【July 1 LegCo Occupation Case】Judge takes District Court’s seven-year maximum as starting point for riot sentence, says protesters sought to overturn LegCo’s constitutional status
【7.1佔立會案】官以區院最高判刑上限7年為暴動罪起點 指示威者推翻立法會憲制地位
On July 1, 2019, protesters stormed and occupied the Legislative Council complex. Fourteen people were charged with riot and “entering or remaining in the precincts of the Chamber”. Eight, including Lau Wing-kuong and Jau Ka-sing, pleaded guilty to riot, while four others, including actor Gregory Wong, were convicted after trial. Twelve people were sentenced today (the 16th) to between four years and six months and six years and 10 months at West Kowloon Court, which was sitting in place of the District Court. Acting judge Juleus Chee Ho Lee took the District Court’s maximum sentence of seven years as the starting point for the riot offence, saying the protesters weakened and sought to overturn the Legislative Council’s unique constitutional status while also attacking the rule of law. Wong was sentenced to six years and two months. He said he entered the Legislative Council to give a charger to reporters, but the judge said he had put his arm around protesters’ shoulders and could boost their morale, although his level of participation was relatively minor. Regarding Jau Ka-sing and Lau Wing-kuong, the judge said both bore serious culpability and took seven years’ imprisonment as the starting point. The judge said Jau tore up a Basic Law booklet and put up a British Hong Kong flag, amounting to an insult to the Legislative Council. Lau discussed with protesters whether they should stay and urged others to protect the people inside the Legislative Council, constituting a leadership and command role. After reductions for their guilty pleas, the two were sentenced to about five years and one month and about four and a half years respectively.
2019年7月1日,有示威者衝擊並佔領立法會大樓,14人被控暴動罪及「進入或逗留在會議廳範圍」罪。其中8人包括劉頴匡及鄒家成認暴動罪,另4人包括藝人王宗堯受審後罪成。12人今(16日)在西九法院(暫代區域法院)被判囚4年半至6年10個月。暫委法官李志豪採取區域法院最高判刑上限7年為暴動罪起點,指示威者削弱及推翻立法會獨特的憲制地位,同時衝擊法治。王宗堯被判囚6年2個月,他稱入立法會將充電器給予記者,李官卻指他曾搭示威者肩膊,能激起對方士氣,但參與程度相對輕微。就鄒家成及劉頴匡,李官指兩人罪責嚴重,以7年監禁為起點。他指鄒撕毀基本法小冊子及貼港英旗,屬侮辱立法會;劉則與示威者商討應否留守,並呼籲其他人守護立法會內人士,屬帶領及指揮角色。兩人經認罪扣減後,分別囚約5年1個月及約4年半。
