30 Jan 2023法庭線#5986
11.2維園|3區議員阻差案 文念志被判240小時社服令 官接納有檢控延誤
On 2 November 2019, pro-democracy district council election candidates held a rally in Victoria Park. Police dispersed the gathering and arrested Osman Chung Hang Cheng, Nim Chi Man and Richard Chun Chit Chan. The three won their district council elections that year and were later convicted after trial of obstructing a police officer in the execution of their duty. Cheng and Chan were each sentenced to 240 hours of community service. Man’s sentencing was adjourned until Monday (30th) because the medical report was not ready.
2019 年 11 月 2 日,民主派區選候選人在維園舉行集會,警方驅散,期間拘捕鄭仲恒、文念志及陳振哲。3 人同年在區選勝出,而早前經審訊後被裁定阻差辦公罪成,當中鄭、陳被判 240 小時社會服務令。文則因醫療報告未備妥,押後至周一(30 日)判刑
28 Jan 2023法庭線#5982
8.11尖沙咀|7人暴動罪成判囚36至45月 1人管武罪成判囚11月
After a march in Sham Shui Po on 11 August 2019, some protesters went to surround the Tsim Sha Tsui Police Station. A total of 29 people were subsequently charged with rioting and other offences, and the cases were heard in three trials. In the case involving eight men, six were convicted of rioting after trial. Together with one person who had pleaded guilty earlier, they were sentenced to between three years and three years nine months in prison at the District Court on Saturday (28th). The remaining person was acquitted of rioting but convicted of possessing an offensive weapon in a public place, and was sentenced to 11 months in prison.
2019 年 8 月 11 日深水埗遊行後,有示威者前往包圍尖沙咀警署,事後 29 人被控暴動等罪,分成 3 案審理。當中涉及 8 名男子的案件,6 人經審訊後,被裁定暴動罪成,連同早前認罪的 1 人,周六(28 日)在區域法院被判監禁 3 年至 3 年 9 個月;餘下 1 人暴動罪不成立、在公眾地方管有攻擊性武器罪成,被判監禁 11 個月。
27 Jan 2023法庭線#5978
《立場》被指煽動案|控方引員工卡片指寫有「星星之火」 稱可聯想「星火基金」
The trial of former Stand News editor-in-chief Chung Pui-kuen, former acting editor-in-chief Lam Siu-tong and the company behind Stand News, who are charged with conspiracy to publish seditious publications, entered its 25th day at the District Court on Friday (27th).
Under questioning, Chung Pui-kuen testified that every employee joining Stand News could choose four characters to be printed on a card. The prosecution said one person had chosen “A Single Spark”, which could lead people to associate it with the Spark Alliance Fund. The remark caused an uproar in the public gallery. Chung testified that the arrangement was intended to provide space for employees to express their “self-expectations”. He also said that if criminal prosecutions were brought through associations, the chilling effect on freedom of expression would be disproportionate. Chung added that the prosecution’s questions had left him surprised: “Why is the evidence brought forward for a criminal prosecution so weak, while so many associations and speculations are being added?”
前《立場新聞》總編輯鍾沛權、前署任總編輯林紹桐,及《立場》所屬公司被控「串謀發布煽動刊物罪」案,周五(27 日)於區域法院踏入第 25 日審訊。
鍾沛權在盤問下供稱,每位入職《立場》的員工,都可揀選四字印上卡片。控方指有人選擇「星星之火」,令人聯想與「星火基金」有關,語畢旁聽席一片嘩然。鍾沛權供稱,有關安排是希望提供空間,讓員工表達「自我期許」,又指若透過聯想進行刑事檢控,對言論自由的寒蟬效應,大得不符比例。鍾又指,控方的提問令他感到詫異,「點解刑事檢控攞出嚟嘅證據咁薄弱之餘,係加諸咁多聯想、猜測?」
27 Jan 2023法庭線#5980
醫生2019年平安夜非法集結罪成 醫委會裁定違反醫生註冊條例 除牌6月、緩刑36月
Cheung, who is currently a registered doctor, appeared before the Medical Council for a disciplinary hearing on Friday (27th) in connection with the conviction. Cheung was not represented by a lawyer and made no submissions. After the five-member inquiry panel adjourned to deliberate for about 1.5 hours, it ruled that Cheung had breached the Medical Registration Ordinance and ordered a six-month erasure from the register, suspended for 36 months.
Announcing the ruling, the chairman of the inquiry panel said it had noted that Cheung was young and might provide useful services to the public in the future. His internship report also showed that he had performed well. However, the charge in this case could undermine public confidence in the medical profession. The panel had to take public expectations into account when determining the sentence, and the sentence also had to reflect doctors’ values.
現為註冊醫生的張,周五(27 日)因該定罪紀錄,在醫委會接受紀律聆訊。張沒有律師代表,也沒陳詞回應。5 人研訊小組退席商議約 1.5 小時後,裁定張違反《醫生註冊條例》,罰除牌 6 個月,緩刑 36 個月。
研訊小組主席宣布裁決時指,留意到張年輕、將來或為公眾提供有用服務,從實習報告也見他表現出色。不過,本案控罪有可能降低公眾對醫生專業的信心,小組判刑時要考慮社會期望,亦要反映醫生價值觀。
26 Jan 2023法庭線#5975
《立場》被指煽動案|控方指訪問自稱襲警者不報警 鍾沛權:保護受訪者、透過報道履行責任
The trial of former Stand News editor-in-chief Chung Pui-kuen, former acting editor-in-chief Lam Siu-tung and the company that operated Stand News, who are charged with conspiracy to publish seditious publications, entered its 24th day at the District Court on Thursday (26th), with Chung continuing to be cross-examined by the prosecution.
The prosecution cited a Stand News feature published in mid-November 2019, which included a person claiming to be from a frontline squad saying that it planned to ambush lone police officers, and questioned why Stand News had not reported the matter to the police. Chung said they had discussed whether it was necessary to report it, but did not do so in order to protect the source. He described handling the matter as “one of the most difficult decisions” he had made as a journalist.
He described it as “a moral dilemma”, saying he knew the interviewee’s advocacy could result in others being injured and that they could not “pretend not to see it after receiving the warning”. He ultimately decided to fulfil his responsibility through reporting, allowing the public to fully understand the frontline squad’s thinking, discuss it and consider how to respond. He said neither the government nor the public could “be an ostrich” and ignore the fact that some people in society were becoming radicalised and proposing methods close to terrorism; as a media organisation, it should “bring it out to face it and bring it out for discussion”.
前《立場新聞》總編輯鍾沛權、前署任總編輯林紹桐,及《立場》所屬公司被控「串謀發布煽動刊物罪」案,周四(26 日)於區域法院踏入第 24 日審訊,鍾沛權繼續接受控方盤問。
控方引述《立場》於 2019 年 11 月中的專題報道,當中有自稱前線小隊揚言計劃伏擊落單警員,質疑《立場》為何不報警。鍾沛權指,曾討論是否需要報警,但為了保護消息來源沒這樣做,直言處理這事件是他作為新聞工作者「其中一個最難嘅決定」。
他形容「呢件事係有道德嘅兩難」,知道該被訪者的提倡,或引致他人受傷,不可以「收到預告當睇唔到」,最後決定透過報道履行責任,讓公眾充分了解該前線小隊的想法,作出討論和思考如何應對。他認為,政府或大眾都不能做「鴕鳥」,忽視社會上有人走向激進,提出接近恐怖主義的手法,作為媒體應「攞出來面對,攞出來傾」。
26 Jan 2023法庭線#5976
《立場》被指煽動案|控方就「武漢肺炎」字眼盤問、指習近平與病毒美術圖屬偏見
The trial of former Stand News editor-in-chief Chung Pui-kuen, former acting editor-in-chief Lam Siu-tong and the company that operated Stand News, who are charged with conspiracy to publish seditious publications, entered its 24th day at the District Court on Thursday (26th).
The prosecution questioned Chung about the use of the term “Wuhan pneumonia” in news reports. The defence interrupted, questioning its relevance to the 17 articles in the case. The prosecution responded that Stand News articles could be used to “identify Chung Pui-kuen’s stance and thereby infer his intention”. The defence further questioned how, even if the reports were inaccurate, this showed Chung’s intention or how the reports “could help the prosecution”.
Judge Guo Wai-kin said that as the prosecution alleged Stand News was a political platform that incited others, the court should consider Chung’s and Stand News’s political orientation. He also said that, as a matter of judicial notice, “the WHO said not to stigmatise the virus and that ‘Wuhan pneumonia’ and ‘China pneumonia’ should no longer be used”, yet Stand News continued to use the terms. He ruled that the prosecution’s questions were relevant to the case and allowed the questioning to continue.
前《立場新聞》總編輯鍾沛權、前署任總編輯林紹桐,及《立場》所屬公司被控「串謀發布煽動刊物罪」案,周四(26 日)於區域法院踏入第 24 日審訊。
控方圍繞在新聞報道中使用「武漢肺炎」字眼盤問鍾沛權,期間辯方打斷,質疑與 17 篇涉案文章無關。控方回應,可從《立場》文章「找出鍾沛權的立場,從而推測其意圖」。辯方再質疑即使報道有錯,「都睇唔到鍾沛權意圖,(報道)點樣幫到控方?」
法官郭偉健指,控方指《立場》是政治平台、煽動他人,故法庭應考慮鍾及《立場》的政治取向,又指據司法認知,「世衞講咗唔好污名化病毒,唔應該再用武漢肺炎、中國肺炎」,而《立場》仍然使用,認為控方問題與本案有關,批准繼續盤問。
20 Jan 2023法庭線#5970
「Lunch哥」被控藐視法庭 法官陳慶偉因「47人案」未能訂審期:國安法案優先
Lee Kwok-wing, known as “Lunch Gor” after organising multiple “Lunch with You” protests in 2020, and a retired woman in her sixties were accused of verbally abusing and harassing witnesses outside a court during a death inquest in August 2020. They were charged with contempt of court.
The case was mentioned again in the High Court on Friday (20th), with the prosecution and defence making submissions on obtaining expert reports. When the possibility of an earlier trial date was raised, judge Andrew Hing Wai Chan said he did not have one available. He said, “I believe you all know that after the Lunar New Year I have a case lasting 90 days, being tried until August,” and that “national security law cases take priority”, so a trial date could not yet be fixed.
2020 年因多次發起「和你 Lunch」示威,被外界稱為「Lunch 哥」的李國永及一名退休六旬婦,被指在 2020 年 8 月一宗死因研訊期間,在法院外指罵及騷擾證人,被控藐視法庭罪。
案件周五(20 日)在高等法院再訊,控辯雙方就索取專家報告陳詞。當提到可否有「快期」開審時,法官陳慶偉指他沒有,「相信你們都知道,農曆新年後我有一宗長達 90 日、審至 8 月的案件」、「國安法案件優先」,故暫未能訂審期。
20 Jan 2023法庭線#5971
林卓廷等3人涉迫刪示威者照片案 林意圖妨礙公正罪脫 官:解紛爭沒犯案意圖
After the July 2019 “Liberate Tuen Mun Park” procession, then Legislative Council member Lam Cheuk-ting and three others were accused of asking someone to delete photos of protesters from the “7.1 siege of Police Headquarters”, and were charged with attempting to pervert the course of justice and other offences. Lam was found not guilty on Friday (20th) of attempting to pervert the course of justice, while the social worker defendant was also acquitted of two charges. The third defendant, an online media journalist, was convicted of unlawful assembly.
2019 年 7 月「光復屯門公園」遊行後,時任立法會議員林卓廷等 4 人,被指要求他人刪去 「7.1 包圍警總」示威者照片,分別被控意圖妨礙司法公正等罪。林周五(20 日)被裁定意圖妨礙司法公正罪不成立、社工被告兩罪亦不成立,而第三被告、網媒記者則非法集結罪成。
19 Jan 2023法庭線#5966
涉將張家朗奪金片國歌換上《願榮光》 男子否認辱國歌 官裁警具「歌曲專家」資格
Cheung Ka-long, a member of Hong Kong’s fencing team, won an Olympic gold medal in 2021. A 27-year-old man was accused of replacing the national anthem in footage of the medal ceremony with “Glory to Hong Kong” and uploading it to YouTube. He was charged with the offence of “insulting the national anthem” under the National Anthem Ordinance. The defendant pleaded not guilty. The case, the first trial involving an alleged insult to the national anthem, was heard on Thursday (19th) at the Eastern Magistrates’ Courts.
The prosecution sought to call a police sergeant as an expert witness on “research into the song ‘Glory to Hong Kong’”. The defence objected and questioned the sergeant’s expert qualifications, saying he had not studied “Glory to Hong Kong” but had studied how the song was applied, describing this as “ill-fitting and irrelevant”. The prosecution said the sergeant had a very sufficient basis to explain and analyse the background of the song. After hearing submissions from both sides and the sergeant’s evidence, Magistrate Minnie Lai Man Wat ruled that he was qualified as an expert and could provide expert opinion on the matter. The case was adjourned to 29 March for continuation of the trial, and the defendant was granted bail on his existing conditions.
香港劍擊隊代表張家朗 2021 年奪得奧運金牌,一名 27 歲男子被指將頒獎片段中的國歌,換上《願榮光歸香港》,並發布至 YouTube,被控違《國歌條例》下「侮辱國歌」罪。被告不認罪,是首宗涉侮辱國歌的審訊案件,案件周四(19 日)在東區裁判法院審訊。
控方欲傳召警長作為「研究歌曲《願榮光歸香港》」的專家證人作供。辯方反對並質疑警長的專家資格,指他沒有研究《願榮光》,而是研究歌曲如何被應用,形容為「衣不稱身,文不對題」。控方則表示警長具極充足基礎作解說,和分析歌曲的背景。裁判官屈麗雯聽罷雙方陳詞及警長作供後,裁定他具專家資格,可就此提供專家意見。案件押後至 3 月 29 日續審,期間被告准以原有條件保釋。
19 Jan 2023法庭線#5969
旺角騷亂四周年|涉「私了」清路障漢 18歲自閉男生認暴動、傷人判囚2年
On the night of the second day of Lunar New Year in 2020, members of the public went to areas around Mong Kok to mark the fourth anniversary of the 2016 Mong Kok riots. The gathering subsequently escalated into clashes and “private justice” incidents. An 18-year-old autistic male student at the time was accused of kicking a middle-aged man who was removing a roadblock. He earlier pleaded guilty to rioting and assault, and was sentenced to two years’ imprisonment at the District Court on Thursday (19th).
2020 年農曆年初二晚,有市民到旺角一帶,紀念 2016 年旺角騷亂四周年,其後演變成衝突及「私了」事件。一名案發時 18 歲男生,被指用腳踢向一名移開路障的中年漢,早前承認暴動及傷人兩罪,周四(19 日)在區域法院被判監禁 2 年。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.