territories East, is expected to testify on Tuesday. In outlining the prosecution’s case, the prosecution said Ho and the other defendants conspired to indiscriminately veto the budget. Ho said there were only three circumstances in which she would vote indiscriminately: when legislators were not allowed to debate and had to vote directly; when officials were not questioned; and a third situation, “when Ting Kwong Wong simply fell asleep in the chamber and didn’t watch”. The prosecution also cited statements made by defendants including Shum Ngo-wai and Wong Pak-yu at press conferences held by the protest camp, and asked whether Ho had publicly clarified that the speakers did not represent her. Ho at one point questioned whether the line of questioning was “a waste of time”. Judge Andrew Hing Wai Chan said that if the court considered something a waste of time, it would interrupt. Ho replied, “Your time is time, but my time isn’t time, OK!” Judge Lee Yuen-tung told Ho to remain calm. Ho said, “I have never been agitated,” and added, “I don’t think that seizing on one or two words in court can be used to say that this was everyone’s understanding.”

47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周一(31 日)展開第 95 天審訊,何桂藍完成共 10 日作供,料參選新東區的另一被告陳志全周二作供。 控方指出案情時,稱何與其他被告串謀無差別否決預算案。何稱只有 3 個情況會無差別投票,包括議員不獲批准辯論要直接表決、官員沒被質詢、還有一種情況,「就係好似黃定光直情喺議會度瞓咗無睇」。 另外,控方引述岑敖暉、王百羽等被告在抗爭派記者會上發言,問何有否對外澄清發言者不代表她。何一度質疑問題「好嘥時間」,法官陳慶偉指,若法庭覺得浪費時間便會打斷,何覆,「你時間係時間,我時間唔係時間,ok!」法官李運騰著何冷靜,何則指「我從來都無激動過」,又稱「我唔認為喺法庭捉住一、兩隻字,就可以話係大家嘅認知」。

28 Jul 2023法庭線#8101

47-case | Gwyneth Ho says budget must inevitably reflect the “five demands”; voting it down regardless of content “doesn’t make sense”

47人案|何桂藍稱預算案必然反映「五大訴求」 不論內容都否決「係講唔通」

The trial of 47 democrats charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” entered its 94th day on Friday (the 28th). During questioning by the prosecution, Gwyneth Ho volunteered that she believed the most important of the “five demands” was dual universal suffrage, “because once you have dual universal suffrage, the other things can gradually be resolved.” She also said that the budget’s departmental expenditure and work plans would inevitably reflect the “five demands”. For example, if the government withdrew its characterisation of the 2019 protests as riots, the Department of Justice’s budget should be reduced. She said she agreed that legislators had the right to reject the budget on the basis of political demands, but that rejecting it regardless of its contents “doesn’t make sense”. The prosecution cited remarks by Leung Wong-wai, Shum Ngou-fai and others at a press conference held by the protest camp in which they referred to “us”, and asked whether this included Ho. Asked whether the public would understand Leung’s use of “us” to include her, Ho said “you could put it that way”. Regarding Shum’s related remarks, Ho said, “that’s what Mr Shum believes,” and said that his reference to “the position of the 16 of us here” meant opposition to the National Security Law and other matters.

47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周五(28 日)展開第 94 天審訊,何桂藍接受控方盤問時,主動稱認為「五大訴求」之中最重要是雙普選,「因為有咗雙普選,其他嘢都可以慢慢解決嘅」。 她又指,預算案的部門開支及工作計劃,必然反映「五大訴求」,例如若政府撤回暴動定性,律政司預算應會減少。她稱,認同議員有權基於政治訴求而否決預算案,惟不論內容都否決「係講唔通嘅」。 控方引抗爭派記者會上,梁晃維、岑敖暉等發言提及「我哋」,指是否包括何。對於外界會認為梁稱「我哋」是包括她,何稱「可以咁講」;而就岑的相關發言,何稱「呢個係岑生相信嘅」,又指岑提及「咁我哋呢度 16 人嘅立場」一句,是指反對《國安法》等。

27 Jul 2023法庭線#8082

47-person case | Gwyneth Ho completes examination-in-chief, says protest camp press conference had no spokesperson and common-law court should not accept mainland logic

47人案|何桂藍完成主問 指抗爭派記者會沒發言人、普通法法庭不應接受大陸邏輯

The 47 democrats charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” began the 93rd day of trial on Thursday (27th), with Gwyneth Ho completing her testimony after eight days of examination-in-chief. Her counsel cited remarks by Lester Shum and Wong Pak-yu at a press conference held by the protest camp concerning vetoing the budget. Ho said the press conference had no official spokesperson, and that the content of the two men’s remarks had not been discussed beforehand. Ho also testified that the Returning Officer had disqualified her from standing for election on the grounds that she opposed the National Security Law. “But anyone who reads the [National Security Law] normally would feel that the entire Basic Law has been hollowed out,” she said. The judge subsequently interrupted her, saying she had already answered that she disagreed with the Returning Officer’s decision and there was no need to pursue the matter further. Ho also denied the prosecution’s allegation that she intended to subvert state power. She said, “I can understand why, under the logic in mainland China, this would be subversion ... but if a common-law court endorses this, I think it is destroying common law.” The trial will continue on Friday.

47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周四(27 日)展開第 93 天審訊,何桂藍完成合共 8 日主問下作供。其代表大狀引述岑敖暉、王百羽於抗爭派記者會,提及否決預算案,何指記者會沒正式發言人,而事前亦沒討論過兩人發言的內容。 何作供時又提到,選舉主任指她反對《國安法》而取消其參選資格,「但係一個正常睇完(國安法)嘅人會覺得,成份《基本法》係(被)架空咗囉」,法官其後打斷,指她已回答不同意選舉主任的決定,毋須再深究。 何亦否認控方所指,她有意圖顛覆國家政權,稱 「我可以理解點解喺中國大陸嘅 logic,咁樣係顛覆嘅...但係如果一個普通法嘅 court endorse(贊同)呢樣嘢,我覺得係攬炒緊普通法囉」。審訊周五續。

26 Jul 2023法庭線#8080

47-defendants case | Gwyneth Ho says she had estimated the government would disqualify pro-democracy candidates on a large scale; 610,000 primary voters was unimaginable beforehand

47人案|何桂藍稱曾估計政府會大規模DQ 初選61萬港人投票是事前無人能想像

The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” entered its 92nd day on Wednesday (26th), with Gwyneth Ho giving evidence for a seventh day. Regarding a Facebook post in July 2020 mentioning “using the Legislative Council election to trigger a constitutional crisis”, Ho said she had estimated that Beijing or the Hong Kong government might disqualify pro-democracy candidates on a large scale. She said this would be tantamount to declaring that Hong Kong’s elections were no different from those in Iran, creating a crisis of legitimacy. The court played footage of Ho at a street booth on the first day of voting in the primary, in which she referred to “the possibility that the protests could initiate truly historic change”. Ho explained that this meant Hong Kong people, after 2019, had consciously pursued democracy, that it could not remain safe forever, and that they could not avoid the inability to maintain the status quo or the need to enter the contest themselves. She said that a change in people’s minds was “what truly makes change possible”. Ho also volunteered that, when asked why she had still chosen to run for the Legislative Council if she believed it was useless, she had been unable to answer at the time. It was not until she saw 610,000 Hong Kong people vote in the primary that she said she encountered a situation nobody could have imagined. She added that political action differs from a legal setting in which “the result, cause, venue and motive are all very clear”, and that its meaning can only possibly be found after it has been carried out.

47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周三(26 日)展開第 92 天審訊,何桂藍第七日作供,就 2020 年 7 月在 Facebook 提及「利用立法會選舉,觸發憲政危機」,何稱當時估計北京或港府會大規模 DQ 民主派候選人,「無異於宣稱香港嘅選舉係同伊朗無乜分別」,造成合法性危機。 庭上播放何於初選首日投票的街站片段,她提及「抗爭開啟真正歷史性變革嘅可能性」。何解釋是指港人 2019 年後有意識追求民主不可能永遠安全,亦不能迴避無法維持現狀及要自己落場,指人心改變「先至真正令到變革有可能發生。」 何又主動供稱,就既然認為立法會無用為何仍要參選的問題,自己當時回答不到,直至看到初選有 61 萬港人投票,指是無人能想像的局面,又稱政治行動有別於「好清楚咁有結果有原因有場所有動機」的法律場合,是在進行後才有可能找到意義。審訊

25 Jul 2023法庭線#8076

47 democrats case | Gwyneth Ho says calling the Chinese Communist Party “totalitarian” is an academic consensus; Hong Kong people do not want to live under a regime’s control in every aspect

47人案|何桂藍稱「中共是極權」為學界共識、港人不想活在政權方方面面控制下

The 91st day of the trial in the case of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” began on Tuesday (25th). In court, Gwyneth Ho explained her reference at a New Territories East primary election forum to “fighting the Chinese Communist Party’s totalitarianism together with all Hong Kong people”, saying that describing the Chinese Communist Party as totalitarian was “an academic consensus”. The judge at one point asked Ho’s leading counsel about the definition of “totalitarianism” and whether Japan and Russia were totalitarian, saying that the court was concerned with what Ho thought at the time rather than with an academic definition. Ho subsequently reiterated that she agreed calling the Chinese Communist Party totalitarian “is an objective description ... whether it is praise or criticism is irrelevant”, saying the key point was that Hong Kong people did not want to live “under the regime’s control in every aspect”. Ho also explained a Facebook post concerning “laam chau”, saying that the term as used in public discussion at the time had an element of self-destruction, with “a strong emphasis on sacrifice and death”. She said, however, that “protest is not about seeking death, but seeking survival”. She also disagreed with Au Nok-hin’s earlier description of “laam chau” as despair, saying that this view “erased the creativity of the 2019 [movement]”.

47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周二(25 日)展開第 91 天審訊,何桂藍庭上解釋在新東初選論壇提及的「同全香港人一齊抗擊中共極權」,稱形容中共是極權是「學界共識」。 法官一度問何的代表大狀對「極權」定義、日本及俄國是否極權,並指法庭是關注何當時的想法,而不是學術定義。何其後重申,同意形容中共是極權「係一個客觀嘅描述...褒義貶義呢啲無關係嘅」,指關鍵是香港人不想活在「方方面面受到政權控制之下」。 何另解釋有關「攬炒」的 FB 帖文時,指當時輿論所指的「攬炒」有一種自毀傾向,「好強調犧牲,好強調死」,但她認為「抗爭唔係求死,係求生」。她又指,不同意區諾軒早前稱「攬炒」是絕望,指有關說法「抹殺咗 2019(運動)嘅創造性」。

24 Jul 2023法庭線#8066

47-case | Ho Kwai-lam explains election manifesto, saying she would not accept Hong Kong’s destruction to preserve “freedom built on shifting sands”

47人案|何桂藍解釋參選宣言 稱不因留住「浮沙上自由」接受香港被破壞現狀

The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with conspiracy to subvert state power entered its 90th day on Monday (24th). Ho Kwai-lam explained her election manifesto, saying many Hong Kong people had imagined that the status quo could be maintained, but she would not accept a Hong Kong that appeared prosperous while being continually destroyed in reality merely to preserve “privilege and freedom built on shifting sands”. “I would describe this as the choice of everyone who took part in the 2019 movement,” she said. She also said the primary-election forums allowed pro-democracy candidates to debate their political paths and voters to make a choice after understanding them. She said there were many voices in society at the time calling for the pro-democracy camp to remain united and finding the 《墨落無悔》 statement very troublesome. “But I disagree. I believe that what is called ‘yellow-on-yellow rivalry’ was actually a very important debate over political paths.” When a judge asked whether the primary had wasted time and money, Ho said she strongly disagreed. The judge interrupted her at one point, saying she would be allowed to answer on matters relevant to the case. Ho questioned the judge’s understanding of the Legislative Council, saying, “How do you distinguish what is relevant from what is irrelevant?” The judge said he knew how to determine what was relevant and added that even if there were mistakes, it was not for Ho to correct them.

47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周一(24 日)展開第 90 天審訊,何桂藍解釋其參選宣言,指很多港人幻想能維持現狀,但認為不會因想留住「建立喺浮沙上面嘅 privilege 同自由」,而接受香港表面繁榮但實際不斷被破壞的現狀,「我會形容呢個係所有參與 2019 運動嘅人嘅選擇」。 她又稱,認為初選論壇讓民主派辯論路線,讓選民了解後作出選擇,當時坊間很多聲音好想民主派團結一致,又覺得〈墨落無悔〉聲明爭議好煩,「但我唔同意嘅,我認為所謂嘅『鬥黃』,其實係啲好重要嘅路線 debate 嚟嘅。」 法官問及,初選是否浪費時間和金錢,何稱非常不同意該說法,法官一度打斷何回答,指與案有關會讓她回答,何質疑官對立法會理解不足,「你點樣分咩係 relevant 咩係唔 relevant!」法官則稱懂得判斷甚麼是有關,又指即使有錯都不是由何糾正。

21 Jul 2023法庭線#8058

47 Democrats case | Gwyneth Ho says she agrees that “the legislature is by no means the end point of resistance”, explaining that she did not want to give the public false hope

47人案|何桂藍稱認同「議會絕非抗爭終點」 解釋指不欲予民眾假希望

The trial of 47 democrats charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” entered its 89th day on Friday (the 21st). Gwyneth Ho testified that she agreed with the line “deeply understand that the legislature is by no means the end point of resistance” in *Ink-Stained Without Regret*, saying she did not want to give the public false hope “that they would think the Legislative Council could really directly force the government”. She said this was an ingrained tendency of Hong Kong’s democracy movement, creating the impression that “everything would be OK once you had voted”, and that she wanted to convey that other forms of resistance should continue to be attempted. Ho also said she did not believe that rejecting the budget could force the Chief Executive to respond to the “five demands”, saying it could at most exert pressure. However, she said the Legislative Council had many powers, giving “calling for a quorum count” as an example of how pressure could be exerted. During examination-in-chief, Ho responded to the prosecution’s allegations. Referring to the four criteria set out by CFA Non-Permanent Judge Justice Kemal Bokhary, she said her earlier description of Hong Kong as having “no rule of law” was “accurate”. She also said she agreed that many people resented the government, that no one needed to encourage them to do so, and that it could not be assumed that their resentment lacked a rational basis or was necessarily incited by others. Ho also rejected the protest camp’s description of *Ink* as “forcing people together”, saying the pressure came from voters’ wishes rather than the protest camp. The trial will continue next Monday.

47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周五(21 日)展開第 89 天審訊,何桂藍供稱認同〈墨落無悔〉中「深明議會絕非抗爭終點」一句,指因不欲給予民眾假希望,「令佢哋覺得立法會真係可以直接逼使到政府」,她指這是香港民主運動的慣性,「造成投咗票就 OK 嘅感覺」,並想帶出其他形式的抗爭都要繼續嘗試。 何又稱,不認為否決預算案可逼特首回應「五大訴求」,認為最多只可施壓,惟立法會有很多權力,舉例指「點人數」亦能施壓。 何在主問下回應控方指控,引終院非常任法官包致金的 4 項準則指自己曾提及的香港「法治無存」,是「準確描述」,又指同意很多人怨恨政府,毋須任何人助長,亦不能假設怨恨背後沒理性基礎,或者一定由他人煽動。何亦反駁抗爭派用〈墨〉「夾人」的說法,認為壓力是來自選民意願,而非抗爭派。審訊下周一續。

20 Jul 2023法庭線#8041

47-case | Gwyneth Ho admits backing “would use” wording on veto power; says she felt ashamed after hearing Owen Chow speak

47人案|何桂藍承認支持採「會運用」否決權字眼 稱聞鄒家成發言感慚愧

The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” entered its 88th day on Thursday (the 20th). Gwyneth Ho testified that she understood the wording written by Benny Tai about veto power to mean that the power included vetoing the budget, but did not necessarily mean that it had to be used to veto it. “Simply put, he [Tai] wrote a sentence that basically said nothing at all,” she said, adding that whether the wording referred to actively using the power or would use it was not very important. Ho also testified that Owen Chow proposed at a New Territories East meeting that the wording should be “would use”, and that she felt “a bit ashamed” after hearing Chow speak. She said Chow, from the perspective of an ordinary person or protester, would intuitively think that “if it is to be done, then it should be stated more firmly”. She admitted that she had supported Chow by speaking up for him and backed the wording “would use”. Ho further said she had not seen Lam Cheuk-ting, Alvin Yeung or two other people during the New Territories East coordination process, and found this strange. She said she had originally thought there would be opportunities to communicate and understand the various parties’ positions on the agreed matters. Ho, who gave evidence in Cantonese, at one point argued with the judge over the court’s English interpretation and told the judge, “May I ask you to listen carefully”. She said that as the charge could carry life imprisonment, she hoped the court would not conclude that she was “arguing for the sake of arguing”.

47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周四(20 日)展開第 88 天審訊,何桂藍供稱,理解戴耀廷寫否決權的字句,是指權力包括否決預算案,但不一定要否決,「簡單嚟講,佢(戴)寫咗句根本乜都無講過嘢出嚟」,故認為積極抑或會運用不太重要。 何又供稱,鄒家成在新東會議上提出採「會運用」,而她聽鄒的發言後「有啲慚愧」,認為鄒從普通人或抗爭者角度,會直觀地認為「如果要做嘅話就講得 firm(確切)啲」。她承認,曾為鄒「幫口」,支持採「會運用」字眼。 何另指,新東協調過程沒見過林卓廷、楊岳橋等 4 人,對過程感奇怪,稱原以為會有機會溝通,了解各黨派對同意事項的立場。以廣東話作供的何,一度就法庭英譯與法官爭論,向官稱「May I ask you to listen carefully」,她指因控罪可囚終身,望法庭勿認定她「為拗而拗」。

19 Jul 2023法庭線#8033

47-case | Gwyneth Ho testifies on reasons for running in Legislative Council election, saying it was a necessary route to secure a mandate for the movement and bring its spirit into elections

47人案|何桂藍供述參選立會原因 稱屬為運動取授權必行之路、欲將精神帶入選舉

The 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” began the 87th day of trial on Wednesday (19th). Gwyneth Ho gave evidence for the second day, saying that while working as a journalist covering Legislative Council news, she had already believed that the budget needed to be vetoed because the Capital Works Reserve Fund within it could not be debated. She described it as a “fiscal black hole” and said that, in such circumstances, opposing it was the constitutional duty of a legislator.

47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周三(19 日)展開第 87 天審訊,何桂藍第二日作供,稱任職記者跟進立法會新聞時,已認為需要否決預算案,因當中的基本工程儲備基金不能討論,形容為「財政黑洞」,認為此情況下反對才是履行議員的憲制責任。

Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.