Tai Hang Sai Estate redevelopment: Court rejects application to resume possession proceedings; judgment says court must stop exploitation of financial advantage
大坑西邨重建 官拒平民屋宇恢復收樓訴訟 判詞:法庭有責制止乘財力優勢行事
Tai Hang Sai Estate in Shek Kip Mei is to be demolished and redeveloped. The Hong Kong Settlers Housing Corporation Limited, which built and manages the estate, set March 15 this year as the deadline for tenants to move out and subsequently brought civil claims against 67 residents who refused to leave. Thirteen of them failed to reach a settlement. The Corporation sought to resume the legal proceedings, but District Court Judicial Registrar Wing Sum Soong rejected its application in a judgment handed down on Thursday (the 22nd). The judge said most of the residents were elderly people from grassroots backgrounds and that, from their perspective, the dispute arose from the loss of their homes, concerning their lives and survival in their later years. The judge also said everyone should have the opportunity of a fair trial: “If any party to litigation attempts to exploit its advantage in financial strength and resources to use procedural convenience to quickly obtain judgment against residents and bring the matter to a hasty conclusion, the court has a duty to stop it.” One defendant resident said they were “extremely happy” with the judgment, describing it as “finally having a ‘person of justice’ step forward”. The resident also said residents were raising funds to prepare for a judicial review. The Corporation said in a statement that it disagreed with the judgment and would appeal, adding that it had always put people first in the Tai Hang Sai New Estate redevelopment plan and rehousing arrangements and maintained communication with tenants. It said more than 99% of tenants had accepted the arrangement and moved out so far.
石硤尾的大坑西邨將清拆重建,興建與管理該邨的「平民屋宇有限公司」定今年 3 月 15 日為租戶搬遷限期,隨後以民事控告 67 名拒絕遷出的居民。當中 13 人和解不果,「平屋」要求恢復法律程序,區院司法常務官宋泳琛周四(22 日)頒下判詞,拒絕「平屋」一方的申請。 法官指,注意到大部分居民為年邁基層,從他們角度,爭議源於喪失了他們的家,是關乎他們在晚年生活和生存,又指任何人也應獲公平審訊的機會,「若有任何訴訟方企圖乘財力和資源之優勢,以程序之便快速地針對居民取得判決,以草草了事,法庭有責任加以制止。」 有被告居民指對判決「非常之開心」,形容「終於有個『正義之士』行出嚟」,又指居民間正籌錢準備司法覆核。「平屋」發聲明表示不認同判決,將會提出上訴,又指「大坑西新邨重建計劃及回遷安排上一直以人為本,與住戶保持溝通」,至今逾 99% 租戶接受方案並遷出。
