Lam Cheuk-ting’s Disclosure of Yau Nai-keung Investigation: Court of Final Appeal Rules 3-2 for Department of Justice, Judges Deeply Divided on Statutory Interpretation
林卓廷披露游乃強受查案 終院3比2裁定律政司得直 官就條文詮釋現明顯分歧
Lam Cheuk-ting was charged with disclosing the identity of police superintendent Yau Nai-keung, who led the search of Nam Pin Wai on 21 July and was under investigation by the ICAC. On Tuesday (1 April), the five judges of the Court of Final Appeal ruled 3-2 in favour of the Department of Justice, restoring Lam’s conviction for “disclosing the identity of a person under investigation” and the sentence of four months’ imprisonment. Lam, who is serving a sentence in another case, will have additional time added to his imprisonment; without any remission for good behaviour, he may not be released until as late as 2031. The five judges showed a clear division over how to interpret the provision under which he was charged. Chief Justice Andrew Cheung Kui-nung and Permanent Judge Li Yee considered that the legislative intent of safeguarding the confidentiality of ICAC investigations should be given greater weight, meaning that disclosing any ongoing ICAC investigation constitutes an offence. Permanent Judges Fok Siu-kong and Lam Man-hon disagreed, holding that the wording of the provision was limited to corruption investigations and could not support extending it to all ICAC investigations. After reading the judgments of the four judges, overseas non-permanent judge Au Chung-leut agreed with Cheung Kui-nung and Li Yee, saying their interpretation established rather than weakened the offence provision. The Witness asked the ICAC for its response to the ruling and an update on its investigation into Yau Nai-keung. The ICAC replied: “The ICAC respects the court’s judgment. The ICAC has no further comment on the investigation mentioned in the case.”
林卓廷被控披露 721 帶隊搜查南邊圍的警司游乃強,受廉署調查一案,終審法院 5 名法官周二(4 月 1 日)以 3 比 2 裁定律政司得直,恢復林「披露受查人身分」的定罪及 4 個月監禁的判刑。正就另案服刑的林再被加監,若沒有獄中減刑,他最遲或至 2031 年才獲釋。 5 名法官就控罪條文的詮釋方法,出現明顯分歧。首席法官張舉能、常任法官李義認為,應該側重維護廉署調查保密的立法原意,即披露任何廉署進行中的調查都屬犯禁。常任法官霍兆剛、林文瀚不同意,認為條文用語只限於貪污調查,沒法支持引伸至廉署的所有調查。 海外非常任法官歐頌律閱讀 4 名法官的判詞後,認同張舉能、李義的看法,指二人的詮釋能確立而不是削弱控罪條文。《法庭線》向廉署查詢對裁決的回應,以及對游乃強的調查進度,獲回覆指「廉署尊重法庭的裁決。對案中提及的調查,廉署沒有補充。」
