7 Jun 2024法庭線#3660
8.31灣仔|女生暴動無罪兼獲訟費 律政司上訴得直 發還原審重新考慮
On 31 August 2019, members of the public organised a march on Hong Kong Island, where clashes between police and protesters broke out. A first-aider and a female student were charged with rioting and acquitted; the female student was also awarded costs. The Department of Justice, dissatisfied with the ruling, appealed by way of case stated. The appeal was heard in the High Court on Friday (the 7th). It was learned that the appeal concerning the first-aider had been discontinued after the first-aider left Hong Kong.
The Department of Justice argued that the trial court had overlooked the importance of the defendants’ escape routes and equipment. Judge Pang Wai-cheong also said that the defendant’s possession of a gas mask and hiking stick showed that she intended to protect herself and engage in physical confrontation. After considering all the circumstantial evidence, the inference that she had participated in the riot was overwhelming. The Court of Appeal allowed the Department of Justice’s appeal, set aside the acquittal on the rioting charge and the related costs order, and remitted the case to the trial court for reconsideration.
The case will return to the District Court on 1 August. It was disclosed in court that the defendant had originally not been required to post bail and had at one point moved overseas, before subsequently returning to Hong Kong. The Court of Appeal reimposed bail conditions, including a ban on leaving Hong Kong and reporting to a police station every month.
2019 年 8 月 31 日,市民在港島區發起遊行,爆發警民衝突。一名急救員及女學生被控暴動,被裁定無罪,女生另獲批訟費。律政司不服裁決,以案件呈述方式提上訴,周五(7 日)在高等法院審理。據悉,急救員已離港獲撤銷上訴。
律政司一方指,原審忽略被告逃走路線、裝備的重要性。法官彭偉昌亦指,被告攜防毒面具、行山杖等,可見她打算防護及肢體衝突,考慮所有環境證供後,其參與暴動的推論是壓倒性。上訴庭裁定律政司上訴得直,撤銷暴動無罪裁決及相關訟費安排,發還原審重新考慮。
案件將於 8 月 1 日在區域法院再訊。庭上透露,被告原毋須保釋,一度移居外地,其後返港。上訴庭重新向她施加保釋條件,包括不得離港、每月往警署報到。
5 Jun 2024法庭線#3651
11.18油麻地|男子暴動囚5年提上訴 指原審拒納辯解 官即日駁回
On 18 November 2019, police cordoned off the Hong Kong Polytechnic University. A total of 213 people were charged with rioting in Yau Ma Tei in an operation described as “besiege Wei to rescue Zhao”, and the cases were divided for trial. In one of the cases, a 34-year-old man was sentenced to five years’ imprisonment. He applied for leave to appeal against his conviction and sentence, with the application heard at the High Court on Wednesday (the 5th). After hearing submissions, Court of Appeal judge Patrick Pang Wai-cheong dismissed the application on the same day and will deliver written reasons within three months.
The applicant testified at trial that he was a taxi driver. After encountering a roadblock while carrying a passenger, he dropped the passenger off and went to McDonald’s to buy dinner wearing a gas mask, but was subdued by police officers on the way. His main argument was that the trial court had failed to accept his testimony. Pang questioned why, after encountering a roadblock, he did not “turn around and leave, which would have been the most reasonable thing”, but instead continued to the restaurant. The judge also said that, by wearing a gas mask, “you weren’t afraid people would suspect you?”, and considered that the trial court’s refusal to accept his testimony “just meant it thought what you said was absurd”.
2019 年 11 月 18 日,警方圍封理工大學,213 人涉在油麻地「圍魏救趙」被控暴動,分拆成多案審理。其中一案的 34 歲男子被判 5 年監禁,他不服定罪和刑罰申請上訴許可,周三(5 日)在高等法院處理。上訴庭法官彭偉昌聽畢陳詞,即日拒絕申請,將於 3 個月內頒下書面判詞。
申請人原審供稱,案發時為的士司機,接載客人時遇堵路,放下對方後,戴防毒面具往麥當勞買晚餐,途中被警員制服。他主要爭議原審不接納其供詞,彭偉昌質疑他遇堵路後,「最合理掉頭走啦」,惟他仍往餐廳。法官又指,他戴防毒面具,「你又唔怕人懷疑喎?」,認為原審拒絕接納其供詞,「咪就係覺得你講嘅嘢荒謬囉」。
5 Jun 2024法庭線#3653
反恐首案|彭軍壕同意「覺得吳智鴻係癲」 憂退出會被殺、「累全家」
In the first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants pleaded not guilty as the trial entered its 28th day at the High Court on Wednesday (the 5th). The defendant who pleaded guilty and prosecution witness Eddie Pang Kwan-ho was cross-examined by the defence. He said his father was a police officer who was due to retire at the time of the case. The defence asked whether, when planning to detonate a bomb on crowded Hennessy Road, he thought Ng Chi-hung was “crazy”. Pang remained silent for several seconds before saying that he did. The defence said Pang could have told his father about the plan. Pang responded: “Since I thought he was crazy and the plan was crazy, why would I go home and drag the whole family into it?” The defence also cited Pang’s 2020 statement, in which he said he had always wanted to withdraw but feared that Ng “would get people to kill me and go after my family”. The defence suggested that Pang wanted to shift the blame to reduce his criminal liability, which he denied. The defence further questioned whether Pang had reached an agreement with police before becoming a witness to testify against the other defendants in exchange for being prosecuted on lesser charges. Pang disagreed with all the suggestions.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周三(5 日)在高等法院踏入第 28 天審訊。認罪被告、控方證人彭軍壕接受辯方盤問,提到其父任職警察,案發時即將退休。辯方問,計劃在滿佈人群的軒尼詩道引爆炸彈,「你覺唔覺得吳智鴻係癲㗎?」彭靜默數秒後,稱「覺」。
辯方指彭可將計劃告知父親,彭回應稱「既然係覺得佢係癲、個計劃係癲嘅,我點解返屋企累全家?」辯方另引述彭於 2020 年錄取的口供,稱一直想退出,但憂慮吳「會搵人殺我,同攪我屋企人」,質疑彭欲推卸責任,以減輕罪責;彭否認。
辯方另質疑,彭轉任證人前與警方有協議,指證其他被告,以換取檢控較輕控罪;彭均不同意。
4 Jun 2024法庭線#3634
反恐首案|彭軍壕:吳智鴻稱「屠龍」掩護下放置炸彈 槍手開槍為訊號再引爆炸彈
In the first case under the Anti-terrorism Law, seven people have pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 27th day at the High Court on Tuesday (the 4th). The defendant who pleaded guilty and prosecution witness Eddie Pang Kwan-ho continued giving evidence, saying that he had tested remote detonation devices with accomplice Ng Chi-hung and defendant Lai Chun-pong. He also handed a pistol to another person at Ng’s instruction, during which Ng disclosed that hollow-point bullets, which had greater stopping power, would be used during the operation.
Pang also said that he assembled bombs with Ng and Lai on the day before the operation. Ng discussed details of the operation, saying that he would plant bombs under the cover of “Dragon Slaying Brigade”, while squads including “Dragon Slaying Brigade” would carry out acts of sabotage to draw police to the scene. The gunman would then fire the first shot as a signal, after which Ng would detonate a small bomb. When the police retreated, Ng would detonate a larger bomb, allowing the others to “pick up the guns”. The operation was ultimately aborted when Ng, “Dragon Slaying Brigade” and others were arrested. Pang said Lai Chun-pong had at one point hoped to continue carrying out the plan, but it fell through after police subsequently recovered the bombs.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周二(4 日)在高等法院踏入第 27 天審訊。認罪被告、控方證人彭軍壕繼續作供,提到與同謀者吳智鴻、被告賴振邦,曾測試遙控引爆裝置,又按吳指示,將手槍轉交他人,期間吳透露行動時,將用殺傷力較強的空尖彈。
彭又指,於行動前一日與吳及賴組裝炸彈,期間吳談及行動細節,指他自己會在「屠龍」掩護下放置炸彈,並由「屠龍」等小隊作破壞,引警員到場,屆時由槍手開第一槍為訊號,吳引爆細炸彈。待警員後退時吳再引爆大炸彈,其他人便可「執槍」。行動最終隨吳、「屠龍」等人被捕而腰斬,彭稱賴振邦一度希望繼續實行計劃,但隨警方事後檢獲炸彈而告吹。
3 Jun 2024法庭線#3628
反恐首案|彭軍壕:獲金主資助到台灣軍訓 原擬真槍炸彈對付警察 疑被警監視終剎停
In the first case under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants have pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 26th day at the High Court on Monday (the 3rd). Defendant Eddie Pang Kwan-ho, who pleaded guilty, testified as a prosecution witness, saying he met co-conspirator Ng Chi-hung during the 2014 social movement. After the 7.21 Yuen Long incident, Ng Chi-hung invited him to join a new organisation, saying it would “rally a bigger force” and “go into Yuen Long to find those rural triad figures and overturn the tables”.
Peng said Walter Joseph Liu, who had stood for election as a district councillor, was the organisation’s behind-the-scenes coordinator and financier. The organisation successively planned to use live firearms and bombs against police, and to throw corrosive liquid bombs at police from elevated locations, but the plans were ultimately suspected to have been halted after coming under police surveillance. Wu also said Walter Joseph Liu had funded members to undergo military training in Taiwan. Peng, together with co-defendants Hui Cham-wing, Lai Chun-pong and Cheung Ming-yu, among others, took part in the training, practising shooting and making petrol bombs and thermite bombs.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周一(3 日)在高等法院踏入第 26 天審訊。認罪被告彭軍壕以控方證人身分作供,供稱 2014 年社運時認識同謀者吳智鴻,對方在 7.21 元朗事件後,邀請他加入新組織,聲稱要「吹大雞」、「入元朗搵班鄉黑覆桌」。
彭供稱,曾參選區議員的「大嚿」劉偉德為幕後統籌及金主,組織先後策劃以真槍及炸彈對付警察、由高處向警方擲鏹水彈,最終疑被警方監視而刹停。吳又指,「大嚿」曾資助成員到台灣接受軍訓,最終彭與同案被告許湛榮、賴振邦及張銘裕等人都有參與軍訓,練習開槍,製作汽油彈和鋁熱彈等。
3 Jun 2024法庭線#3629
11.12大老山隧道|女生認暴動判囚17個月 官:完成學位難能可貴
In November 2019, netizens launched the “Dawn Action”, and clashes between police and the public broke out in multiple districts. Three female students from Hang Seng University were accused of taking part in a riot at Tate’s Cairn Tunnel adjacent to the university. The Hang Seng University student, who was 19 at the time of the incident, pleaded guilty before trial, while the other two were acquitted after trial. Acting Judge Poon Leung-ting sentenced the student who pleaded guilty to 17 months’ imprisonment at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts, sitting as the District Court, on Monday (the 3rd).
2019 年 11 月,有網民發起「破曉行動」,多區爆發警民衝突。3 名恒大女學生涉於大學毗鄰的大老山隧道參與暴動,案發時 19 歲的恒大生開審前認罪,另兩人經審訊後獲裁無罪。暫委法官彭亮廷周一(3 日)於西九龍裁判法院(暫代區域法院)判認罪女生監禁 17 個月。
法官指,被告整個大學生涯均在案件的籠罩下度過,對於她最終能努力完成學位,官讚揚她有此能耐及毅力,形容難能可貴。法官信納被告態度誠懇,深感後悔,並非因證據強,在沒有選擇的情況下才認罪,而似乎是因真誠悔意而認罪,遂酌情扣減部分刑期。
31 May 2024法庭線#3607
反恐首案|控方傳彭軍壕作供 押後讓彭閱讀「免予起訴書」
In the first case under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 25th day at the High Court on Friday (31st). Victor Chun Keung Wong, the self-styled leader of the “Dragon Slaying Brigade Squad”, had earlier completed giving evidence. The prosecution continued by calling another defendant who had pleaded guilty, Eddie Pang Kwan-ho, to testify. Pang told the court that he had not received the “letter of immunity from prosecution”. After discussions, Judge Cheung Wai-ling adjourned the case until next Monday (3rd) to allow Pang’s legal representative to explain the document to him.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周五(31 日)在高等法院踏入第 25 天審訊。自稱「屠龍小隊」隊長黃振強早前已完成作供,控方續傳召另一名認罪被告、彭軍壕出庭作供。但彭於庭上表示沒有收到「免予起訴書」,經商討後,法官張慧玲把案件押後至下周一(3 日)續審,讓彭的代表律師向彭解釋文件。
29 May 2024法庭線#3588
反恐首案|黃振強完成 15 日作供 辯方質疑知作供可減刑 故「唔介意唔講真話」
In the first case under the Terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants pleaded not guilty. The trial at the High Court entered its 23rd day on Wednesday (the 29th). The defendant who pleaded guilty, and self-described captain of the “Dragon Slaying Brigade squad”, Victor Chun Keung Wong, completed a total of 15 days of testimony. Three defence teams conducted supplementary cross-examinations, all targeting Wong’s credibility. Leung Hung-kuk, counsel for Yim Man-Him, questioned whether Wong had “two safeguards” before giving evidence: he knew that immunity from prosecution could be granted for offences, and that the sentences for offences he admitted could also be reduced because of his testimony. Leung therefore suggested that Wong “didn’t mind not telling the truth” in court. Wong denied this.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周三(29 日)在高等法院踏入第 23 天審訊。認罪被告、自稱「屠龍小隊」隊長黃振強完成歷時共 15 日作供。3 名辯方補充盤問,均針對黃的口供可信性。其中代表嚴文謙的大狀梁鴻谷質疑,黃作供前「有兩個保障」,知道有罪行獲豁免不告,而承認的罪行亦可因作供而減刑,故黃庭上「唔介意唔講真話」。黃否認。
另對於辯方貿疑,黃「有重要嘢」就不出現,例如試槍時不想碰軍火,就自稱在中大示威中受傷。控方則展示在中大示威期間,黃曾於群組發出數張傷勢相,稱「我喺前線,好正」,當中一張見前臂有圓形大紅印。
17 May 2024法庭線#3546
反恐首案|黃振強錄影會面稱同謀者有過百萬資金 故投其所好稱想用槍「氹住、呃住佢先」
In the first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 18th day at the High Court on Friday (17th), with the defendant who pleaded guilty, Victor Chun Keung Wong, continuing to be cross-examined. The court played a videotaped interview conducted after Wong’s arrest. Wong said in the recording that he did not need a lawyer present and provided police with his phone password. He also said he knew that his accomplice, Ng Chi-hung, had funds exceeding one million, so he falsely claimed that he wanted to use guns in order to play to Ng’s interests and “placate and deceive him first” to obtain funding. He stressed that the plan had always been led by Ng, and that he was not involved in making bombs or other such activities. The defence also cited a Complaints Against Police Office report, saying that when Wong complained of being subjected to police violence and threats, an officer told him: “Do you believe that there will be deaths on 8.31 … throw you in too … we can send you back to the mainland.” Wong softly sobbed after hearing this, agreed that he had been subjected to violence, and said that one of the officers involved had also taken his videotaped interview.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周五(17 日)在高等法院踏入第 18 天審訊。認罪被告、自稱「屠龍小隊」隊長黃振強續接受盤問。
庭上播放黃被捕後的錄影會面,黃在片中稱毋須律師陪同,並向警方提供手機密碼,又提到知悉同謀者吳智鴻有過百萬資金,所以投其所好訛稱想用槍、「氹住、呃住佢先」,以獲取資金,強調計劃一直由吳主導,自己不涉製作炸彈等。
辯方另引述投訴警察課報告,指黃投訴遭警武力對待和威嚇時,有警員向他稱「你信唔信 8.31 有死人 … 掟埋你 … 可以送你返大陸」。黃聞言輕聲啜泣,同意曾遭武力對待,並指其中一名涉事警員,有份為他錄取錄影會面。
16 May 2024法庭線#3540
反恐首案|辯方指黃振強為配合認罪 誣衊同案被告知悉殺警計劃 黃否認
In the first case under the anti-terrorism law, seven defendants have pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 17th day at the High Court on Thursday (16th). Victor Chun Keung Wong, the defendant who pleaded guilty and described himself as captain of the “Dragon Slaying Brigade squad”, continued to be cross-examined. The defence continued to focus on discrepancies between Wong’s admitted facts and his testimony in court. Wong confirmed that parts of the admitted facts did not accord with the facts, saying: “The prosecution brought these out; whatever it said, that was it.”
Wong also said he had called defendant Lau Pui-ying, who was involved in helping with fundraising, and told the defendant that someone would use guns and bombs, urging the defendant to make efforts to assist the crowdfunding. The defence questioned why Wong had waited nearly four years to disclose the content of the call, describing it as “impossible to corroborate”, and accused Wong of making it up to smear the defendant in order to facilitate his guilty plea. Wong disagreed.
Wong was also asked whether, apart from the “plan to kill police officers”, he had committed any other acts involving terrorism. Wong said, “I also think using petrol bombs counts,” and said he had deliberately thrown petrol bombs at police officers.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周四(16 日)在高等法院踏入第 17 天審訊。認罪被告、自稱「屠龍小隊」隊長黃振強續接受盤問。辯方續關注黃的承認案情,與其庭上供詞有出入。黃確認部分承認案情與事實不符,稱「呢啲係控方攞出嚟,佢話幾多就幾多㗎啦。」
黃另指,曾致電涉協助籌款的被告劉佩凝,講述將有人使用槍和炸彈,著努力協助眾籌。辯方質疑,黃事隔近 4 年才透露通話內容,形容是「無從對證」,質疑黃為配合認罪,「作出嚟去誣衊」被告;黃不同意。
黃另被問及,除了「殺警計劃」外,有否作出其他行為涉恐怖主義,黃稱「用汽油彈我都覺得算係嘅」,指曾蓄意將汽油彈擲向警員身上。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.