Technology Voucher investigation (1) | Data analysis of 35,000 projects: nearly 2,000 approved for the same $190,312.5; one person secured $4.53 million for 17 projects
科技券調查・1 | 數據分析 3.5 萬個項目 近 2000 項目同批 $190,312.5 一人申 17 項目獲資助 453 萬
The Government’s latest Budget again stressed the development of innovation and technology, using technology to “empower” traditional industries in upgrading and transformation. The authorities launched the Technology Voucher Programme in 2016. By the end of January this year, it had approved nearly $6.7 billion in total funding, and stopped accepting applications at the end of last year after the programme had “achieved its purpose”. How was the Technology Voucher Programme implemented, and what were its actual results? The Collective is following up with a series of three reports. The Collective consolidated and analysed data from the Innovation and Technology Commission’s website on nearly 35,000 approved Technology Voucher projects as of early this year, involving $6.22 billion in approved funding. It found that nearly 2,000 projects had been approved for the same “oddly precise” amount of $190,312.5. Some industry members considered it “strange” that even the decimal place was identical, while an economist said the situation was “rather unusual” statistically and might indicate common features among the projects, such as involving the same project content or being handled by the same people. Further investigation into these “upgrading and transformation” companies found that nine companies approved for $190,312.5 covered businesses including renovation, funeral goods and services, toys and logistics. However, the relevant businesses could not be found at any of the three addresses listed online. The same names also repeatedly appeared as applicants for multiple projects on behalf of different companies, with approved funding often amounting to several million dollars. One person applied for 17 projects on behalf of 12 companies, securing total funding of $4.53 million, including $480,000 approved for developing an “intelligent human body model measurement” system in 27 days. The Innovation and Technology Commission said in response to enquiries that the assessment process referred to market prices and evaluated whether budgets were reasonable. It also referred to the costs of approved projects when adjusting funding amounts, meaning projects of similar nature and scale might receive the same approved amount. The commission stressed that it had always rigorously examined final reports and supplementary information, and also conducted random inspections to verify whether projects complied with the application and programme requirements.
政府新一份財政預算案,續強調發展創新科技、以科技「賦能」傳統產業升級轉型。當局於2016 年推出「科技券」計劃,截至今年 1月底批出近 67 億資助總額,計劃在去年底「達至目的」停接受申請。科技券的執行、實際成效究竟如何?《集誌社》以一連三篇報道跟進。 《集誌社》整合分析創新科技署網站,截至今年初、近 3.5 萬個已批出科技券項目,獲批資助 62.2 億元的資料,發現有近 2000 個項目獲批相同「零丁」金額 $190,312.5,有業內人士認為,連「毫子位」都一致「咁蹺蹊」,有經濟學者認為情況在統計學上「較奇怪」,或顯示有關項目有共通處,如涉及相同項目內容、或由相同人士經手。 記者進一步追查這些「升級轉型」公司,發現有獲批 $190,312.5 的九間公司,業務涵蓋裝修、香燭殯儀、玩具、物流等,但在網上顯示的三個地址,都未能找到相關業務。另不時有相同人名,為多家公司申請多個項目,獲批資助動輒數百萬元;其中一人為 12 間公司申請 17 個項目,總資助額達 453 萬,當中包括獲批 48 萬、在 27 日開發「智能人體模型量度」系統。 創新科技署回覆查詢指,評審過程會參照市場價格、評估預算是否合理,亦會參考核准項目成本調整資助金額,故性質與規模相近項目獲批金額或會相同。署方強調,一直嚴謹審查項目最終報告及補充資料,亦會隨機進行抽查,以核實項目是否符合申請及計劃規定。
