3 Jan 2023法庭線#5899
七一刺警|35歲入境助理涉連登發布煽惑言論 稱「齊斬黑警」認罪囚6月
Following the 2021 Causeway Bay July 1 police stabbing case, a man and a woman were accused of posting online statements inciting harm to police officers. The 35-year-old male senior immigration assistant was accused of posting on the LIHKG discussion forum urging people to “chop black cops”. He pleaded guilty at the District Court on Tuesday (the 3rd) to one count of “inciting another to wound with intent”. Judge Clement Lee sentenced him to six months’ imprisonment.
2021 年銅鑼灣七一刺警案後,兩男女被指在網上發表煽惑傷害警員言論。當中 35 歲男入境高級事務助理員被指在連登討論區發帖呼籲人「斬黑警」,他周二(3 日)在區域法院承認一項「煽惑他人有意圖而傷人」罪,法官李慶年判被告監禁 6 個月。
3 Jan 2023法庭線#5902
陳日君向法院申請取回護照 據悉獲准離港出席本篤十六世喪禮
Cardinal Joseph Zen, emeritus bishop of the Catholic Diocese of Hong Kong, appeared at the West Kowloon Magistrates’ Courts on Tuesday (the 3rd). He is understood to have applied to the court to retrieve his passport and was granted permission by Chief Magistrate Lo Tak-chuen to leave Hong Kong from the 4th to the 8th of this month to attend the funeral of Pope Benedict XVI at the Vatican. He must return the passport to the police after coming back to Hong Kong. The prosecution did not object.
天主教香港教區榮休主教陳日君樞機周二(3 日)現身西九龍裁判法院。據了解,他是向法庭申請取回護照,並獲主任裁判官羅德泉批准於本月 4 日至 8 日離港,到梵蒂岡出席天主教教宗本篤十六世的喪禮,回港後須將護照交回警方。控方沒有反對。
31 Dec 2022法庭線#5891
11.18油麻地|13人暴動罪成囚29月至63月
In November 2019, when police surrounded protesters inside the Polytechnic University, 213 people were involved in an effort in Yau Ma Tei to “besiege Wei to rescue Zhao” by rescuing the besieged protesters. They were charged with rioting and dealt with in several cases. In the case involving 13 people, one of the “12 Hong Kong residents”, Kwok Tsz-lam, and a 21-year-old man pleaded guilty. The remaining 11 were convicted after trial, making it the first case involving “support for the Polytechnic University” in which defendants were convicted after trial. The judge said that, apart from the two defendants who pleaded guilty—including Kwok Tsz-lam, one of the “12 Hong Kong residents”—who received reduced sentences of 2 years and 5 months and 3 years and 11 months respectively, and one defendant who received discretionary mitigation because of his young age, the other defendants had no grounds for mitigation and were sentenced to between 4 years and 6 months and 5 years and 3 months in prison.
2019 年 11 月警方圍堵理大內的示威者,213 人涉在油麻地以「圍魏救趙」,營救被圍堵的示威者,被控暴動,分成多案處理。其中涉及 13 人的案件,除了「12 港人」之一的郭子麟及一名 21 歲男生認罪,其餘 11 人經審訊後裁定罪成,為首宗「聲援理大」、經審訊後定罪的案件。法官指,除了 2 名認罪被告,包括「12 港人」之一的郭子麟獲減刑,分判囚 2 年 5 個月及 3 年 11 個月,另有一被告因年輕獲酌情減刑外,其他被告均沒有減刑理由,分別被判監 4 年半至 5 年 3 個月。
30 Dec 2022法庭線#5886
青年涉藏鐳射筆勝訴 稱警漏披露兩證供 入稟追討52萬 官剔除申請、斥濫用程序
Nineteen-year-old student Pang Yuk-him was previously accused of possessing a laser pointer in Mong Kok in November 2019. He denied the charge and, without legal representation, defended himself in English. He was ultimately acquitted. He later filed a claim in the District Court against the Secretary for Justice, alleging that, after the judgment, he discovered that police officers had failed to fully discharge their duty to disclose documents, including that two witness statements had not been provided to him. He sought more than HK$520,000 in compensation from the Department of Justice.
Judge Ko King-shiu handed down his judgment on Friday (30th), striking out Pang’s claim and finding it frivolous, an abuse of the judicial process, academic, and disclosing no reasonable cause of action. The judge also said he agreed with the Secretary for Justice’s submissions that, given the circumstances of the case, the trial magistrate would not have approved Pang’s application for costs, and ordered Pang to pay the Secretary for Justice’s costs.
19 歲男學生彭裕謙早前被指 2019 年 11 月在旺角管有鐳射筆,他否認控罪,在無律師代表下,親自以英文自辯,最終獲判無罪。他其後向區院入稟起訴律政司長,指裁決後發現有警員沒盡披露文件責任,向他漏提供兩證人證供等,向律政司追討共逾 52 萬元賠償。
法官高勁修周五(30 日)頒下判詞,剔除彭裕謙申索,指其申索瑣屑無聊(frivolous)、濫用司法程序、變得學術,及未能披露合理訴訟因由(cause of action)。法官又指,同意律政司一方所言,觀乎本案情況,原審裁判官也不會批准他的訟費申請,並下令彭裕謙負擔律政司一方訟費。
29 Dec 2022法庭線#5882
前中大學生會長蘇浚鋒認煽惑投白票 官裁控罪合憲 判囚2月緩刑18月
The magistrate ruled that inciting others not to vote or to cast blank ballots undermined the electoral system and affected the voting rights of other citizens. The offence had a legitimate purpose and did not target any particular political stance. So immediately pleaded guilty. In sentencing, the magistrate accepted that the defendant had a good background and a low likelihood of reoffending, and had committed the offence out of momentary foolishness and a lack of legal knowledge. The starting point was three months’ imprisonment; after a reduction for the guilty plea, So was sentenced to two months’ imprisonment, suspended for 18 months.
裁判官認為,煽惑他人不投票或投白票的行為,令選舉制度受挫,影響其他市民的投票權,控罪有其合法目的,亦沒有針對特定政治主張。蘇隨即認罪。裁判官判刑時接納被告有良好背景,重犯機會低,因一時愚蠢、缺乏法律常識而犯案,以監禁 3 個月作量刑起點,認罪扣減後判囚 2 個月,緩刑一年半。
29 Dec 2022法庭線#5884
社民連等4人一組請願違限聚 7人欲申上訴至終院許可 高院拒批證明書
Leung Kwok-hung of the League of Social Democrats, Lee Cheuk-yan of the Labour Party and six others marched in groups of four to petition outside the Government Headquarters on Labour Day in 2020. They were convicted of breaching the gathering restriction order and sentenced to 14 days’ imprisonment, suspended for 18 months. In October this year, the High Court dismissed their appeals against conviction and sentence. Seven of them applied to the High Court last Friday (23) for certificates to apply for leave to appeal to the Court of Final Appeal. In a judgment handed down on Thursday (29), High Court judge Wong Chung-hau rejected the applications.
社民連梁國雄及工黨李卓人等 8 人,2020 年五一勞動節以 4 人一組遊行到政總外請願,被裁定違「限聚令」罪成,判囚 14 天、緩刑一年半。8 人今年 10 月,被高等法院駁回定罪及刑期上訴,當中 7 人上周五(23 日)再向高院申請證明書,以申請上訴至終院許可。高院法官黃崇厚周四(29 日) 頒下判詞,駁回申請。
23 Dec 2022法庭線#5871
梁振英控《立場新聞》及鍾劍華誹謗 官指鍾逾 14 月未繳費 失陪審團審理權利
National Committee of the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference Vice-Chairman and former Chief Executive Leung Chun-ying filed a defamation suit in the High Court in 2018 against Chung Kim-wah, a former assistant professor at Hong Kong Polytechnic University, and Stand News. The case was previously scheduled to be heard by a jury and was expected to go to trial in 2023, with Chung required to pay the relevant fees by a specified deadline. Chung’s side subsequently applied to defer payment, citing solicitor negligence and arguing that an extension would not prejudice any party. Leung’s side opposed the application, arguing that Chung had lost the right to request a jury trial, that Stand News no longer had legal representation, and that the allegations against Leung might violate the National Security Law.
全國政協副主席、前行政長官梁振英,2018 年入禀高等法院,控告理大前助理教授鍾劍華及《立場新聞》誹謗,案件早前決定交由陪審團審理,預計於 2023 年開審,提出申請的鍾需在限期前繳交有關費用。鍾劍華一方其後表示,因律師疏忽、延長繳款沒有損害各方的利益等理由,因此向法庭申請延期繳款。但梁振英一方反駁指,鍾失去權利要求陪審團參與審訊,且《立場新聞》已無法律代表,又指對梁的指控或觸犯國安法。
23 Dec 2022法庭線#5872
中大生非法集結等3罪成囚6月 服刑後上訴 管非法工具上訴得直 兩罪維持原判
During the “Kowloon March” on 20 October 2019, CUHK student Leung Hing-chun was alleged to have taken part in demonstrations and blocked roads with fellow students, including former student union president Owen Au Cheuk-hei. After a trial, Leung was convicted of three offences: unlawful assembly, violating the Prohibition on Face Covering Regulation, and possessing an offensive weapon or a tool fit for an unlawful purpose (the “possession offence”). He was sentenced to six months’ imprisonment, which he had already served.
Leung appealed against the convictions. In a judgment handed down on Friday (23rd), High Court judge Wong Sung-hau ruled that, in light of the Court of Final Appeal’s latest precedent, the conviction for the possession offence was unsafe and should not stand. The appeal was therefore allowed, and the conviction and sentence were set aside. The other two convictions were upheld. After considering the submissions from both sides, the judge found that “the appellant was a person who ran out from the place of the unlawful assembly in question”, saying that the inference was supported by evidence including the appellant’s clothing and the items he was carrying.
2019 年 10 月 20 日「九龍遊行」,中大學生梁馨駿被指和同校學生會前會長區倬僖等人參與示威、堵路,梁經審訊後被裁定 3 罪罪成,包括非法集結、違《禁蒙面法》及「管有攻擊性武器或適合作非法用途的工具」(下稱管有罪),判囚 6 個月,之前已完成服刑。
梁馨駿不服定罪提出上訴,高等法院法官黃崇厚周五(23 日)頒下判詞,裁定按終審法院最新案例《陳俊傑案》,管有罪定罪不穩妥、不應維持,因此上訴得直,撤銷定罪及判刑。餘下兩罪則維持原判,指考慮雙方陳詞後,裁定「上訴人是從涉案非法集結的地方跑出來的人」,稱推論獲上訴人衣著、所攜物品等證據支持。
23 Dec 2022法庭線#5873
10.1荃灣|兩男暴動罪成申上訴被駁回 官:事實「幾何級」累積 足以令原審作推論
On National Day, 1 October 2019, clashes occurred in multiple districts, and Secondary 5 student Tsang Chi Kin was shot in Tsuen Wan. Four people in the same district denied rioting charges and were earlier all convicted, receiving sentences ranging from 4 years and 3 months to 4 years and 8 months. Two of them, dissatisfied with their convictions, had earlier applied for leave to appeal. High Court Court of Appeal judge Poon Man-ki handed down her judgment on Friday (23rd), refusing to grant the two men leave to appeal.
2019 年 10 月 1 日國慶日,多區發生衝突,當中中五生「健仔」在荃灣中槍。同區 4 人否認暴動罪,早前被裁定全部罪成,判囚 4 年 3 個月至 4 年 8 個月不等。當中兩人不服定罪,早前申請上訴許可。高院上訴庭法官潘敏琦周五(23 日)頒下判詞,拒絕向二人批出上訴許可。
23 Dec 2022法庭線#5874
11.12粉嶺|4男涉擲鐵枝落路軌表證不成立 官質疑警員故意違查問疑犯守則
On 12 November 2019, anti-extradition bill protesters launched “Operation Dawn”. Roads were blocked in multiple districts and a “three-strikes” action was launched. Four male students were accused of throwing iron rods and other items from a footbridge in Fanling onto railway tracks. More than two years later, they were charged. On Thursday (22nd), magistrate Kenneth Ping Chau Chan ruled at Fanling Magistrates’ Courts on a special matter that the confession statements of all the defendants were inadmissible.
2019 年 11 月 12 日,反修例示威者發起「破曉行動」,多區有人堵路,發動「三罷」。其中 4 名男學生被指從粉嶺一條行人天橋,將鐵枝等物品投擲到火車路軌上,事隔逾兩年被起訴,裁判官陳炳宙周四(22 日)在粉嶺裁判法院就特別事項裁定,不接納所有被告的招認口供。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.