5 Mar 2024法庭線#3105
8.18流水式集會|黎智英等7人就參與集結罪維持定罪提上訴 終院6.24審理
On August 18, 2019, the Civil Human Rights Front held a flowing assembly at Victoria Park. Seven pro-democracy figures, including Jimmy Lai and Audrey Eu, were convicted after trial of organising and participating in an unauthorised assembly. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeals of all seven against their convictions for organising an assembly and quashed those convictions, but dismissed their appeals against the convictions for participating in an assembly and upheld them.
The defendants appealed to the Court of Final Appeal against the convictions for participating in an assembly, arguing over whether the Public Order Ordinance was disproportionate in its application. The Court of Final Appeal had earlier granted leave to appeal. The defendants also sought to have the court address issues including whether the penalties under the Public Order Ordinance would create a chilling effect, but the court, after consideration, rejected the application on Tuesday (the 5th).
The substantive appeal by the seven will be heard on June 24. The Department of Justice’s application for leave to appeal against the convictions for organising an assembly was earlier rejected by the Court of Final Appeal on the same day.
2019 年 8 月 18 日,民陣在維園舉行流水式集會,黎智英、吳靄儀等 7 名民主派人士,經審訊後被裁定「組織」及「參與」未經批准集結兩罪罪成。上訴庭裁定 7 人「組織集結」上訴得直、撤銷定罪;「參與集結」罪則上訴失敗、維持定罪。
被告一方就「參與」定罪申上訴,爭議《公安條例》在執行層面有否違反相稱性,早前獲終院批出上訴許可。被告方另希望終院處理《公安條例》刑罰,會否帶來寒蟬效應等議題,終院則經考慮後,周二(5 日)拒絕申請。
7 人的正審上訴將於 6 月 24 日開庭處理。至於律政司就「組織」罪申請上訴許可,早前已被終院即日駁回。
23 Feb 2024法庭線#3027
8.18流水式集會|黎智英等7人「組織集結」獲撤罪 終院駁回律政司上訴許可申請
On 18 August 2019, the Civil Human Rights Front held a flowing assembly at Victoria Park. Following a trial, Jimmy Lai, Audrey Eu and five other pro-democracy figures were convicted of two offences: organising and taking part in an unauthorised assembly. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeals of all seven against the “organising an assembly” convictions and quashed those convictions. Their appeals against the “taking part in an assembly” convictions failed, and those convictions were upheld.
The Department of Justice and the defendants were both dissatisfied with the decision and applied to the Court of Final Appeal for leave to appeal on Friday (the 23rd). The Department of Justice argued that the Court of Appeal’s view that “even if appellants stood at the front of the procession and led the chanting, it could not necessarily be inferred that they were the organisers” was perplexing and incorrect. It reiterated that the defendants’ spontaneous leadership—including Lee Cheuk-yan holding a microphone and Jimmy Lai and Leung Kwok-hung making gestures—also constituted “organising”. After hearing the Department of Justice’s submissions, the Court of Final Appeal judges dismissed the application immediately.
As for the defendants’ appeal concerning “taking part in an assembly”, which disputed whether the Public Order Ordinance, as applied, breached the principle of proportionality, the Court of Final Appeal granted leave to appeal. The defendants also asked the Court of Final Appeal to address issues including the definition of an “assembly” and whether the Public Order Ordinance would create a chilling effect. The court will decide on another date whether to grant leave on those issues.
2019 年 8 月 18 日,民陣在維園舉行流水式集會,黎智英、吳靄儀等 7 名民主派人士,經審訊後被裁定「組織」及「參與」未經批准集結兩罪罪成。上訴庭裁定 7 人「組織集結」上訴得直、撤銷定罪;「參與集結」罪則上訴失敗、維持定罪。
律政司與被告方均不服決定,周五(23 日)向終院提出上訴許可申請。律政司一方指,上訴庭指「即使上訴人站在隊頭、帶領喊口號,也不一定能推論他們是組織者」,推論令人不解及錯誤,重申被告自發帶領,如李卓人手持麥克風,黎智英及梁國雄做手勢,亦構成「組織」。終院法官聽畢律政司陳詞,即場駁回申請。
至於被告一方就「參與集結」申上訴,爭議《公安條例》在執行層面有否違反相稱性,終院則批出上訴許可。被告方另外希望終院處理「集會」定義、《公安條例》會否帶來寒蟬效應等議題,終院擇日決定是否批准。
4 Dec 2023獨媒#8745
「民主派」林頌鎧支持工聯會候選人 記者查詢稱感冒初癒拒回應
Voting in the District Council election will take place on Sunday. The pan-democratic camp has been completely shut out of this election and is unable to stand. Some internet users discovered that incumbent Tuen Mun District Councillor Chung Hoi Lam, who ran as a Democratic Party candidate in 2019 and has since left the party, is backing an FTU candidate. An InMedia reporter called Chung Hoi Lam for comment. He said he had just recovered from a cold, coughed several times, and immediately hung up without responding.
區議會選舉周日進行投票,民主派今屆清零未能入閘參選。有網民發現,現任屯門區議員、2019年以民主黨身份參選、現已退出的林頌鎧支持工聯會候選人。《獨媒》記者致電林頌鎧查詢,他稱感冒初癒,並咳嗽數聲,並隨即收線拒絕回應。
27 Oct 2023集誌社#8547
區選提名記|向三會拜票 資深民主派獲覆「未收到消息可否提名」
In this year’s “improved” District Council election, the “battleground” for candidates seeking nominations is no longer the streets. After the government amended the electoral system, directly elected district councillors must secure nominations from nine members of “"the three committees"” to qualify to stand. A former pan-democratic district councillor seeking a nomination sent messages to 50 acquainted committee members, receiving only five replies—all refusals. Non-establishment group New Thinking, which had spent six months preparing for the election, also encountered obstacles in seeking nominations: a candidate wrote to more than 100 committee members and cited quotations from Xi Jinping to demonstrate patriotism, but received only “verbal promises” of nominations. On the other hand, establishment candidates registered with strong momentum. The new party Hong Kong New Direction fielded five candidates, all of whom qualified to stand, while Henry Chi Hang Ma, itself a member of "the three committees", secured enough nominations to register on the first day nominations opened. How did candidates from the three camps seek nominations?
今年「被完善」了的區議會選舉,候選人爭取提名的「戰場」,不再是街頭。政府修改選制,直選的區議員,要爭取九個「三會」委員提名,才可入閘。有民主派前區議員圖爭提名,發信息給 50 個相識的委員,只獲五個回覆、但全數拒絕;非建制的新思維籌備選舉半年,也在爭取提名碰壁,候選人發信予百多位委員、引習近平語錄自證愛國,但仍只得「口頭承諾」提名。另一邊,建制派報名氣勢如虹,新政黨香港新方向派五人出選全部入閘,本身是三會成員的馬志恆,在提名首日便夠提名可「入閘」報名。三條路線的參選人,是如何爭取提名?
13 Oct 2023獨媒#8486
兩名民主派區議員宣布不參選 鍾禮謙:制度民主短期內不會實現
The nomination period for the District Council election begins next Tuesday, and some pro-establishment parties have already announced their candidate lists. Two incumbent pan-democratic district councillors have announced in turn that they will not run, including Sha Tin District Council chairman Chris Yun Pui Mak and district councillor Johnny Lai Him Chung. Johnny Lai Him Chung said the decision to leave the system was prompted by democratic regression, and believed that democracy within the system would not be realised in the short term.
區議會選舉提名期下周二開始,有建制派政黨已公布參選名單。兩名民主派現任區議員先後宣布不會參選,包括沙田區議會主席麥潤培、區議員鍾禮謙。鍾禮謙表示,因為民主倒退而決定離開制度,並認為制度上的民主,在短期內不會實現。
5 Sept 2023獨媒#8320
四民主派告別深水埗區議會 「末代」主席覃德誠不連任將同辭民協執委
The District Council election will be held at the end of the year. The Sham Shui Po District Council held the final full council meeting of its current term this morning, where four pro-democracy councillors said they did not intend to seek re-election and would bid farewell to the council. The next-term District Council will be chaired concurrently by the District Officer, with no vice-chairman. Sham Shui Po District Council Chairman Tak Shing Chum said he would not seek re-election as a district councillor and would also resign from the executive committee of the Association for Democracy and People’s Livelihood. In his concluding remarks, Tak Shing Chum apologised for being unable to invite officials from the relevant policy bureaux or departments to attend meetings: “Over these two years, I have been unable to improve in this regard.” He hoped the new District Council chairman would invite more officials to “hold meetings more often” and engage in direct dialogue with councillors.
區議會換屆選舉年底舉行,深水埗區議會今早舉行現屆最後一次大會會議,4名民主派議員表明無意連任,將告別區議會。來屆區議會將由民政專員兼任主席,不設副主席。深水埗區議會主席覃德誠表明不會連任區議員,更將同時辭任民協執委。覃德誠在總結發言時,對未能邀請相關政策局或部門官員出席會議感抱歉:「呢兩年小弟呢,喺呢方面未能夠有改善。」他期望,新任區議會主席能邀請更多官員「多啲開會」,與議員直接對話。
14 Aug 2023法庭線#8200
8.18流水式集會案 黎智英、吳靄儀等7人組織未經批准集結上訴得直 參與集結罪維持原判
On 18 August 2019, the Civil Human Rights Front held a procession-style assembly at Victoria Park. Following trial, seven pro-democracy figures, including Jimmy Lai and Margaret Ng, were convicted of organising an unauthorised assembly and knowingly taking part in an unauthorised assembly. They were sentenced to between eight and 18 months in prison, while Martin Lee, Margaret Ng and Albert Ho were given suspended sentences.
The seven separately appealed against their convictions and sentences. The Court of Appeal handed down its judgment on Monday (14th), ruling that even if the appellants stood at the front of the procession and led the chanting, it could not necessarily be inferred that they were the organisers. It therefore allowed the appeals against the convictions for organising an unauthorised assembly, but dismissed all appeals against the convictions and sentences for knowingly taking part in an unauthorised assembly.
Jimmy Lai, Lee Cheuk-yan, Leung Kwok-hung and Cyd Ho had their sentences reduced by three to six months; all four had already completed their sentences in this case. For the other three—Martin Lee, Margaret Ng and Albert Ho—the original sentences were not dealt with because their periods of suspension had already expired. Outside court, Margaret Ng said she would study the judgment with her lawyers before deciding on the next steps, and that it was not appropriate to comment at this stage.
2019 年 8 月 18 日,民陣在維園舉行流水式集會,黎智英、吳靄儀等 7 名民主派人士,經審訊後被裁定「組織未經批准集結」及「明知而參與未經批准集結」罪成,判囚 8 至 18 個月,其中李柱銘、吳靄儀、何俊仁獲判緩刑。
7 人分別就就定罪及刑期上訴,上訴庭周一(14 日)頒下判決,指即使上訴人站在隊頭、帶領喊口號,也不一定能推論他們是組織者,裁定「組織未經批准集結」定罪上訴得直,「明知而參與未經批准集結」定罪及刑期上訴則全部駁回。
黎智英、李卓人、梁國雄、何秀蘭獲減刑3至6個月,4人早前已服畢本案刑期。另外 3 人包括李柱銘、吳靄儀、何俊仁,則因緩刑期限已過,未有處理原審判刑。吳靄儀在庭外指,會與律師研究判詞,再決定下一步行動,現階段不適宜作任何評論。
6 Aug 2023獨媒#8151
李家超視察全民運動日 民主派區會主席首次同場
Today is Sports for All Day, and several sports and recreational facilities under the Leisure and Cultural Services Department have been opened free of charge. Chief Executive John Lee inspected Sham Shui Po Sports Centre in the afternoon and tried an electronic fencing version. Tak Shing Chum, chairperson of the Sham Shui Po District Council from the Association for Democracy and People’s Livelihood, was also present. It was a rare occasion in recent years for a pro-democracy district council chairperson to be invited to an official event. Tak Shing Chum told The Collective that they attended at the invitation of the Leisure and Cultural Services Department: “Before coming here, I didn’t know there would be so many V IPs. I thought there would be, at most, bureau secretaries; I didn’t know John Lee would be here too. I didn’t expect the Chief Executive to have so much time to support these activities.”
今日是全民運動日,康文署轄下多項康體設施免費開放,行政長官李家超下午到深水埗體育館視察,並試玩電子劍擊版。民協深水埗區議會主席覃德誠亦同場,這是民主派區會主席近年罕有地獲邀出席官方活動。覃德誠對《獨媒》表示,今次應康文署邀請出席,「嚟之前唔知有咁多VIP ,以為至多有局長,唔知李家超都喺度,估唔到特首有咁多時間支持呢啲活動。」
11 Jan 2022獨媒#1778
民主派集結案審結 黃之鋒刑期最長 黎智英鄒幸彤等14人另涉國安案 還柙未見盡頭
More than 30 pro-democracy figures involved in multiple unauthorised assembly cases have all been sentenced. Joshua Wong received the longest sentence, totalling 27.5 months across three cases (after his sentence in the June 4 assembly case was reduced by two months on appeal, bringing the total sentence to 23.5 months). He was followed by Leung Kwok-hung, who received a total of 23 months’ imprisonment across four cases.
逾30名民主派牽涉多宗未經批准集結案均已判刑,其中黃之鋒刑期最長,三案合共判囚27.5個月(六四集會案刑期上訴後,刑期獲減2個月,總刑期為23.5個月),其次為梁國雄,四案合共囚23個月。
11 Dec 2021立場新聞#1722
前區議員劉珈汶多名民主派政治人物-tg-被入侵-黑客-ip-地址疑來自香港
Former Civic Party district councillor Lau Ka-man said the Telegram accounts of several former district councillors and political figures had been hacked.
前公民黨區議員劉珈汶指,多名前區議員和政治人物的Telegram帳戶被黑客入侵。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.