31 Jul 2024法庭線#3864
反恐首案|控方結案:「屠龍」成員「行山」試槍後 知悉及加入串謀殺警計劃
In the first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants have pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 62nd day at the High Court on Wednesday (31st), with the prosecution continuing its closing submissions. It said the defendants involved in the “Dragon Slaying Brigade squad” knew of and joined a conspiracy to kill police officers no later than November 2019, after going “hiking” in Sai Kung to test-fire guns.
The prosecution said that after the test-firing, a “Dragon Slaying Brigade” defendant took a handgun, and under the original plan, “Dragon Slaying Brigade” would use firearms. However, after the “Dragon Slaying Brigade” captain Victor Chun Keung Wong met co-conspirator Ng Chi-hung, Victor Chun Keung Wong told members that there was a new plan and that there was “no need to carry out the Glasses plan”. The prosecution said this showed that the “plan to kill police” had already taken shape at that time.
The prosecution also cited “Dragon Slaying Brigade” Telegram messages, saying that the term “20KG” had appeared. Apart from one member who did not attend the meeting, no one else had asked what it meant, indicating that “Dragon Slaying Brigade” had reached an agreement with Ng Chi-hung’s side to use bombs and firearms.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周三(31 日)在高等法院踏入第 62 天審訊。控方續作結案陳詞,指涉及「屠龍小隊」的被告,最遲於 2019 年 11 月到西貢「行山」試槍後,知悉及加入串謀殺警計劃。
控方指,試槍後有「屠龍」被告拿取手槍,而按照原定計劃,「屠龍」會使用槍械;但「屠龍」隊長黃振強與同謀者吳智鴻見面後,黃向成員稱有新計劃,「唔使行眼鏡 plan 」。控方指由此可見,當時「殺警計劃」已成形。
控方另引述「屠龍」TG 通訊,指當中曾出現「20KG」字眼,除沒參與會議的一成員外,其他人未曾問及有何意思,反映「屠龍」已與吳智鴻一方達成協議,將使用炸彈和槍械。
30 Jul 2024法庭線#3860
反恐首案|控方結案:擲汽油彈屬恐怖主義行為 各被告協議作不法目的 可互不相識
In the first case under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants pleaded not guilty and the trial entered its 61st day at the High Court on Tuesday (the 30th). The prosecution began its closing submissions, saying that conspiring to place bombs, use firearms, throw petrol bombs and damage public facilities all constituted acts of terrorism. Regarding one defendant charged with assisting in raising funds, the prosecution said the offence did not have to be connected with bombs or firearms, or require proof that the defendant had any role in the 12.8 “plan to kill police officers”.
The prosecution also said the defendants had agreed to pursue an unlawful purpose. They could have joined at different times, might not have known one another and did not need to know each other’s roles, as long as they knew the agreement’s ultimate purpose. Regarding a defendant’s complaint that he had confessed after being assaulted by police, the prosecution said the jury should observe his demeanour during recorded interviews and consider whether he “looked like he had been beaten for 30 to 45 minutes”.
The prosecution also referred to the accomplice witness, Victor Chun Keung Wong, who described himself as the captain of Dragon Slaying Brigade, as “fond of showing off and good food, and a compulsive gambler”. However, large sums of money suddenly flowed to him during the anti-extradition bill protests. The prosecution asked, “How many young people in their early 20s have seen more than a million?” It stressed that the Telegram messages relating to the case were consistent with his testimony, and that the jury should consider his manner and conduct while giving evidence in deciding whether to accept his testimony.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周二(30 日)在高等法院踏入第 61 天審訊。控方開始結案陳詞,指各被告串謀放置炸彈、使用槍械,以至擲汽油彈、破壞公共設施均屬恐怖主義行為。就一被告被控協助籌錢,控方指,此罪毋須與炸彈或槍械有關,或證明被告在 12.8「殺警計劃」中有任何角色。
控方又指,各被告協議作不法目的,各人可在不同時間加入、可互不相識、亦毋須知別人崗位,只須知道協議的最終目的。至於有被告投訴被警施襲而作招認,控方認為應觀察其錄影會面時神態,「似唔似俾人打咗 30 至 45 分鐘」。
控方另提及,從犯證人、自稱「屠龍」隊長的黃振強「貪威識食、爛賭」,但他在反修例時忽然有大額款項湧入,「有幾多個後生仔,廿歲出頭見過百幾萬?」,強調涉案 TG 訊息與其證供脗合,陪審團應留意其作供言行舉止等,去決定是否信納其供詞。
30 Jul 2024法庭線#3861
涉2019年串謀製爆炸品炸「狗屋」 3男判囚8年4月至12年 官:行為有如向警方宣戰
Three men were accused of testing an improvised explosive device on Siu Leng Shui Road in Tuen Mun in December 2019 for use against police, but the test failed. They were charged with one count of conspiracy to cause an explosion of a nature likely to endanger life or cause serious damage to property. Two pleaded guilty, while the other, who was 27 at the time of the offence, was convicted after trial. On Tuesday (30th), Judge Lai Yuen-ki sentenced the two defendants who pleaded guilty to between 8 years 4 months and 8 years 7 months in prison, and sentenced the defendant convicted after trial to 12 years’ imprisonment.
The judge criticised the defendants for intending to endanger police officers and targeting roadblocks and police stations, while disregarding public safety. She said the case occurred during the social unrest in 2019, when violence and attacks on police occurred frequently, and that the conduct was akin to declaring war on law enforcement personnel and the police. The defendants had committed the offences against police who were facing difficulties in enforcing the law at the time, and their conduct was evil. Had police not stopped them in time, the consequences would have been unimaginable.
3 名男子於 2019 年 12 月,在屯門小冷水路,涉試驗土製爆炸裝置後用作對付警方,但試驗失敗。他們被控一項「串謀導致性質相當可能會危害生命或對財產造成嚴重損害的爆炸」罪。當中兩男認罪,另一名案發時 27 歲的男子則經審訊後被裁定罪成。法官黎婉姫周二(30 日)於高等法院判兩認罪被告監禁 8 年 4 個月至 8 年 7 個月,受審後罪成被告則判囚 12 年。
法官批評,被告意圖危害警員,並以路障及警署為目標,罔顧市民安全。法官又指,本案發生於 2019 年社會動盪期間,暴力及襲警事件時有發生,本案行為有如向執法人員及警方宣戰。被告針對當時執法困難的警方犯案,行為邪惡。假若警方沒有及時制止被告,後果不堪設想。
26 Jul 2024法庭線#3853
7.1銅鑼灣|20歲男縱火等罪成囚6年提上訴 上訴庭:情況「微妙」交3法官處理許可
On 1 July 2020, a procession was organised on Hong Kong Island to protest the implementation of the National Security Law. A 17-year-old male student at the time, the son of a retired police officer, was alleged to have possessed petrol bombs and set fire to a Maxim’s Cakes outlet with others. He was convicted of four offences, including arson, and sentenced to six years’ imprisonment. He appealed against the sentence, arguing that he was young at the time of the offence, had worked hard towards rehabilitation in prison and had the support of his wife, and seeking to obtain a training centre report again.
After hearing submissions on Friday (26th), Court of Appeal judge Pang Wai-cheong said the case had “delicate aspects”. The application for leave to appeal will be handled further by a panel of three Court of Appeal judges.
2020 年 7 月 1 日,有人發起港島區遊行,抗議《國安法》實施,一名退休警員兒子、案發時 17 歲男學生涉攜有汽油彈,與其他人到美心西餅縱火,被裁定縱火等 4 罪成,判囚 6 年。他不服刑期提上訴,爭議他案發時年輕、在獄中努力更生、獲太太支持,冀重新索取勞教中心報告。
上訴庭法官彭偉昌周五(26 日)聽罷陳詞,認為案件「有佢微妙嘅地方」,將交由 3 名上訴庭法官組成的合議庭,再處理上訴許可申請。
24 Jul 2024法庭線#3848
20歲男生涉2020年APM非法集結 踢保4年後回港時重新被捕 認罪還押候判
On the eve of the National Security Law for Hong Kong taking effect in 2020, netizens organised a “Sing With You” protest at the APM mall in Kwun Tong. Police subsequently entered the mall to disperse the protesters, and four people were arrested that day. More than four years later, another 20-year-old male student was charged with participating in an illegal assembly and appeared in court for the first time last Tuesday (the 16th). At a further hearing on Wednesday (the 24th), the defendant pleaded guilty and was remanded in custody until August 12 for sentencing, pending reports from a rehabilitation centre, detention centre and training centre. The facts of the case stated that the defendant displayed a blue flag bearing the words “Hong Kong independence” at the APM mall. After his arrest, he dropped bail and was re-arrested when he returned to Hong Kong in mid-July.
2020 年《港區國安法》生效前夕,有網民在觀塘 APM 商場發起「和你 Sing」示威活動,警方其後入商場驅散,當日有 4 人被捕。事隔逾四年,再有一名 20 歲男學生被控參與非法集結罪,上周二(16 日)首次提堂。
被告周三(24 日)再訊時認罪,續還押至 8 月 12 日判刑,等候索取更生中心、勞教中心及教導所報告。案情指,被告在 APM 商場展示有「香港獨立」字眼的藍旗,他被捕後一度「踢保」,7 月中回港時重新被捕。
23 Jul 2024法庭線#3843
11.18油麻地|兩男暴動罪成判囚5年 官稱受審後才表示悔疚「口惠而實不至」
On 18 November 2019, police cordoned off the Polytechnic University. A total of 213 people were charged with rioting in Yau Ma Tei in an attempt to “besiege Wei to rescue Zhao”, and the cases were split for trial. In one of the cases, six people pleaded guilty before the trial began. The remaining two pleaded not guilty but were convicted after trial, and were sentenced to five years’ imprisonment at the District Court on Tuesday (23rd).
In sentencing, Judge Adriana Noelle Tse Ching said the two defendants only expressed remorse after the trial, which amounted to “mere lip service”. The judge also said that personal physical and family factors did not constitute grounds for a reduced sentence, and sentenced both men to five years’ imprisonment.
2019 年 11 月 18 日,警方圍封理工大學,213 人涉在油麻地「圍魏救趙」被控暴動,分拆成多案審理。其中一案 6 人開審前認罪,餘下兩人不認罪受審後罪成,周二(23 日)在區域法院被判囚 5 年。
法官謝沈智慧判刑時稱,兩名被告經審訊後才表示悔疚,是「口惠而實不至」,並指個人身體、家庭等因素均不構成減刑理由,判兩人監禁 5 年。
21 Jul 2024集誌社#3837
7.21 五年.元朗|西鐵站獻花默站 十多人快閃舉五一手勢
Today marks the fifth anniversary of the Yuen Long 7.21 incident. On that day, white-clad men attacked members of the public with rattan sticks and other weapons at Yuen Long West Rail Station and elsewhere. The government condemned the white-clad men at the time with terms including “lawless and outrageous” and “rioters”. Five years on, the official narrative has gradually shifted to saying that both sides were “evenly matched”; non-white-clad people, including former Legislative Council member Lam Cheuk-ting, have been arrested and charged. This afternoon, three uniformed police officers patrolled the station together. A man wearing black was checked at the station. Around dusk, members of the public arrived to lay flowers and observe a silent vigil. In the evening, more than 10 people briefly flashed a “5-1”, or five-finger, gesture.
今日是元朗 7.21 事件五周年,當日在的元朗西鐵站等地,白衣人曾以籐件等武器襲擊市民,政府曾以「目無法紀、令人髮指」、「暴徒」等字眼譴責白衣人,五年下來,官方漸漸指雙方「勢鈞力敵,旗鼓相當」、前立法會議員林卓廷等非白衣人被捕、被控。今日下午,在元朗西鐵站,有軍裝警三人一組,在站內巡邏。有穿黑衫褲男子西鐵站被查。黃昏時份,有市民到場獻花、默站。晚上,十多人快閃舉五一,或五字手勢。
20 Jul 2024法庭線#3834
陳真遭「私了」案 5人暴動等罪成 判囚3年半至5年3個月
Middle-aged unemployed man Joe Chen was alleged to have bitten off the left ear of former Eastern District councillor Chao Ka-hin and injured him with a knife outside Cityplaza on 3 November 2019, before himself being struck and attacked by others. Six men were charged with rioting and wounding with intent, among other offences. Four pleaded guilty; of the other two, one was convicted and one acquitted after trial. The five convicted men were sentenced at the District Court on Saturday (20th) to between 3½ years and 5 years 3 months in prison.
Acting Judge Ko Wai-hung cited the defence's mitigation submissions, which said that one defendant was a member of Hong Kong teams for kabaddi and dodgeball, while another was a singer-songwriter who had been signed by a Taiwanese record company, but whose contract was suspended after the company learned of his arrest. Another defendant obtained a fitness instructor licence while awaiting trial.
The judge said he agreed that the victim, Joe Chen, had provoked the crowd's emotions, but said that whatever the brutality and irrationality of his actions, particularly after he had fallen to the ground, the crowd's continued assault could no longer be regarded as lawful or reasonable. He said the defendants' actions were tantamount to “taking matters into their own hands”.
Court records show that Joe Chen was charged with wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm and other offences, convicted and sentenced to 14½ years in prison. His appeal against sentence succeeded in May this year, reducing the sentence to 14 years' imprisonment.
中年無業漢陳真涉於 2019 年 11 月 3 日,於太古城中心外,咬甩前東區區議員趙家賢左耳及持刀傷人,後亦遭其他人擲物、攻擊。6 男被控暴動、有意圖傷人等罪,4 人認罪,另兩人受審後一人罪成、一人罪脫。罪成 5 人周六(20 日)在區院被判囚 3 年半至 5 年 3 個月。
暫委法官高偉雄引述辯方求情稱,有被告為卡巴迪及躲避盤的港隊成員,另為唱作音樂人,曾獲台灣唱片公司簽約,但知悉他被捕後則中止合約;亦有被告候審期間考取健身教練牌照。
官指,同意事主陳真有挑動眾人情緒,但指陳的所作所為即使如何兇殘及不理性,尤其陳倒地後,群眾仍施襲,已不可能視為合法或合理,又指被告的行為等同「私了」。
翻查資料,陳真被起訴蓄意嚴重傷人等罪,罪成被判囚 14 年半,今年 5 月刑罰上訴得直,減刑至判囚 14 年。
19 Jul 2024法庭線#3827
11.18油麻地|23人被控暴動 12人開審前認罪 判囚3年至3年4月
On 18 November 2019, police cordoned off the Polytechnic University. A large number of people attempted to “besiege Wei to rescue Zhao”, and 213 people were arrested in the area around Pitt Street in Yau Ma Tei. The cases were divided into several trials. In a case involving 23 people, 12 pleaded guilty before trial and were sentenced at the District Court on Friday (19th) to between 3 years and 3 years 4 months’ imprisonment.
Acting Judge Peony Nga Yan Wong said the protest scene had reached a peak of 2,000 people. Most wore dark or black clothing and had equipment including helmets and masks. The judge said their clothing showed that the protesters had planned in detail and were “well prepared for battle”.
In addition to the reduction for pleading guilty, the judge noted that one defendant had graduated with first-class honours in chemistry and was pursuing a doctoral degree, but had to suspend the studies because of the case. The defendant also had to put on hold plans to publish a paper in an international scientific journal. Another defendant was studying for a master’s degree while working part-time, and took three distance-learning courses while remanded in custody. The two defendants each received a further four-month reduction in sentence. The judge also took into account that five people had not given up on themselves and had studied diligently and actively, granting them an additional two-month reduction in sentence.
2019 年 11 月 18 日,警方圍封理工大學,大批市民「圍魏救趙」,213 人在油麻地碧街一帶被捕,分拆成多案審理。其中涉及 23 人的案件,12 人開審前認罪,周五(19 日)在區域法院判囚 3 年至 3 年 4 個月。
暫委法官黃雅茵指,示威現場最高峰達 2000 人,大部分穿深色或黑色裝束,並有頭盔、口罩等裝備,從裝束可見,示威者有周詳計劃,「有備而戰」。
除了認罪扣減,法官提到有被告化學系一級榮譽畢業,正修讀博士學位,但因本案須停學,欲於國際科學期刊刊登論文,亦因案件擱置;另有被告半工讀碩士課程,還押後修讀了 3 個遙距課程,2 人獲減刑 4 個月。官另考慮有 5 人沒有自暴自棄,努力及積極學習,額外減刑 2 個月。
19 Jul 2024法庭線#3832
7.14新城市衝突|警員受傷索償 涉警方一案暫攔置 涉示威者案一人以15萬元和解
Police–civilian clashes occurred at Sha Tin New Town Plaza on 14 July 2019. Two plain-clothes police officers said they were injured after being attacked by protesters that night. One officer subsequently sought damages from two protesters who admitted rioting offences and from the Commissioner of Police. The case involving the Police Force was originally scheduled for trial in the High Court in early July. The parties were granted a stay of the trial pending the conclusion of the damages claim involving the protesters.
High Court deputy judge Chun Man (Judge) Leung handed down a judgment on Friday (19th) giving supplementary reasons. The judge said the plaintiff police officer had not disclosed throughout that another damages action was being conducted at the same time, and it was difficult to understand why different lawyers had been engaged to handle the two matters separately, describing the situation as “unusual and regrettable”. The judgment also disclosed that, in the other case, one protester defendant had settled out of court for HK$150,000, while the court was assessing the damages payable to another.
According to the writ of summons, when seeking damages from the Police Force, the officer alleged that the Police had failed to conduct an appropriate assessment of the situation before deploying officers to the scene, leaving them outnumbered and causing injuries to his face, body and eyes.
2019 年 7 月 14 日,沙田新城市廣場發生警民衝突。兩名便衣警稱當晚受示威者襲擊受傷。一警員先後向兩名承認暴動罪的示威者,以及警務處長索償。涉及警務處的案件原定 7 月初在高院開審,雙方獲准擱置審訊,待涉及示威者的索償案完結。
高院暫委法官梁俊文周五(19 日)頒判詞補充理由,指原告警員一直沒披露有另一宗索償訴訟同時進行,難以理解為何會聘用不同的律師各自處理,形容情況「特殊和令人遺憾」。判詞又透露在另案中,有示威者被告以 15 萬元庭外和解,另一人則正由法庭評定賠償額。
翻查入稟狀,警員向警方索償時指,警方委派警員到場前沒作適當形勢評估,令他們寡不敵眾,致他的臉部、身體及眼睛受傷。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.