20 Aug 2024法庭線#3920
11.12荃灣|兩男非法集結等罪不成立 律政司上訴要求發還原審重新考慮
In November 2019, netizens called for a “three strikes” action, and clashes broke out across Hong Kong. Two men were accused of taking part in an unlawful assembly in Tsuen Wan and violating the Prohibition on Face Covering Regulation. They were found not guilty in June 2021. The Department of Justice lodged an appeal by way of case stated. The High Court began hearing the appeal on Tuesday (20th). After hearing submissions, the judge Anthony Kai On Kwok adjourned the case, with judgment to be delivered within two months.
The Department of Justice argued that the judgment in the “Lo Kin-man case” had been handed down after the decision in this case, and asked for the case to be remitted to the original magistrate to reconsider it in light of the clarified legal principles. The defence questioned whether this would effectively give the Department of Justice two opportunities to prosecute, saying, “It seems this method doesn’t work—try another one,” and argued that the approach was unfair to the defendants.
2019 年 11 月,網民發起「三罷」,香港各區爆發衝突。兩名男子被指在荃灣參與非法集結及違反《禁蒙面法》,2021 年 6 月被裁定罪名不成立。律政司以案件呈述方式提出上訴,高等法院周二(20 日) 開庭審理,法官郭啟安聽罷陳詞,押後兩個月內頒裁決。
律政司一方陳詞指,本案裁決後出現「盧建民案」判決,希望發還讓原審裁判官,根據釐清後的法律原則重新考慮;答辯方質疑,此舉無疑讓律政司有兩次機會作出檢控,「好似用呢個方法唔得喎,用另一個方法啦」,做法對答辯人不公。
20 Aug 2024法庭線#3921
反恐首案|法官引導陪審團 指須考慮被告是否知情下參與、擲汽油彈屬否恐怖行為
In the first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants have pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 76th day at the High Court on Tuesday (20th), with Judge Cheung Wai-ling on the third day of summing up the evidence and directing the jury.
The judge said Victor Chun Keung Wong, who claimed to be the captain of “Dragon Slaying Brigade,” had earlier told teammates that they did not need to bring equipment, but had separately discussed using petrol bombs with other squads. She asked the jury to consider “how much Wong had told his teammates” and whether the teammates had knowingly participated in the “plan to kill police officers.”
The judge also said that one defendant had chosen to testify. If the jury considered his account to be true or possibly true, or was unable to be sure of the prosecution’s case, it should find him not guilty. She added that whether throwing petrol bombs constituted terrorist acts was also for the jury to decide.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周二(20 日)在高等法院踏入第 76 天審訊,法官張慧玲第 3 天總結供詞及引導陪審團。
法官指,自稱「屠龍」隊長的黃振強事前著隊友毋須帶裝備,但另與其他小隊談及用汽油彈,著陪審團考慮黃「講咗幾多嘢畀隊友聽」,隊友是否在知情下參與「殺警計劃」。
官又指,一被告選擇出庭作供,若陪審團認為其說法真實、可能真實,或未能肯定控方說法,就應裁定罪名不成立;官另指,擲汽油彈屬否恐怖行為,亦交由陪審團決定。
19 Aug 2024法庭線#3917
反恐首案|法官引導陪審團 控方指串謀11.18開始 辯方指12月才開始
In the first case under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants have pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 75th day at the High Court on Monday (19th), with Judge Cheung Wai-ling on the second day of summarising the testimony and directing the jury.
The judge summarised the prosecution’s allegation that the conspiracy involving Dragon Slaying Brigade began on Nov. 18, 2019, because it was only then that Victor Chun Keung Wong, who called himself the captain of Dragon Slaying Brigade, confirmed that co-conspirator Ng Chi-hung had guns and bombs. The defence disputed this, saying the conspiracy involving Dragon Slaying Brigade began no earlier than Dec. 3, when the date and time of the operation were finalised. Counsel for defendant Cheung Ming-yu argued that the agreement only began in the early hours of Dec. 8, when Wong and Ng confirmed the actual location of the operation.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周一(19 日)在高等法院踏入第 75 天審訊,法官張慧玲第二天總結供詞及引導陪審團。
法官簡述,控方指控關於「屠龍」的串謀,於 2019 年 11 月 18 日開始,因為當時自稱「屠龍」隊長的黃振強才確認共謀者吳智鴻有槍及炸彈;辯方則爭議「屠龍」有份的串謀,最早於 12 月 3 日才開始,因為當時才落實行動的日期及時間。被告張銘裕的辯方代表則認為,涉案協議於 12 月 8 日凌晨,當黃與吳確認行動實際地點後才開始。
16 Aug 2024法庭線#3909
反恐首案|法官引導陪審團 提醒須謹慎考慮污點證人供詞
In the first case under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants have pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 74th day at the High Court on Friday (the 16th). The seven defendants have completed their closing submissions, and Judge Zhang Huiling summed up the evidence and directed the jury.
The judge said the jury must treat the evidence of the three defendants who had pleaded guilty with caution, as they had assisted the prosecution in proving its case in the hope of receiving reduced sentences. They had obvious incentives to tailor their evidence for sentence reductions, or even to give false evidence. However, if the jury considered that a witness had told the truth, it could accept that witness’s evidence. Victor Chun Keung Wong and Eddie Pang Kwan-ho had also been granted immunity from prosecution. The judge reminded the jury to consider the personal interests of these two people when assessing whether their evidence was credible. She also reminded the jury not to be influenced by personal sympathy or prejudice, and to deal with the case fairly and impartially.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周五(16 日)在高等法院踏入第 74 天審訊。7 名被告已完成陳詞,案件由法官張慧玲總結供詞,引導陪審團。
法官指,陪審團須謹慎處理本案 3 名認罪被告的證供,因他們協助控方舉證,希望可獲減刑。他們有明顯誘因為減刑而剪裁證供,甚或作假證供,但如陪審團認為證人已說出真相,便可信納其證供。當中黃振強及彭軍壕亦獲豁免起訴書,提醒陪審團要考慮此兩人的個人利益,考慮其證供是否可信。法官又提醒,陪審團不應被個人同情或偏見影響,須抱持平及中肯的態度處理案件。
15 Aug 2024法庭線#3905
反恐首案|辯方指劉佩凝僅「兼職會計文員妹」 2019年暴動沒被指為恐怖活動、非控方說了便算
In the first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants have pleaded not guilty, and the trial entered its 73rd day at the High Court on Thursday (15th). In submissions, counsel for female defendant Lau Pui-ying said the charge of conspiracy to crowd-fund for terrorist acts required the prosecution to prove that she intended, or knew, that the funds would be used for terrorist acts.
In response to the prosecution’s claim that throwing petrol bombs constituted terrorist acts, the defence said that a terrorist act was “not simply whatever the prosecution says”. It said the 2019 riot had never been classified as a terrorist act, and there was also no evidence in the case that any police officer had been seriously injured during the riot. The defence stressed that, at the time of the alleged offences, Liu followed the instructions of Victor Chun Keung Wong, captain of the self-styled “Dragon Slaying Brigade” team, and opened the “育龍” channel to pass the funds raised to Wong. She would “just nod when prompted”, and was “just a part-time accounting clerk girl—she wasn’t even paid.”
The defence also said that Victor Chun Keung Wong had “dragged Liu into the case” to obtain a reduced sentence. Wong was issued a letter granting immunity from prosecution, while the conspiracy-to-murder charge against him was left on the court file. “To put it plainly, it depends on your performance, whether you behave, whether you sincerely cooperate with the prosecution, and whether they will charge you again with conspiracy to murder—it is equivalent to a sword hanging over his head.”
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周四(15 日)在高等法院踏入第 73 天審訊。女被告劉佩凝一方陳詞,指其面對的串謀眾籌以作恐怖活動罪,須證劉有意圖或知悉眾籌將用於恐怖活動。
對於控方指擲汽油彈已屬恐怖活動,辯方稱恐怖活動「不是控方說了便算」,指 2019 年的暴動從沒被定性為恐怖活動,案中亦沒證據顯示有警員於暴動中嚴重受傷。辯方強調,劉案發時對自稱「屠龍」隊長黃振強言聽計從,開設「育龍」頻道將籌得款項交予黃,被「點到頭擰擰」,「只係一個兼職會計文員妹嚟,佢冇人工收添㗎。」
辯方又指,黃振強為減刑將劉「拖落水」,指黃獲發豁免起訴書、被控的串謀謀殺罪獲存檔法庭,「講白少少,睇下你表現如何,睇下你乖唔乖,係咪真誠同控方合作,再睇下告唔告返你串謀謀殺,等同佢頭上嘅一把刀。」
15 Aug 2024法庭線#3906
8.31太子站|5男襲警等罪成判囚7至22周 控方解釋延誤指速龍警員證人重疊
On 31 August 2019, clashes occurred inside Mong Kok and Prince Edward MTR stations, where riot police entered and used batons and other means to subdue and arrest numerous people. Sixteen people were charged with offences including assaulting police and possession of weapons more than three years and eight months later. In one case involving 11 people, five men were convicted after trial and, on Thursday (15th)—nearly five years after the incident—were sentenced to between 7 and 22 weeks’ imprisonment at Kowloon City Magistrates’ Courts.
The prosecution explained the delay in court, saying the Department of Justice had decided to prosecute by mid-2020, but the cases were handled in batches. “The Special Tactical Contingent police officers were working from morning to night at the time. Imagine handling all the cases, with the District Court and Magistrates’ Courts doing them at the same time—the witnesses would all overlap,” it said. The prosecution said it had handled the matter as far as possible, but “in reality, there would be a ‘time lag’”.
The defence submitted in mitigation that the delay had affected the defendants’ further studies and employment. Magistrate Brian Chi Fai Chan took the delay into consideration, as well as the fact that one defendant’s wife had to suspend her duties because of the case and undergo disciplinary proceedings, potentially losing her eligibility for disciplinary services quarters, and exercised discretion to reduce the sentences by 2 to 3 weeks.
2019 年 8 月 31 日,旺角及太子港鐵站內發生衝突,防暴警進站以警棍等制服和拘捕多人。16 人事隔逾 3 年 8 個月被起訴襲警、藏武等罪,其中一宗涉 11 人案件,5 男經審訊後定罪,周四(15 日)即事發將近 5 年後,在九龍城裁判法院被判監禁 7 至 22 星期。
控方庭上解釋延誤,指律政司於 2020 年中已決定起訴,惟因案件分批處理,「速龍警員(當時)由朝做到晚,想像到所有案件,區院、裁院一齊做,啲證人會重疊晒」,指已盡量處理,惟「事實上會有『時差』出現」。
辯方求情指,本案延誤影響被告升學、工作。裁判官陳志輝考慮延誤、有被告妻因本案須停職、接受紀律聆訊,可能被撤銷紀律部隊宿舍資格等,酌情減刑 2 至 3 周。
14 Aug 2024集誌社#3902
8.18 流水式集會|彭定康批定罪不公 港府:強烈譴責惡意詆毀
In the 8.18 assembly case, Jimmy Lai, Martin Lee, Margaret Ng and four other pro-democracy figures lodged a final appeal against their convictions for participating in an assembly, arguing that the prosecution and conviction decisions undermined freedom of assembly. On Monday (12th), the Court of Final Appeal handed down its judgment and unanimously dismissed all the appeals. Former Governor Chris Patten told The Guardian that the ruling was unjust, and that the involvement of former President of the UK Supreme Court Lord Neuberger made the matter worse. The Hong Kong Special Administrative Region Government issued a statement today (14th) strongly condemning Patten for “maliciously denigrating” the ruling and for making wanton personal attacks on Lord Neuberger.
8.18 流水式集會案,黎智英、李柱銘、吳靄儀等7名民主派人士,就「參與集結」定罪作終極上訴,爭議檢控、定罪決定損害集會自由;本周一(12日)終審法院頒下裁決,一致駁回所有上訴。前港督彭定康接受《衛報》訪問時,批評裁決不公,前英國最高法院院長廖柏嘉參與其中令事件更差;特區政府今(14日)發聲明譴責彭定康「惡意詆毀」裁決及對廖柏嘉肆意作人身攻擊,予以強烈譴責。
14 Aug 2024法庭線#3904
反恐首案|辯方:許湛榮串謀形成前已退出 控方不公起訴令許「浪費青春、人生摧毀」
In the first case under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants have pleaded not guilty. The trial at the High Court entered its 72nd day on Wednesday (the 14th). In submissions on behalf of defendant Hui Cham-wing, the defence said the prosecution’s evidence against him was devoid of substance and that it had failed to prove its case.
The defence said Hui had withdrawn before the conspiracy agreement was formed. Accomplice witness Eddie Pang Kwan-ho also confirmed that, after the gun-testing exercise, Hui no longer took part in any activities. The defence said that, from Hui’s perspective, it was conceivable that he learned during the gun test that there were guns and bombs, and decided to withdraw, refusing to answer calls from co-conspirator Ng Chi-hung.
The defence also said the prosecution knew “how much weight” the evidence against Hui carried, but nevertheless blindly and unfairly prosecuted him, leaving him to “sit in prison awaiting trial”, “waste his youth for nothing”; it was unjust, and an unfounded prosecution was destroying his life. It added: “Justice delayed is not justice, but late is better than never.”
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周三(14 日)在高等法院踏入第 72 天審訊。被告許湛榮一方陳詞指,控方針對其證據空洞無物,舉證失敗。
辯方指,許在串謀協議形成前已退出,從犯證人彭軍壕亦確認許在試槍後,已再沒參與任何行動。辯方指,由許角度可想像,他在試槍時得悉有槍和炸彈,因而決定退出,並拒絕接聽同謀者吳智鴻來電。
辯方又指,控方心知針對許的證據「有幾多斤兩」,仍盲目、不公正地起訴,令許「坐住監等審訊」、「白白浪費青春,係不公義,無理控告係摧毀佢嘅人生」;又指「遲來公義唔係公義,不過遲到好過無到」。
13 Aug 2024法庭線#3900
反恐首案|賴振邦一方結案指賴被捕後曾獲釋 可自由離港 仍留下因相信自己無辜
In the first case under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance, seven people pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 71st day at the High Court on Tuesday (13th), with submissions from the defence of defendant Lai Chun-pong. The defence criticised the testimony of guilty-plea defendant Eddie Pang Kwan-ho, saying he “shrunk whenever things got serious” and “made himself sound very capable”, but when it came to taking concrete action, claimed he had not participated and had only watched from the side. The defence also said Pang had a “selective memory” and that his account was logically confused and contradictory.
The defence concluded that Lai had been arrested twice and had been released by police for about three months during that period, allowing him to leave Hong Kong freely. He nevertheless chose to stay because he believed he was innocent and could continue working openly. The defence said that even if a defendant’s political stance was “yellow”, that did not mean he would kill police officers. It urged the jurors not to consider the defendant’s political beliefs when considering the case and to acquit Lai Tat.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周二(13 日)在高等法院踏入第 71 天審訊,由被告賴振邦一方陳詞,批評認罪被告彭軍壕的證供「逢大必縮」,「講到自己好叻」,但當實質要行動時,又稱自己沒參與其中,只在旁觀看;彭亦「選擇性記憶」,邏輯混亂、自相矛盾。
辯方最後指,賴曾兩度被捕,期間有約 3 個月獲警方釋放,可自由離港,但他仍選擇留下,正正因為他相信自己無辜,可以坦蕩蕩地繼續工作。辯方形容,即使被告的政治立場屬於「黃」,不等於會殺警,希望陪審員考慮案情時,不要考慮被告的政治理念,為賴達無罪裁決。
12 Aug 2024法庭線#3896
8.18流水式集會終極上訴 李柱銘、吳靄儀等7人敗訴 判詞:香港法庭不應跟隨兩英案例
On 18 August 2019, the Civil Human Rights Front held a flowing assembly at Victoria Park. Following trial, seven pro-democracy figures, including Jimmy Lai and Margaret Ng, were convicted of organising and participating in an unauthorised assembly. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal against the conviction for organising an assembly and quashed the convictions, but dismissed the appeal against the conviction for participating in an assembly and upheld those convictions. The defendants appealed to the Court of Final Appeal, arguing that the court should adopt the “principle of proportionality in enforcement” established in UK Supreme Court cases to consider whether the decisions to prosecute and convict had disproportionately restricted freedom of assembly. Five judges unanimously dismissed the appeal on Monday (12th). The judgment said that the legal backgrounds of the two UK cases differed from those in Hong Kong and that the legal frameworks for addressing human-rights challenges were not the same. For example, Hong Kong courts can directly declare unconstitutional laws invalid, whereas in the UK provisions declared incompatible with human rights are still regarded as valid law and continue to be enforced, potentially giving rise to consideration of whether prosecution and conviction have excessively restricted rights. Hong Kong courts should therefore not follow the UK cases and “should follow Hong Kong’s established principles of constitutional review”. The Court of Final Appeal also said the appellants’ arguments ran counter to all the principles relating to constitutional challenges in Hong Kong, stressing that the processes of arrest, prosecution, conviction and sentencing were governed by a comprehensive legal and procedural framework. Outside court, Margaret Ng said the ruling was very important, but she had not had time to study the judgment in detail and it would not be appropriate to comment. She also thanked the legal team and members of the public who had continued to support them. Martin Lee said, “No comment”.
2019 年 8 月 18 日,民陣在維園舉行流水式集會,黎智英、吳靄儀等 7 名民主派人士,經審訊後被裁定「組織」及「參與」未經批准集結兩罪罪成。上訴庭裁定 7 人「組織集結」上訴得直、撤銷定罪;「參與集結」罪則上訴失敗、維持定罪。被告一方上訴至終審法院,指法庭應採納英國最高法院案例所訂下的「執行相稱性原則」,以考慮檢控、定罪決定,有否不符比例地限制集會自由。5 位法官周一(12 日)一致裁定敗訴。
判詞指,兩宗英國案例的法律背景有別於香港,處理人權挑戰的法律框架並不相同,例如本港法庭可直接裁定違憲法律無效,但在英國,被宣告為不符合人權的條文,仍會被視為有效法律、繼續執行,有機會衍生檢控、定罪有否過分限制權利的考慮。因此,香港法庭不應跟隨英案例,「應遵從本港已確立的違憲審查原則」。終院又指,上訴方的主張,違背香港與憲法挑戰有關的所有原則,強調拘捕、檢控、定罪及判刑過程,已受到完善法律和程序管轄。
吳靄儀庭外表示,本次裁決非常重要,但未有時間詳細研究判詞,不適合作出評論,另感謝律師團隊及一直支持他們的市民;李柱銘則稱「No comment」。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.