Civilian Housing Company wins case against Tai Hang Sai Estate resident in her 90s; court orders surrender of flat
平屋控大坑西邨未遷出居民案 九旬居民敗訴 官下令交出單位管有權
Tai Hang Sai Estate in Shek Kip Mei is to be demolished and redeveloped. Civilian Housing Company Limited, which built and manages the estate, brought civil proceedings against several residents who refused to move out. Judge Kam Tsuen Chan handed down a judgment on Tuesday (the 16th) in the case involving one resident in her 90s, ordering her to surrender possession of the flat. The judgment said the defendant questioned why Ping Uk, a non-profit organisation that had received substantial concessions from the government, had to keep confidential the profits from the redevelopment. She also argued that Ping Uk’s process for considering former tenants’ eligibility to return was not transparent and had no appeal mechanism, and that Ping Uk was unregulated and had abused public power. The judge, however, held that regardless of whether Ping Uk made a profit and whether it was required to account to the government, neither constituted grounds for a tenant to refuse to return possession of the property after the tenancy had expired. The court therefore ruled in favour of Ping Uk.
石硤尾大坑西邨將清拆重建,興建與管理該邨的「平民屋宇有限公司」,民事控告多名拒絕遷出的居民,法官陳錦泉周二(16 日)就其中一名九旬居民的案件頒下判詞,下令居民須交出單位管有權。 判詞指,被告質疑「平屋」為非牟利機構,得到政府大量優惠,卻要保密重建所得的利潤,而且「平屋」審理舊租戶回遷資格的過程不透明,沒有上訴機制,認為「平屋」沒有監管,濫用公權。惟法官認為,無論「平屋」賺取利潤與否,是否需向政府交代,都不構成租客在租約期滿後,不交回物業管有權的理據,裁定「平屋」勝訴。
