20 Dec 2024法庭線#4376
反恐第二案|次被告一方盤問下 另一O記警員否認以女友安危威脅、逼招認
In early 2020, explosives were found at Caritas Medical Centre and in a Lo Wu MTR carriage. The Telegram channel “92 Sign"(九十二籤) subsequently claimed responsibility. Seven people were charged with offences under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, while one remaining defendant was charged with “attempting to manufacture explosives”. All eight pleaded not guilty, and the trial at the High Court entered its 21st day on Friday (20th). The prosecution continued calling Detective Police Constable Wan Man-king to give evidence. Wan said he identified the second defendant, Lee Ka-pan, from CCTV footage based on his gait, appearance, eyebrows, clothing and backpack. He described the area “from the brow towards the centre” as darker, adding that “it appeared to form a V-shape”.
Under cross-examination by counsel for the first defendant, Wan confirmed that police had identified the Telegram group “92 Sign” during their investigation in March 2020.
During cross-examination by Lee’s counsel, the defence pointed out that Wan had told Lee, “We’ve arrested your girlfriend as well”, and suggested that Wan had used concerns over his girlfriend’s safety to threaten Lee and force him to confess. Wan denied the allegation.
The trial will continue next Monday.
2020 年初,明愛醫院、羅湖港鐵車廂被發現有爆炸品,Telegram 頻道「九十二籤」事後承認責任。7人被控《反恐條例》罪名,餘下 1 人被控以「企圖製造炸藥」罪。8 人不認罪,周五(20 日)於高院踏入第 21 天審訊。
控方續傳召偵緝警員溫文鏡,溫從 CCTV 片段認出次被告李嘉濱,稱從其步姿、外貌、眉、衣著、背囊確認,形容李的「眉頭至中間比較深色」、「感覺上會呈 V 字型」。
溫在首被告一方盤問下,確認警方在 2020 年 3 月調查到 Telegram 群組「九十二籤」。而李一方盤問時指出,溫曾經向李稱「你女朋友都俾我哋拉埋」,質疑溫以女友安危威脅李,逼他招認。溫否認。審訊下周一續。
19 Dec 2024法庭線#4373
反恐第二案|次被告手機經WeChat購鎂粉、鋁粉 警員指憑被告步姿獨特認人
In early 2020, explosives were found at Caritas Medical Centre and in a Lo Wu MTR train carriage. The Telegram channel “九十二籤” subsequently claimed responsibility. Seven people were charged with offences under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, while the remaining person was charged with attempting to manufacture explosives. All eight pleaded not guilty, and the trial at the High Court entered its 20th day on Thursday (19th).
The prosecution continued calling the police officer who seized the two mobile phones of second defendant Lee Ka-ban. Contents extracted from the phones were shown in court, indicating that the owner had made enquiries about and purchased magnesium powder, aluminium powder and iron powder through WeChat. A payment of $1,500 was made through Alipay, with the courier recipient listed as “Mr Lee”.
The officer also testified that he spent seven months reviewing CCTV footage in the case and identified Lee from his appearance and gait. The prosecution showed CCTV footage from Caritas Medical Centre. The officer said Lee’s gait was distinctive—“one hand would swing from side to side, giving him the air of a chancellor”—and that this enabled him to recognise Lee. The trial will continue on Friday.
2020 年初,明愛醫院、羅湖港鐵車廂被發現有爆炸品,Telegram 頻道「九十二籤」事後承認責任。7人被控《反恐條例》罪名,餘下 1 人被控以「企圖製造炸藥」罪。8 人不認罪,周四(19 日)於高院踏入第 20 天審訊。
控方續傳召檢取次被告李嘉濱兩部手機的警員,並展示警方擷取的手機內容,顯示機主曾透過 WeChat 查詢及購買鎂粉、鋁粉、鐵粉,透過支付寶支付 1,500 元下單,快遞收件人為「李生」。
警員另供稱花 7 個月檢視涉案閉路電視片段,從李的外型、步姿等確認其身分。控方展示明愛醫院的閉路電視片段,警員指李的步姿獨特,「隻手會左右揈嘅,好似個丞相嘅感覺」,因此認出是李。審訊周五續。
18 Dec 2024法庭線#4372
反恐第二案|警員確認次被告兩手機入證物袋沒封存 親自保管兩天 從沒干擾
In early 2020, explosives were found at Caritas Medical Centre and in an MTR train carriage at Lo Wu. The Telegram channel “Ninety-Two Divinations” later claimed responsibility. Seven people were charged with offences under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, while the remaining person was charged with “attempting to manufacture explosives”. All eight pleaded not guilty, and the trial at the High Court entered its 19th day on Wednesday (18th). The prosecution called an Organised Crime and Triad Bureau officer who was responsible for questioning and searching the second defendant, Lee Ka-pan. The officer testified that after finding two mobile phones on Lee, he placed them in anti-interference evidence bags. However, because he believed the phones “might be needed for investigative purposes later”, he did not seal the bags and kept the phones in his own custody for two days. They were only sealed when they were sent to the Cyber Security and Technology Crime Bureau for examination. He testified that he had never interfered with either phone.
The court was shown the fourth video-recorded interview. During the interview, Lee provided the passcode to unlock his phone and opened the Telegram application. One of the groups contained a video alleged to show a test explosion of a bomb. The officer twice asked Lee whether he was willing to allow police to examine the contents of his phone, and Lee replied, “Yes.”
2020 年初,明愛醫院、羅湖港鐵車廂被發現有爆炸品,Telegram 頻道「九十二籤」事後承認責任。7 人被控《反恐條例》罪名,餘下 1 人被控以「企圖製造炸藥」罪。8 人不認罪,周三(18 日)於高院踏入第 19 天審訊。
控方傳召負責查問及搜查次被告李嘉濱的 O 記警員作供,他供稱搜出李身上兩部手機後,放在防干擾證物袋,但因為相信「稍後會有啲調查用途」而沒封存,並親自保管兩天,直至送往網罪科檢驗時才封存。他供稱從沒干擾兩部手機。
庭上播放第四次錄影會面,李嘉濱提供密碼解鎖手機並打開 Telegram 應用程式,一個群組內有被指是試爆炸彈的影片,警員兩度詢問李是否願意供警方查看手機內容,李回答「願意」。
17 Dec 2024法庭線#4365
反恐第二案|辯方質疑涉案行車記錄儀「被植入」踩線片段 警員:唔可以確定
In early 2020, explosives were found at Caritas Medical Centre and in a Lo Wu MTR train carriage. The Telegram channel “Ninety-Two Fortune Sticks” later claimed responsibility. Seven people were charged with offences under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, while the remaining person was charged with “attempting to manufacture explosives”. All eight pleaded not guilty, and the trial entered its 18th day at the High Court on Tuesday (17th).
According to the prosecution’s case, second defendant Lee Ka-ban and a man drove to Tseung Kwan O to conduct reconnaissance while planning to place bombs. The prosecution called police officers who arrested the driver and seized the dashcam involved to give evidence on the entire evidence-collection process; all said they had not interfered with the evidence.
The defence said footage on the dashcam’s memory card suddenly jumped from 2017 to 2020, and questioned whether the relevant reconnaissance footage had been planted. A Cyber Crime Unit officer responsible for extracting the footage said the possibility “cannot be ruled out” and reiterated that he had never interfered with the evidence. The trial will resume on Wednesday.
2020 年初,明愛醫院、羅湖港鐵車廂被發現有爆炸品,Telegram 頻道「九十二籤」事後承認責任。7 人被控《反恐條例》罪名,餘下 1 人被控以「企圖製造炸藥」罪。8 人不認罪,周二(17 日)於高院踏入第 18 天審訊。
控方案情指次被告李嘉濱與一名男子駕駛到將軍澳「踩線」,策劃放置炸彈。控方傳召拘捕司機、檢取涉案行車記錄儀的警員,舉證整個取證過程,全部均稱沒有干擾證物。
辯方指記錄儀的記憶卡內的片段,由 2017 年突然跳到 2020 年,質疑涉案「踩線」片段是被植入。負責擷取片段的網罪案科警員稱「唔可以確定」可能性,重申不曾干擾證物。審訊周三續。
16 Dec 2024法庭線#4362
反恐第二案|辯方指警搜屋時「放下物品」、要求次被告認管有硝酸鉀等 警否認
In early 2020, explosives were found at Caritas Medical Centre and in a Lo Wu MTR train carriage. The Telegram channel “Ninety-Two Lots” subsequently claimed responsibility. Seven people were charged with offences under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance, while one remaining person was charged with “attempting to manufacture explosives”. All eight pleaded not guilty, and the trial at the High Court entered its 17th day on Monday (16th).
The defence said that when police officers took second defendant Lee Ka-ban to search the flat involved in the case in Tai Kok Tsui, a person claiming to be a lawyer wished to speak to Lee but was blocked by police. The officer responsible for escorting Lee denied this, saying that his superior dealt with the group at the time, and that the superior later said: “He is a lawyer; it has already been dealt with.” He testified that “dealt with” meant that the lawyer’s enquiries had been answered.
The defence also said that the officer asked Lee to admit that he had falsely reported his address, so that police would not discover potassium nitrate, metal powder and other substances inside the flat. Lee allegedly said, “There’s no such thing inside [the flat],” while the officer said, “We’ll deal with it.” During the search, the officer allegedly placed some items in a plastic bag inside the flat, and later said during a recorded interview that the bag contained potassium nitrate, metal powder and sulphur. The officer denied all of these allegations. The trial will continue on Tuesday (17th), when the next witness will be called.
2020 年初,明愛醫院、羅湖港鐵車廂被發現有爆炸品,Telegram 頻道「九十二籤」事後承認責任。7 人被控《反恐條例》罪名,餘下 1 人被控以「企圖製造炸藥」罪。8 人不認罪,周一(16 日)於高院踏入第 17 天審訊。
辯方指,在警員帶次被告李嘉濱,到大角咀涉案單位搜查時,有自稱律師的人希望接觸李,但遭警方阻擋。負責押解李的警員否認,指當時由上級處理該批人,事後上級表示:「係律師,已經處理咗。」他供稱「處理」是指已經回答律師的查詢。
辯方又指,警員要求李承認虛報地址,以免警方發現單位內的硝酸鉀、金屬粉等物,李當時稱「(單位)入面冇啲咁嘅嘢」,警員則表示「我哋會搞㗎喇」,並在搜屋時,把一些物品放入單位內一個膠袋,之後在錄影會面時,指膠袋內有硝酸鉀、金屬粉、硫磺。警員一概否認。審訊周二(17 日)續,將傳召下一名證人。
13 Dec 2024法庭線#4357
反恐第二案|辯方指警員稱「差館都有過強姦案」以女友威脅次被告配合 警否認
In early 2020, explosives were found at Caritas Hospital and in an MTR carriage at Lo Wu. The Telegram channel “Ninety-Two Lots” later claimed responsibility. Seven people were charged with offences under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, while the remaining person was charged with “attempting to manufacture explosives”. All eight pleaded not guilty, and the trial at the High Court entered its 16th day on Friday (13th). The defence continued its cross-examination of a police officer who had conducted a video-recorded interview with the second defendant, Lee Ka-pan. The defence alleged that, before the interview, the officer told Lee to “think about how to take the rap for Ng Fei”, and also told him that his girlfriend had been arrested, threatening him by saying: “There have been rape cases at police stations before. We have plenty of rooms without CCTV. You decide for yourself.”
The defence argued that Lee, in order to protect his girlfriend’s safety, had no choice but to follow the officer’s instructions on how to answer questions.
Lee was also accused of giving police a false address and was charged with perverting the course of justice. The defence put forward a different version of events, saying that Lee had told officers he had already moved out, but the officers did not believe him and accused him of “putting on an act”, while insisting that he enter the building’s access code. The officer denied this account.
The trial will continue next Monday.
2020 年初,明愛醫院、羅湖港鐵車廂被發現有爆炸品,Telegram 頻道「九十二籤」事後承認責任。7 人被控《反恐條例》罪名,餘下 1 人被控以「企圖製造炸藥」罪。8 人不認罪,周五(13 日)於高院踏入第 16 天審訊。
辯方繼續盤問與次被告李嘉濱進行錄影會面的警員,指警員在會面前著李「自己諗下點隊五飛」,又指已拘捕李的女友,威嚇稱「差館都有過強姦案,我哋大把房冇 CCTV,你自己決定」。辯方指,李為了保障女友的安全,惟有接受警員指示他如何回答提問。
李另被指向警員虛報地址,被控意圖妨礙司法公正。辯方指出另一版本,指李曾稱已搬走,但警員不相信,並斥李「扮嘢」,堅持要求他輸入大門密碼。警員亦否認。審訊下周一續。
12 Dec 2024法庭線#4355
反恐第二案|辯方指警叉頸等脅迫指證「五飛」 迫令交手機密碼 警員一概否認
In early 2020, explosives were found at Caritas Medical Centre and in a Lo Wu MTR train carriage. The Telegram channel “Ninety-Two Divinations” subsequently claimed responsibility. Seven people were charged with offences under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, while one other person was charged with “attempting to manufacture explosives”. All eight pleaded not guilty, and the trial at the High Court entered its 15th day on Thursday (12th).
Police officers who arrested and questioned the second defendant, Lee Ka-ban, began being cross-examined by the defence. The defence said that during the arrest, police carried Li deep into a back alley, put him in a neck hold and pushed him against a wall. They allegedly persuaded Li to testify against Ng Fei in exchange for a reduced sentence, punched him forcefully in the abdomen, and threatened him, saying: “We have arrested your girlfriend too. If you want her to be all right, you know what to do,” and “Whatever I tell you to admit, you have to admit.” Li subsequently admitted under duress that he had participated in the explosives case at Caritas Medical Centre at the direction of Ng Fei.
The defence also said that an officer had exposed his gun holster and demanded Li’s phone password, leaving Li with no choice but to comply. In addition, the defence said the officer’s 2020 statement indicated that the duty officer had discovered Li’s injuries, but that he had told the court in recent days that he himself had discovered them, suggesting an attempt to create the impression that he was not responsible for causing the injuries. The officer denied all the defence allegations in court. The trial will continue on Friday.
2020 年初,明愛醫院、羅湖港鐵車廂被發現有爆炸品,Telegram 頻道「九十二籤」事後承認責任。7 人被控《反恐條例》罪名,餘下 1 人被控以「企圖製造炸藥」罪。8 人不認罪,周四(12 日)於高院踏入第 15 天審訊。
拘捕及查問次被告李嘉濱的警員開始接受辯方盤問。辯方指警在拘捕時將李抬入後巷深處,用手叉頸及將他推向牆,遊說李指證「五飛」換取減刑,又用力拳打李的腹部,要脅稱「你條女都俾我哋拉埋,想佢冇事就自己識做」、「我要你認乜你就要認」,而李在脅迫下承認受「五飛」指使參與明愛醫院爆炸品案。
辯方又指,警員曾露出槍袋,要求李提供手機密碼,李唯有屈服。此外,辯方指警員 2020 年的供詞指值日官發現李有傷勢,但日前在庭上指是自己發現,質疑製造傷勢與他無關的假象。警員在庭上一概否認辯方的指控。審訊周五續。
11 Dec 2024法庭線#4348
反恐第二案|次被告錄影會面:欲在尚德停車場放煙彈 待警清場時釀混亂
Explosives were found at Caritas Medical Centre and in an MTR carriage at Lo Wu in early 2020. The Telegram channel “92 Lots” subsequently claimed responsibility. Seven people were charged with offences under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance, while the remaining person was charged with attempting to manufacture explosives. All eight pleaded not guilty, and the trial at the High Court entered its 14th day on Wednesday (11th).
The court continued playing a recorded interview between the second defendant Lee Ka-ban and police. He said he had planned to place smoke bombs in the shape of tombstones at the Sheung Tak car park in Tseung Kwan O in early March 2020, “to cause chaos when the police were clearing the area; that was our purpose”.
During the interview, Lee agreed to let police officers access his Telegram account. The group contained two experiment videos. Lee explained that the experiments were intended to “achieve the power of a bomb”, and that making bombs was meant to ensure that the police “could not engage in police brutality with impunity”. However, he denied being involved in the two explosives cases at Shenzhen Bay Port and Lo Wu Station. The trial will continue on Thursday, when the prosecution will continue playing Lee’s recorded interview.
2020 年初,明愛醫院、羅湖港鐵車廂被發現有爆炸品,Telegram 頻道「九十二籤」事後承認責任。7 人被控《反恐條例》罪名,餘下 1 人被控以「企圖製造炸藥」罪。8 人不認罪,周三(11 日)於高院踏入第 14 天審訊。
庭上續播放次被告李嘉濱與警員的錄影會面,他提及打算於 2020 年 3 月初在將軍澳尚德停車場放置煙彈,包裝成墓碑形狀,「等警察清場嗰陣造成混亂,呢個係我哋嘅目的」。
李在會面期間同意警員開啟其 Telegram 帳戶,在群組有兩段實驗片段,李解釋進行實驗希望「做到炸彈嘅威力」,而製作炸彈為令警方「唔可以肆無忌憚咁警暴」。不過他否認與深圳灣口岸及羅湖站兩宗爆炸品案有關。審訊周四續,控方將續播放李的錄影會面。
10 Dec 2024法庭線#4344
反恐第二案|次被告錄影會面:按「五飛」指示放煙霧彈 沒想過會爆炸或傷害任何人
In early 2020, explosives were found at Caritas Medical Centre and in an MTR train compartment at Lo Wu. The Telegram channel “Ninety-Two Lots” later claimed responsibility. Seven people were charged with offences under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance, while the remaining defendant was charged with attempting to manufacture explosives. All eight pleaded not guilty, and the trial at the High Court entered its 13th day on Tuesday (10th).
The court continued playing a recorded interview between the second defendant, Lee Ka-ban, and police officers. He said he did not know how to detonate a smoke bomb and had only placed it at Caritas Medical Centre on the instructions of Ng Fei. He said he only learned from the news afterwards that it had successfully exploded, and that he had “not thought of using this to hurt anyone”, stressing: “This isn’t a bomb, it’s just a smoke bomb.”
The police officer who conducted the questioning testified that officers took the second defendant to search his reported address in Sai Ying Pun and seized 12 sashimi knives. The defendant was then arrested on suspicion of possessing offensive weapons. After someone reported to police that sashimi knives were missing, the defendant admitted that he had given the wrong address, and police arrested him again on suspicion of misleading police officers. The trial will continue on Wednesday.
2020 年初,明愛醫院、羅湖港鐵車廂被發現有爆炸品,Telegram 頻道「九十二籤」事後承認責任。7 人被控《反恐條例》罪名,餘下 1 人被控以「企圖製造炸藥」罪。8 人不認罪,周二(10 日)於高院踏入第 13 天審訊。
庭上續播放次被告李嘉濱與警員的錄影會面,他表示不清楚如何引爆煙霧彈,只按「五飛」的指示在明愛醫院放下煙霧彈,事後「睇新聞先知」成功引爆,他「冇諗住用呢樣嘢傷害任何人」,強調「呢個唔係炸彈,只係煙彈」。
負責查問的警員供稱,帶次被告到其西營盤的報稱住址搜屋,檢走 12 把魚生刀,並再拘捕被告藏有攻擊性武器。其後有人報警指遺失魚生刀,被告才承認報錯地址,警再以誤導警務人員罪名拘捕他。審訊周三續。
9 Dec 2024法庭線#4341
反恐第二案|次被告會面認醫院放煙霧彈稱受脅迫 警否認拉被告入後巷免被看到逼供
In early 2020, explosives were found at Caritas Medical Centre and in an MTR train carriage at Lo Wu. The Telegram channel “Ninety-Two Lots” later claimed responsibility. Seven people were charged with offences under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, while one other person was charged with “attempting to manufacture explosives”. All eight pleaded not guilty, and the trial at the High Court entered its 12th day on Monday (9th).
During defence counsel’s questioning of the police officer who arrested the second defendant, Lee Ka-ban, it was alleged that the officer did not identify himself, pulled the defendant to the ground and knelt on his neck. The defendant allegedly called for help but was gagged, and the officer dragged him into an alley to prevent passers-by from seeing him being coerced. The officer denied all the allegations in court. The officer responsible for taking the defendant back to the police station testified that the defendant had injuries on his neck, but said he did not need to see a doctor and had made no complaints.
A video interview with the second defendant was played in court. He said Ng Fei had suggested setting off smoke bombs at Caritas Medical Centre to force the government to close the borders. He had initially wanted to withdraw but was threatened by the other party: “If I didn’t do it, he would do something dangerous to me, to my life or to my family.” He also admitted buying one tonne of potassium nitrate and making and planting smoke bombs on Ng Fei’s instructions. The trial will continue on Tuesday.
2020 年初,明愛醫院、羅湖港鐵車廂被發現有爆炸品,Telegram 頻道「九十二籤」事後承認責任。7 人被控《反恐條例》下罪名,餘下 1 人被控以「企圖製造炸藥」罪。8 人不認罪,周一(9 日)於高院踏入第 12 天審訊。
辯方盤問拘捕次被告李嘉濱的警員時,指警員沒表露身分,直接將被告扯落地,及用膝蓋跪其頸部,被告一度呼救但遭捂口,警員將他拉入後巷,為免途人發現他逼供。警員在庭上一概否認。負責將被告帶回警署的警員,則供稱被告頸部有傷痕,但被告稱毋須看醫生,亦沒有任何投訴。
庭上播放次被告的錄影會面,他表示「五飛」建議在明愛醫院放煙霧彈,逼使政府封關,他原欲退出但遭對方脅迫,「如果我唔做嘅話,佢會做一啲對我有危險嘅嘢,對我條命或者我屋企人」,他亦承認按「五飛」的指示購買一噸硝酸鉀、製作及放置煙霧彈。審訊周二續。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.