“Release order” judicial review | Order revoked, self-funded review in hope of benefiting the community — Ha Chi-wai wins: “Giving a little meaning to my life”
「釋放令」覆核案|已獲撤令、自資提覆核望造福社區 夏志偉勝訴:活出一點點意義
After several assault cases involving people with mental illness occurred in 2023, the Health Bureau considered expanding the scope of “conditional release” (CD) arrangements for psychiatric patients discharged from hospital, but ultimately shelved the plan. Ha Chi-wai, who had been subject to an order for 10 years and had failed four applications to have it revoked as well as a judicial review, filed a judicial review in the High Court at the end of the same year. It was the first such case since CD was introduced in 1988. Ha sought declarations that the Hospital Authority, the tribunal and the hospital superintendent had failed to comply with their statutory duties to explain patients’ rights to him, resulting in procedural unfairness. After waiting for more than a year and a half, the court handed down its judgment today (the 24th), ruling in Ha’s favour. It held that the hospital and the Hospital Authority had breached common-law requirements and had a duty to ensure that patients understood their right to apply for a review. Regarding the judicial review outcome, Ha said he did not yet know whether the other side would appeal, but believed that the result had already become a precedent that could help many people. “In that case, even the first half of my life, which was completely meaningless, can be said to have gained a little meaning!”
2023 年數宗涉精神病人的襲擊案件發生後,醫衞局一度考慮擴大精神科病人出院安排的「有條件釋放」(CD) 範圍,最終擱置。曾持令十年、四次申撤令兼覆核失敗的病人夏志偉,同年底入稟高等法提司法覆核,是 CD 自 1988 年實施已來的首宗案例。 夏志偉要求法庭宣告醫管局、審裁處及醫院院長沒遵照法定責任,向他解釋病人權利,構成程序不公。等待逾一年半,法院今(24日)頒下判詞,裁定夏志偉勝訴,指院方及醫管局違反普通法要求,並有責任確保病人明白申請覆核的權利。對於司法覆核結果,夏志偉說尚未知對方會否上訴,但相信現階段結果已成案例,可以幫到很多人,「這樣,完全沒有意義的前大半生,也算是活出一點點意義!」
