7 Oct 2023法庭線#8458
47人案|據悉控方交逾1,200頁結案陳詞 官指頁數超限制、限兩周內縮減
In the case involving 47 democrats charged with conspiracy to subvert state power, the 16 defendants who pleaded not guilty and are standing trial have completed their case. The prosecution and defence are preparing closing submissions, with the next hearing tentatively scheduled for November 27.
It is understood that the prosecution submitted written closing submissions to the court and the defence in early October. Together with the appendices, they exceeded 1,200 pages, prompting a complaint from the defence that the page limit had been exceeded. Judge Andrew Hing Wai Chan issued directions on Friday (the 6th), returning the submissions to the prosecution and ordering it to reduce them to the specified page limit and resubmit them within two weeks. The defence was correspondingly granted an additional two weeks to prepare.
The Court Line made enquiries with the Department of Justice and the Judiciary. A Department of Justice spokesperson said it would not comment on details of the case, while the Judiciary said it did not comment on individual cases. According to directions issued by Andrew Hing Wai Chan on the 115th day of the trial (August 28), the prosecution was required to submit written closing submissions on October 3 (Tuesday of that week), with each defendant limited to 35 pages. For 16 defendants, this meant a maximum of 560 pages.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,16 名不認罪受審被告已完成案情,控辯正準備結案陳詞,暫訂 11 月 27 日再訊。
據悉,控方 10 月初向法庭及辯方遞交書面結案陳詞,連同附錄共逾 1,200 頁,被辯方投訴指超出頁數限制。法官陳慶偉周五(6日)頒下指示,將陳詞交還控方,下令兩周內刪減至指定頁數再提交;辯方亦獲相應延長兩周時間準備。
《法庭線》向律政司及司法機構查詢。律政司發言人指,不會對案件細節作評論;司法機構指不評論個別案件。據陳慶偉在案件第 115 日審訊(8 月 28 日)下達的指示,控方須在 10 月 3 日(本周二)遞交書面結案陳詞,每名被告限 35 頁,以 16 名被告計,即上限為 560 頁。
2 Sept 2023獨媒#8308
【初選47人案】第廿九周審訊整理 控辯雙方舉證完畢 暫定11.27結案陳詞
The 47 defendants were involved in organising and participating in the pan-democratic primary election, with 16 pleading not guilty to conspiracy to subvert state power. The trial entered its 29th week. The final defendant, Yu Wai-ming, completed her testimony this week, stressing that she had always sought to pursue the “five demands, not one less”, and that voting down the budget was a lawful and reasonable means. Yu also described each legislator as an independent individual who could not be forced to join others in voting down the budget.
47人涉組織及參與民主派初選,16人否認「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪,進入審訊第二十九周。最後一名被告余慧明本周完成作供,強調一直想爭取「五大訴求,缺一不可」,而否決預算案是合法、合理的手段;余又形容每個議員為獨立個體,無法迫人聯手否決。
28 Aug 2023法庭線#8274
47人案|余慧明完成作供 辯方案情完結 暫押後11.27續審處理結案陳詞
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with conspiracy to subvert state power entered its 115th day on Tuesday (the 28th), with the final defendant, Yu Wai-ming, completing four days of testimony. Under questioning by the prosecution, Yu reiterated that she had consistently sought “five demands, not one less”, saying she did not consider it unlawful even after the National Security Law was enacted, and that voting down the budget was a lawful and reasonable means.
After Yu completed her testimony, the defence case also concluded. The judge provisionally adjourned the hearing until Nov. 27 to deal with closing submissions from the prosecution and defence, which are expected to take two to three weeks. Both sides must submit written submissions by the end of October and early November respectively.
Judge Andrew Hing Wai Chan also said that if the hearing then clashes with Jimmy Lai’s national security case, Lai’s case might have to be adjourned. Judge Li Wan-tang, who is responsible for that case, said he believed counsel in that case would not object to an adjournment. The judge also said that during the adjournment, the court might deal with factual disputes concerning defendants who had pleaded guilty, but would not deal with mitigation.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周二(28 日)展開第 115 天審訊,最後一名被告余慧明完成四日作供。控方盤問下,余重申一直爭取「五大訴求缺一不可」,稱即使《國安法》通過後,都不認為是違法,又指否決預算案是合法、合理的手段。
余完成作供後,辯方案情亦告完結。法官暫定押後至 11 月 27 日再開庭,處理控辯結案陳詞,料需時 2 至 3 周,而雙方須於 10 月底及 11 月初提交書面陳詞。
法官陳慶偉又指,若屆時續審與黎智英國安案撞期,黎案或需要押後。有份負責該案的法官李運騰亦指,相信該案大狀亦不介意押後。法官另稱,押後待續期間,或會處理認罪被告的案情爭議,但指不會處理求情。
24 Aug 2023法庭線#8249
47人案|余慧明:衞生服務界初選結果無約束力 無開協調會議、無接收協議文件
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with conspiracy to subvert state power entered its 113th day on Thursday (24th). Yau Wai-ming gave evidence for a second day, saying candidates in the Health Services sector primary had disputed how voters’ eligibility should be determined, and that the organisers ultimately decided the sector’s primary result would not be binding. Yau also said the Health Services sector had not held a primary coordination meeting. She had invited four candidates to a meeting, but only Michael Felix Hoi Man Lau attended. Yau further testified that she had neither received nor seen the sector’s coordination agreement document.
The defence also questioned Yau about her manifesto. Yau said that, as stated in the manifesto, she would “exercise the right to oppose and oppose all (government) motions”, but that this “does not mean I do not look at the content”. The judge questioned whether Yau appeared to have decided to oppose a motion first and then looked for reasons. Yau said her preset position was to vote against it, “unless I could not find any reason to oppose that motion.”
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周四(24 日)展開第 113 天審訊,余慧明第二日作供,稱衞生服務界的初選參選人曾就如何確定選民資格一事有爭議,而最終組織者決定該界別的初選結果無約束力。余又指,衞服界沒開過初選協調會議,她曾邀請 4 名參選人開會,惟只有前線護士劉凱文出席。余又供稱,沒有收過或看過界別的協調協議文件。
另辯方引余的政綱作提問,余稱如政綱所言,她會「行使反對嘅權利,反對一切(政府)議案」,但「唔代表我唔睇個內容」。法官質疑,余似是決定要反對,再找出理由。余稱,預設立場是投反對票,「除非嗰個議案係令我搵唔到任何一個反對嘅原因。」
24 Aug 2023法庭線#8252
47人案|衞服界4參選人就確認選民資格現分歧 控方指達共識需約束 余慧明不同意
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with conspiracy to subvert state power entered its 114th day on Friday (25th). Yu Wai-ming gave evidence for a third day and completed her examination-in-chief. It emerged in court that the four candidates in the Health Services constituency primary differed over how voters’ eligibility should be verified, and held different views on four voting arrangements. Benny Tai ultimately decided that the result would not be binding in light of the circumstances.
Under questioning by the prosecution, Yu agreed that she wanted the result to be binding, and said Tai’s decision was “an unavoidable method”, because Tai had said that if everyone did not accept it, he would not hold a primary for the constituency. The prosecution pointed out that Yu and the other candidates had in fact reached a consensus that the primary’s result should be binding. Yu replied: “I disagree, because we did not discuss that.”
Yu also testified that she did not believe the purpose of the “protest camp press conference” was to announce the continuation of the “35+” plan after the organisers halted the primary. She said that, according to her understanding, the plan had already ended after polling day for the primary.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周五(25 日)展開第 114 天審訊,余慧明第三日作供,完成主問。綜合庭上,初選衞生服務界 4 名參選人,就如何核實投票人的選民資格有分歧,並對投票安排的 4 個方案有不同取態,戴耀廷終因應情況決定結果不具約束力。
控方盤問下,余同意想結果有約束力,而戴的決定是「無可奈可的方法」,指因戴說如各人不接受就不會為該界別辦初選。控方指出,事實上余與其他參選人達成共識,即初選的結果要有約束力;余答,「不同意,因為我哋無討論到囉。」
余另供稱,不認為「抗爭派記者會」的目的,是在組織者中止初選後,宣布繼續「35+」計劃;稱按其理解,計劃在初選投票日後已經結束。
23 Aug 2023法庭線#8241
47人案|余慧明首日作供 稱參選因見證政府對訴求視若無睹 欲爭足夠話語權
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with conspiracy to subvert state power entered its 112th day on Wednesday (23rd). Yu Wai-ming, who ran in the Health Services functional constituency and was formerly chairwoman of the Hospital Authority Employees Alliance, began giving evidence. She said she had witnessed the government turn a blind eye to public demands in 2019 and “only use force to suppress” them. She also promoted a healthcare workers’ strike to urge the government to close the border. This made her realise that without sufficient influence, “the regime or those in power would not talk to me”, and she therefore decided to run. Yu said she was concerned that potential candidates in the Health Services constituency might split the vote, resulting in “the snipe and the clam fighting while the establishment benefits”. She therefore contacted Benny Tai and proposed holding a primary for the Health Services constituency alongside the district direct-election primaries. She said Tai replied that the possibility would be discussed depending on the circumstances. The defence also referred to articles written by Yu and asked her to explain several passages. Regarding the statement that the purpose was to “fully veto all proposals put forward by the government”, Yu explained that “this was only a stance, not a threat”. She said that, in contrast to the pan-democrats’ approach of “negotiating and building at the same time”, her own approach was to “build first, then negotiate”, and that she took a firmer stance than the pan-democrats. The case will continue on Thursday.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周三(23 日)展開第 112 天審訊,參選衛生服務界、前「醫管局員工陣線」主席余慧明開始作供,稱見證 2019 年政府對市民訴求視若無睹,「只係一味武力打壓」,另推動醫護罷工促政府封關,令她明白若無足夠話語權,「政權或者當權者係唔會同我傾」,故決定參選。
余又稱,她因擔心衛生服務界潛在參選人間,或因𠝹票致「鷸蚌相爭,建制得利」,遂聯絡戴耀廷,提出辦地區直選初選時,「搭單」為衛服界舉辦初選,又引述戴當時覆視乎可能性再議。
辯方亦引余所撰文章,要求解釋多個段落,當中就「全面否決所有政府提出的議案為目的」一段,余解釋「依個只係一個姿態,唔係一個恐嚇」。余又指相對泛民「又傾又砌」,自己是「先砌後傾」,較泛民「企得硬啲」。案件周四續。
22 Aug 2023法庭線#8226
47人案|李予信完成作供 稱公民黨不支持攬炒 理解黨對否決預算案有彈性
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” entered its 111th day on Tuesday (22nd). Yue Shun Lee completed four days of testimony, while the defence case has so far taken 46 days (see table in the article). Yu Wai-ming, who is standing in the Health Services constituency, is expected to begin testifying on Wednesday.
Yue Shun Lee testified that she had seen the “No Regrets Once the Ink Is Spilled” statement but had not examined it closely. The prosecution cited a forum document prepared by the Civic Party for primary election candidates, which said that vetoing the budget could force the government to implement the five demands. Yue Shun Lee testified that the document was not binding and reflected flexibility that “existed very vaguely”, and that she had not mentioned vetoing the budget or related matters at the primary election forum.
The prosecution also cited a Civic Party Facebook post, noting that it did not mention that there was flexibility over vetoing the budget, and asked whether Yue Shun Lee had asked Jeremy Tam about it and confronted him. She said she had not: “But he encouraged me to continue holding to the platform I originally wanted to talk about.” She also said that when Bill Yan Piau Lay called to invite her to stand in the New Territories West constituency, “he did not put any pressure on me or tell me that I had to make certain promises.”
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周二(22 日)展開第 111 天審訊,李予信完成共 4 天作供,辯方案情至今處理 46 天(見內文表),預料參選衛生服務界的余慧明周三開始作供。
李供稱,有看過〈墨落無悔〉聲明但沒深究。控方引用公民黨為初選參選人準備的論壇文件,寫有可透過否決預算案逼使政府落實五大訴求等。李予信供稱,文件沒約束力,並反映彈性「好模糊地存在」,而自己於初選論壇沒說過否決預算案等。
控方又引用公民黨 Facebook 帖文,指沒提及否決預算案是有彈性,問李有否問譚文豪,與他對質?李稱沒有,「但係佢鼓勵我繼續去持有我本來想講嘅政綱」,並指獲賴仁彪致電參選超區時,「佢亦都無俾任何嘅壓力,叫我一定要去講某啲嘅承諾」。
21 Aug 2023法庭線#8225
47人案|李予信稱不會跟隨公民黨「莊嚴承諾」否決預算案 法官屢質疑
The trial of 47 pro-democracy defendants charged with conspiracy to subvert state power entered its 110th day on Monday (21st), with Yue Shun Lee beginning cross-examination by the prosecution. The prosecution cited Alvin Yeung as saying at a Civic Party press conference that, if the government did not respond to the “five demands”, it would vote down every bill and funding proposal, describing this as a “solemn promise”.
Lee said he understood that the promise might not be honoured, and that he would not follow the party’s position in voting down the budget because this was related to his original reason for standing for election. The prosecution questioned Lee on not having publicly said that he would not follow the party’s position. Lee confirmed this, but reiterated that legislators had previously voted differently from the party, and that if his application for an exemption from voting along the party line was not approved, he “would still vote according to my own intention”.
Lee also testified that Alvin Yeung had instructed him to register to stand in the Hong Kong Island direct election, and that he understood he was not Cheng Tat-hung’s “Plan B”. He said he had not asked the primary election organisers about the coordination consensus, and had only asked senior party members about the rules for the super-district constituency. He did not know how the consensus was related to the remarks at the party press conference. Separately, counsel representing Yau Wai-ming said that, following Yau’s latest instructions, she would testify, which was expected to take several days.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周一(21 日)展開第 110 天審訊,李予信開始接受控方盤問,控方引楊岳橋於公民黨記者會稱政府若不回應「五大訴求」,會否決每個法案及撥款,並稱為「莊嚴承諾」。
李稱,理解該承諾未必會兌現,而自己不會跟隨黨立場否決預算案,因與參選初衷有關。控方質疑,李沒公開提及不跟從黨立場;李確認沒有,但重申過往曾發生議員投票與黨不一致,而若屆時申豁免隨黨立場投票不獲批,「都會照跟自己嘅意向投票」。
李又供稱,曾獲楊岳橋指示報名參選港島區直選,並理解自己不是鄭達鴻的「Plan B」。他又指,沒向初選組織者查詢協調共識,僅向黨高層問及超區規則,不知共識與黨記者會的發言有何關聯。另外,余慧明代表大狀稱,獲余最新指示將會作供,料需時數天。
18 Aug 2023法庭線#8210
47人案|李予信稱街頭被捕後獲公民黨准出選 曾向譚文豪表達想爭取撥款
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with “conspiracy to subvert state power” entered its 109th day on Friday (18th). Yue Shun Lee gave evidence for a second day, saying that after Wong Man-hyun decided not to contest the super-district constituency, the Civic Party sought someone to fill the vacancy. He applied, but the party rejected him because of funding and his chances of winning.
Li continued that after he was arrested in Causeway Bay on suspicion of unlawful assembly on the first anniversary of 12 June, the party said it had received donations and eventually approved him to represent it in the super-district primary. He ultimately lost with few votes and announced that he would not contest the general election (see the chronology table in the full article). Li said he did not take part in discussions about whether the party should sign “No Regrets After the Ink Is Cast”, or repost related posts, and that he did not mention rejecting the budget bill at the primary-election forum.
Li also said that before applying to contest the super-district seat, Jeremy Tam had asked about his intention to run. Li told Tam that he wanted to seek funding, which might differ from the Civic Party’s position of rejecting funding. Li considered Tam’s remarks at the time to imply that there was flexibility and that the matter could be dealt with after he successfully secured the nomination. The trial will continue next Monday.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周五(18 日)展開第 109 天審訊,李予信第二日作供,稱黃文萱不參選超區後,公民黨找人填補,而自己提出申請惟公民黨因資金及勝算而拒絕。
不過李續稱,自己於 6.12 一周年在銅鑼灣被指涉非法集結拘捕後,黨稱獲捐獻,終批准由他代表參與超區初選;他最後低票落敗,宣布不參加正選(時序請看內文表)。李稱,沒參與黨簽否〈墨落無悔〉的討論或轉發有關帖文,而在初選論壇上亦沒提及否決預算案。
李另提及,他申請參加超區前,譚文豪曾問他出選意向,李向譚提及他欲爭取撥款,與公民黨否決撥款的立場或有出入,認為譚當時說法,「言下之意」是有彈性、成功出線再算。案件下周一續審。
17 Aug 2023法庭線#8208
47人案|李予信:公民黨記者會有混合訊息 有人提否決所有撥款、有人似乎不會
The trial of 47 pro-democracy figures charged with conspiracy to subvert the state power entered its 108th day on Thursday (the 17th), when Yue Shun Lee, who had run in the super district council constituency in the primary election, began giving evidence. Yue Shun Lee said they had studied social work at The Chinese University of Hong Kong, became a social worker in 2019, and aspired to work in the community and with young people.
The prosecution said in its opening that Li had attended a Civic Party press conference in March 2020, at which Alvin Yeung mentioned vetoing every government bill and financial appropriation. Li testified that the speakers had conveyed “mixed messages”: Li heard Alvin Yeung and others talk about vetoing all funding, but Kwok Ka-ki appeared not to support vetoing all funding.
Li also testified that they met Cheng Tat-hung and others in 2016 while assisting with the Civic Party’s Legislative Council election campaign, and later joined the party and stood for election to the District Council after being lobbied by Cheng. Li was elected as an Eastern District councillor. Cheng later proposed that Li be placed second on his list for the 2020 Legislative Council election, but Li declined and subsequently stood in the super district council constituency under the party’s “drafting mechanism”. The trial will continue on Friday.
47 名民主派被控「串謀顛覆國家政權」罪一案,周四(17 日)展開第 108 天審訊,初選參選超區的李予信開始作供,稱修讀中大社工學系,2019 年成為社工,有志做社會、青年工作。
控方開案稱李有份出席 2020 年 3 月公民黨記者會,而楊岳橋發言提及否決每個政府議案、財政撥款。李供稱,發言者當時表達「混合訊息」,他聽到楊岳橋等人否決所有撥款的說法,但郭家麒的說法又似乎不會否決所有撥款。
李又供稱,2016 年因協助公民黨立會選舉而認識鄭達鴻等人,後獲鄭遊說入黨並出選區議會,並當選東區區議員。鄭曾提出 2020 年立會選舉時,李排其名單第二,惟李拒絕,李其後響應黨內「徵召機制」出選超區。案件周五續。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.