HONG KONG · NEWS RECORDS

Search the archive

Explore news reporting in English and traditional Chinese.

Results JSON

Statistics

4matching records

of 7107 in this collection

Records over time

Monthly distribution

0
Feb 20
0
Mar 20
0
Apr 20
0
May 20
0
Jun 20
0
Jul 20
0
Aug 20
0
Sep 20
0
Oct 20
0
Nov 20
0
Dec 20
0
Jan 21
0
Feb 21
0
Mar 21
0
Apr 21
0
May 21
0
Jun 21
0
Jul 21
0
Aug 21
0
Sep 21
0
Oct 21
0
Nov 21
0
Dec 21
0
Jan 22
0
Feb 22
0
Mar 22
0
Apr 22
0
May 22
0
Jun 22
0
Jul 22
0
Aug 22
0
Sep 22
0
Oct 22
0
Nov 22
0
Dec 22
0
Jan 23
0
Feb 23
0
Mar 23
0
Apr 23
0
May 23
0
Jun 23
0
Jul 23
0
Aug 23
0
Sep 23
1
Oct 23
2
Nov 23
1
Dec 23
0
Jan 24
0
Feb 24
0
Mar 24
0
Apr 24
0
May 24
0
Jun 24
0
Jul 24
0
Aug 24
0
Sep 24
0
Oct 24
0
Nov 24
0
Dec 24
0
Jan 25
0
Feb 25
0
Mar 25
0
Apr 25
0
May 25
0
Jun 25
0
Jul 25
0
Aug 25
0
Sep 25
0
Oct 25
0
Nov 25
0
Dec 25
About this collection

14 Feb 2020 - 24 Dec 2025

English translations accompany the original Chinese records.

Results 4

結案陳詞Clear all
Showing 1-4 of 4 recordsEN
4 Dec 2023法庭線#8751

47-person case | Oral closing submissions completed; Yue Shun Lee and Ho Kwai-lam’s sides argue “unlawful means” must involve force or criminal offences

47人案|口頭結案完成 李予信、何桂藍方指非法手段 須涵武力及涉刑事罪

The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” entered its 118th day on Monday (4th). The final two defendants, Yue Shun Lee and Ho Kwai-lam, completed their submissions on the facts and legal issues. On the facts, Yue Shun Lee’s side argued that there was insufficient evidence of Yue Shun Lee’s participation in the conspiracy, and that the prosecution had not named the Civic Party as a co-conspirator, meaning the party’s conduct could not be attributed to Yue Shun Lee. Ho’s side argued that Ho considered “35+” unworkable, and that she stood for election only to “break the deadlock”, while clearly knowing that she had no chance of becoming a Legislative Council member (see the table in the main text). On the legal issues, both sides disputed the definition of “unlawful means” in the charge. Yue Shun Lee’s side submitted that it had to encompass force or threats to use force, while Ho’s side submitted that it had to involve criminal offences. Judge Andrew Hing Wai Chan questioned the arguments by citing computer viruses and robbery lookouts as examples. Oral closing submissions by both the prosecution and defence have been completed. Judge Andrew Hing Wai Chan said a ruling could be delivered at the earliest in three to four months, but stressed that another case had to be heard and could not guarantee that the ruling would be delivered on schedule. The curfew orders on 10 defendants who had been granted bail were lifted, while the remaining six defendants continued to be remanded in custody. After the hearing, the defendants in the main courtroom and the extension courtroom waved goodbye to those in the public gallery.

47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周一(4 日)展開第 118 天審訊,最後兩名被告李予信及何桂藍均完成案情及法律爭議陳詞。就案情,李一方指,李參與串謀的證據不足,而控方沒將公民黨列為共謀者,該黨的行為也不能歸咎於李。何一方指,何認為「35+」不可行,參選只為「破局」,亦清楚知悉沒有機會成為立法會議員(見內文表)。 就法律爭議,雙方均爭議控罪條文中「非法手段」的定義,李一方提出須涵蓋武力或威脅用武,何一方則提出定義須涉刑事罪行;法官陳慶偉分別引電腦病毒及劫案哨兵為例質疑。 控辯口頭結案陳詞階段完成,法官陳慶偉料最快 3 至 4 個月後裁決,但強調須審理另案,未能保證能否如期裁決。10 名准保釋被告獲撤宵禁令,其餘 6 名被告繼續還押。散庭後,在正庭及延伸庭的被告,向旁聽揮手道別。

30 Nov 2023法庭線#8724

47 Democrats Case | Defence Continues Closing Submissions: Hectar Hei Pun Says No Intention to Implement Conspiracy; Ma Wai-kwan Says Blanket Vetoes Do Not Constitute Subversion

47人案|辯方續結案 潘熙:沒意圖執行串謀 馬維騉:無差別否決不構成顛覆

The trial of 47 democrats charged with conspiracy to subvert State power entered its 117th day on Thursday (30th). Five defendants, including Leung Kwok-hung, Chan Chi-chuen and Chow Ka-shing, completed their factual or legal closing submissions (see table in main text); Lawrence Wai Chung Lau and Sze Tak-lai filed written submissions. The remaining defendants, Gwyneth Ho and Yue Shun Lee, will make factual submissions after the defence completes its legal submissions. The case will continue next Monday. Senior counsel Hectar Hei Pun, representing Cheng Tat-hung and Leung Kwok-hung, said the two had no intention of implementing the conspiracy agreement and should not be regarded as conspirators. The judge cited case authorities and questioned Leung’s statements several times; Pan reiterated that the two had no intention of implementing the agreement and that the prosecution had not proved its case beyond reasonable doubt. Chow Ka-shing’s senior counsel Philip Sai Kit Chan said that even if there had been an agreement among the initiators of “Ink Without Regret”, it was not the agreement alleged in this case; in any event, “Ink Without Regret” was absolutely not an agreement. Counsel also said the prosecution could not treat the National Security Law as a “magic sword” and expand its interpretation without limit. Ma Wai-kwan, representing Chan Chi-chuen, said dereliction of duty was not inherently equivalent to being “illegal”, while blanket vetoes were not expressly prohibited and did not constitute subversion.

47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周四(30 日)展開第 117 天審訊。梁國雄、陳志全及鄒家成等 5 名被告完成案情或法律結案陳詞(見內文表);劉偉聰、施德來採書面陳詞。餘下的何桂藍、李予信,將待辯方完成法律陳詞後,再就案情陳詞。案件下周一續。 代表鄭達鴻、梁國雄的資深大狀潘熙指,兩人沒意圖執行串謀協議,不應被視為共謀者。法官引案例、梁的發言數度質疑;潘重申兩人沒意圖執行,控方亦未舉證至毫無合理疑點。 鄒家成代表大狀陳世傑指,〈墨落無悔〉發起人之間就算有協議,也非本案指控的協議,何況〈墨〉絕非協議;又指控方不能當《國安法》是「尚方寶劍」,不受限地拓闊詮釋。陳志全代表大狀馬維騉指,失職本質上不等同「非法」,而無差別否決沒明文禁止,也不構成顛覆。

29 Nov 2023法庭線#8712

47-person case|Closing submissions begin as prosecution says unlawful means need not involve force; judge cites remarks and posts to question defence

47人案|結案陳詞開始 控方指非法手段毋須涵蓋武力 官引發言帖文質疑辯方

The 116th day of the trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with conspiracy to subvert state power began on Wednesday (29th), with both the prosecution and defence starting oral closing submissions. On a legal dispute, the prosecution submitted that under Article 22 of the National Security Law, “unlawful means” in the offence of subversion of state power need not involve force, and that “unlawful” covers both criminal offences and abuse of power. The defence then made closing submissions on the facts of the case in turn (see the table in the main text). In summing up, the leading counsel representing Wu Chi-hang and Yu Wai-ming, Randy Shu Ming Shek, said that Wu and Yu did not advocate bloodshed or killings, nor did they seek to overthrow the constitutional order. The counsel also said that their wish for the authorities to honour their promises, bring about political change in accordance with the constitutional order, and implement the Basic Law’s commitment to universal suffrage for both elections “could not possibly be subversion”. During submissions by the representatives of Lam Cheuk-ting, Helena Wong Pik-wan, Clarisse Yeung Suet-ying and Ho Kai-ming, the judge cited remarks made at forums and Facebook posts, questioning references to “using up the powers within the constitutional framework” and “vetoing any funding for criminal organisations”. The defence responded that the remarks referred only to powers under the Basic Law and did not mean indiscriminate vetoes. The judge also rejected the defence’s application to adjourn submissions on the legal dispute until this Friday. In response to the defence, the judge said the case was expected to require a further three to four months before a verdict could be delivered. The case will continue on Thursday.

47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周三(29 日)展開第 116 天審訊,控辯雙方開始口頭結案陳詞。控方就法律爭議陳詞,指《國安法》第 22 條「顛覆國家政權罪」下,「非法手段」毋須涵蓋武力,而「非法」涉及刑事罪行及濫權兩層面。 辯方其後依次就案情作結案陳詞(見內文表),吳政亨、余慧明的代表大狀石書銘總結時指,吳、余不主張流血殺戮,亦非尋求推翻憲制秩序,又指兩人想政權信守諾言、根據憲制帶來政治改變,以及實踐《基本法》承諾的雙普選,皆「不可能是顛覆」。 林卓廷、黃碧雲、楊雪盈、何啟明的代表陳詞時,法官引述論壇發言、FB 帖文等質疑曾提及「用盡憲制入面權力」、「否決對犯罪組織的任何撥款」,辯方回應稱僅指《基本法》權力及並非無差別否決。 此外,法官拒絕辯方申請押後至本周五就法律爭議陳詞,並在回答辯方時指,預計本案需要 3 至 4 個月後方可裁決。案件周四續。

7 Oct 2023法庭線#8458

47-democrat case | Prosecution said to have submitted over 1,200 pages of closing submissions; judge says page limit exceeded, orders reduction within two weeks

47人案|據悉控方交逾1,200頁結案陳詞 官指頁數超限制、限兩周內縮減

In the case involving 47 democrats charged with conspiracy to subvert state power, the 16 defendants who pleaded not guilty and are standing trial have completed their case. The prosecution and defence are preparing closing submissions, with the next hearing tentatively scheduled for November 27. It is understood that the prosecution submitted written closing submissions to the court and the defence in early October. Together with the appendices, they exceeded 1,200 pages, prompting a complaint from the defence that the page limit had been exceeded. Judge Andrew Hing Wai Chan issued directions on Friday (the 6th), returning the submissions to the prosecution and ordering it to reduce them to the specified page limit and resubmit them within two weeks. The defence was correspondingly granted an additional two weeks to prepare. The Court Line made enquiries with the Department of Justice and the Judiciary. A Department of Justice spokesperson said it would not comment on details of the case, while the Judiciary said it did not comment on individual cases. According to directions issued by Andrew Hing Wai Chan on the 115th day of the trial (August 28), the prosecution was required to submit written closing submissions on October 3 (Tuesday of that week), with each defendant limited to 35 pages. For 16 defendants, this meant a maximum of 560 pages.

47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,16 名不認罪受審被告已完成案情,控辯正準備結案陳詞,暫訂 11 月 27 日再訊。 據悉,控方 10 月初向法庭及辯方遞交書面結案陳詞,連同附錄共逾 1,200 頁,被辯方投訴指超出頁數限制。法官陳慶偉周五(6日)頒下指示,將陳詞交還控方,下令兩周內刪減至指定頁數再提交;辯方亦獲相應延長兩周時間準備。 《法庭線》向律政司及司法機構查詢。律政司發言人指,不會對案件細節作評論;司法機構指不評論個別案件。據陳慶偉在案件第 115 日審訊(8 月 28 日)下達的指示,控方須在 10 月 3 日(本周二)遞交書面結案陳詞,每名被告限 35 頁,以 16 名被告計,即上限為 560 頁。

Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.