12 Dec 2025HK01#7678
七旬清潔工收垃圾被食環署告「亂拋垃圾」惹議 兩個月後終獲撤控
A 71-year-old building cleaner was issued a littering fixed penalty notice by Food and Environmental Hygiene Department (FEHD) staff in September this year while preparing to transport rubbish he had collected from a building in a handcart. The incident drew criticism of the FEHD’s handling. Sap Ping Toi, an organisation concerned with scavengers and cleaners, said on Thursday (11th) that the cleaner had received a letter from the FEHD confirming that the charge had been withdrawn.
Sap Ping Toi said it would continue to follow up on calls for the FEHD to revise its guidelines on enforcing fixed penalties, as failure to amend the enforcement guidelines could mean that all self-employed cleaners responsible for private buildings across Hong Kong would continue to face the possibility of being issued littering notices.
The FEHD confirmed that it had met the person involved. It said he acknowledged placing the relevant rubbish on the street that day, but had also explained the circumstances and undertaken to change his operating practice of storing rubbish in public places. FEHD staff had also observed his work practices on site several times during the period. After considering all relevant factors, the department decided to withdraw the fixed penalty notice issued to him on 8 September and had informed him of the decision.
一名71歲大廈清潔工今年9月收集完大廈垃圾,準備用手推車運走時,遭食環署職員票控「亂拋垃圾」,事件曝光後,食環署做法惹議。關注拾荒者及清潔工的組織「拾平台」周四(11日)表示,該清潔工終收到食環署回覆信函,通知已撤銷控罪。
「拾平台」說,會繼續跟進關於要求食環署修訂定額罰款執法前指引,因不修正執法指引,全港所有負責私人大廈的自僱清潔工友,將會有繼續面對被票控亂拋垃圾的可能性。
食環署證實已與涉事人會面,指涉事人承認當日將有關的垃圾放置在街上,但亦有就當時情況作出解釋,並承諾改變將垃圾存放在公眾地方的作業模式。過去一段時間,該署人員亦多次實地觀察涉事人的作業情況。經考慮所有相關因素後,署方決定撤回9月8日向涉事人發出的定額罰款通知書,並已就此通知涉事人。
10 Jun 2025集誌社#6886
申訴署刪「訴」|下架報告何處尋? 網站時光機全備份 曾稱有版權 轉載會否違例? 署方:建議諮詢法律意見
The Office of The Ombudsman’s earlier removal of years of reports from its website sparked controversy. Access now requires a written application and an in-person, time-limited visit to the office. However, the Internet Archive, a non-profit organisation, had long backed up the removed reports on the Wayback Machine. Asked whether publicly reposting links to the relevant archived reports, or publicly uploading the report contents, would violate the Copyright Ordinance, the Office told The Collective: “The Office suggests that you seek legal advice.”
申訴專員公署早前刪除網站多年報告引起爭議,現時需書面申請,親身到辦公室限時查閱。不過,非牟利組織 The Internet Archive 建立的平台「網站時光機」(Wayback Machine)早已備份下架的報告。被問市民公開轉載相關備份報告的連結,或公開上載報告內容會否觸犯《版權條例》。申訴專員公署回覆《集誌社》稱,「公署建議你諮詢法律意見」。
2 Jun 2025光傳媒#6851
申訴專員公署網頁大刪報告 民間組織接力整理目錄重現人間
The Office of The Ombudsman was found to have removed large numbers of investigation reports, annual reports, mediation cases and related press releases from its website, retaining only materials from the past three years and prompting public outcry. Although the office allows members of the public to inspect the materials in person, it requires them to provide details including the report topic, department involved and month of publication, while not providing a directory of reports that have been taken offline. Over the past week, two civic groups used different methods to locate the relevant materials and reconstructed a directory of nearly 238 reports, covering all reports removed from the office’s website. The Liber Research Community, one of the groups involved, criticised the office for setting a “bad example” in handling publicly available information, raising concerns that other departments might follow suit and make more historically valuable documents unavailable.
The office reiterated that members of the public could submit written requests for information not available on the website. However, after testing the process in person, several media organisations found that applicants first had to complete a form stating the topic of the report they wished to inspect, the department involved and the month of publication. Office staff said that providing detailed information would make it easier to locate the relevant report accurately; if applicants could only provide general information, they would have to wait for a response from the office. As the office does not provide a report directory, members of the public face difficulties in completing the form accurately.
申訴專員公署被揭在網頁刪走大量調查報告、年報、調解個案和相關新聞稿,僅保留近三年資料,引起輿論譁然。雖公署允許市民親身查閱資料,惟要求填寫報告主題、涉及部門及公布月份等資料,卻不提供已下架報告的目錄。兩個民間組織過去一周以不同方式尋找相關資料,重新製作有近238份報告的目錄,涵蓋公署已於網站移除的所有報告。有份出力的本土研究社批評,若公署示範一個處理公開資料的「壞榜樣」,讓人憂慮其他部門會否「有樣學樣」,令更多昔日具參考價值的文件不予公開。
公署雖重申市民可書面要求索取網站以外資料,但多間傳媒親身實測後發現,市民需要先填表格,包括欲查閱報告的主題、涉及部門、公布月份。署方職員表示,提供資料詳細的話,較易準確地查找出相關報告,若只能籠統填寫,則需待公署回應。由於公署不提供報告目錄,市民要準確填表面對一定阻礙。
3 Feb 2025光傳媒#4479
學者民間組織建「去中心化」反修例運動法庭案件資料庫
The Resilience Innovation Lab (RIL) released a database of cases related to the anti-extradition bill movement last month, covering the period from June 9, 2019, to mid-2024. The organisation said Hong Kong courts had issued nearly 3,000 judgments related to the movement over the past five years. The records document the official description of the movement, the reasons for courts’ decisions on whether to convict, and the inferences underlying convictions, giving the texts “historical and research value.”
The database’s information was verified through two independent sources. Journalists and law students first collected and compiled information by attending court hearings in person. Researchers within the organisation then randomly sampled the material and conducted “triangulation” through cross-checking—for example, comparing it with reports by news organisations and independent reports, consulting experts in relevant fields, and, where feasible, directly extracting rulings and judgments from the Hong Kong Judiciary website.
韌性創新實驗室(RIL)上月發佈反修例運動相關的案件數據庫,涵蓋範圍為2019年6月9日至2024年中旬。組織指,過去5年,香港法庭頒布了近3,000宗有關反修例運動的判詞,紀錄官方對運動的描述、法庭定罪與否的理由,和定罪的推論等,文本具「歷史價值和研究價值」。
數據庫的資料通過兩個獨立來源的驗證,先由記者及法律系學生實地出席法庭審訊收集資料並彙整,再由組織內部研究人員隨機抽取樣本,以交叉驗證方法進行「三角驗證」,例如與新聞機構的報導、獨立報告進行比對,以及諮詢相關領域的專家,在可行的情況下直接從香港司法機構網站提取裁決和判詞資料。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.