17 Jun 2024法庭線#3701
反恐首案|從犯證人蘇緯軒稱獲安排任槍手 欲中途退出但擔心遭殺害
The first case under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance involves seven defendants who have pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 35th day at the High Court on Monday (17th). So Wai-hin, the third accomplice witness, who has pleaded guilty, confirmed in court that he had been assigned to be the gunman in the “police-killing plot”, responsible for shooting police officers from a high point in a building.
So testified that he met a man named “Stephen” in 2014 and later joined his violent organisation. So said “Stephen” was involved in planning the police-killing plot and was suspicious by nature, and that he feared he would be killed if he withdrew midway. He also said that after learning of the plan, he had “not wanted to actually take part in the plan”, and therefore used excuses such as insufficient ammunition and concerns that police officers might set up roadblocks when test-firing the weapons or on the day of carrying out the plan, hoping to stay away and delay it. After his arrest, police found an AR-15 rifle and more than 100 rounds of ammunition at his residence.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周一(17 日)在高等法院踏入第 35 天審訊。第三名從犯證人、已認罪的蘇緯軒在庭上確認,在「殺警計劃」被指派為槍手,負責在大廈高處射殺警員。
蘇供稱,在 2014 年認識一位叫「Stephen 」的男子,及後加入其武力組織。蘇指,「Stephen 」有份策劃殺警計劃,又指對方疑心重,擔心自己若中途退出會遭殺害。他又指,自己知悉計劃後,一直「唔想實際親身參與個計劃」,故在試槍或執行計劃當日,曾搬出彈藥不足、擔心警員設路障等藉口推搪,期望避席及推遲計劃。他被捕後,警方在其住所搜出 AR 15 步槍及過百發子彈。
17 Jun 2024法庭線#3702
7.1銅鑼灣|青年阻差辦公表證不成立 律政司上訴得直 發還另一裁判官重審
On July 1, 2020, large numbers of people took to the streets to protest the National Security Law. A 19-year-old man was accused of obstructing police officers outside Times Square as they arrested a woman, and was charged with obstructing a police officer in the execution of his duty. The trial magistrate, Pang Leung-ting, said videos admitted in court were inconsistent with police testimony, criticised the Department of Justice by saying, “Prosecute, prosecute, prosecute! Prosecute all the way to the ends of the earth,” and questioned whether the police’s “unlawful arrest” and firing of sponge rounds to disperse people inside the square were “open to question”. The magistrate ultimately ruled that there was no case to answer, and the defendant was not required to enter a defence.
The Department of Justice appealed by way of case stated. High Court Judge Chan Chung-hang allowed the appeal in written reasons handed down on Monday (the 17th). The judgment said the trial magistrate had applied the wrong standard in deciding that the police officer was not lawfully performing his duty, while comments on the police operation were “unsupported by sufficient evidence and of no assistance to consideration of issues relevant to the trial”. The magistrate had also overlooked the risk to public order at the time.
The judgment further said that, having regard to the comments made by the trial magistrate during the trial and other circumstances, it was appropriate for the case to be retried by another magistrate.
2020 年 7 月 1 日,大批市民上街抗議《國安法》,19 歲青年被指在時代廣場外,阻礙警員拘捕一名女子,被控阻差辦公。原審裁判官彭亮廷指呈堂影片與警員供詞不符,斥律政司「告告告!告到天腳底都要告」,並質疑警方「非法拘捕」及發射海棉彈,進入廣場內驅散「值得商榷」,終裁定表證不成立,被告毋須答辯。
律政司以案件呈述方式提上訴。高院法官陳仲衡周一(17 日)頒下書面裁決,判律政司得直。判詞指,原審採納錯誤的準標,判斷警員並非正當執行職務,而對警方行動的評論「缺乏足夠證據支持,亦對審訊相關議題的考慮並無幫助」,忽略了當時的社會安寧風險。
判詞又指,考慮到原審在審訊時作出的評論等情況,認為適合由另一位裁判官重審。
15 Jun 2024獨媒#3695
梁凌杰逝世五週年 市民太古廣場外悼念
Today marks the fifth anniversary of Leung Ling-kit’s death. As evening approached, the number of mourners at the scene gradually increased. Some brought flowers and stood silently, but did not leave them behind to avoid their being cleared away as “rubbish” by Food and Environmental Hygiene Department staff in previous years. A Police Public Relations Branch media liaison team and plain-clothes officers were on standby nearby, recording the situation.
今日是梁凌杰逝世五週年,踏入傍晚,現場悼念人數漸增,有人攜帶鮮花到場默站,未有放下,避免與過往數年被食環署人員視為「垃圾」清走。附近有警察傳媒聯絡隊和便衣戒備,並錄影現場情況。
14 Jun 2024法庭線#3688
反恐首案|辯方指賴振邦遭警毆打威嚇招認 否則「整到你坐十幾碌」 警一概否認
In the first case under the Anti-terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants have pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 34th day at the High Court on Friday (the 14th). Fung Po-lo, a police officer involved in investigating the case, said Victor Chun Keung Wong, who later became a prosecution witness, struggled violently when arrested, so officers restrained him by wrapping their arms around him and pressing down on his head and legs. However, he said he was unaware that Wong had later complained of being assaulted by police officers.
The defence also said defendant Lai Chun-pong had been required to strip down to his underpants at the police station, squat in a corner and was verbally abused as a “cockroach”. It alleged that Fung threatened him, saying: “If you just say you know them, I’ll let you go. Otherwise, I’ll definitely make sure you sit for more than a dozen years. Don’t think we have no way of getting you sent to prison.” The defence said that because Lai did not confess, police suggested to another prosecution witness, Eddie Pang Kwan-ho, that he should “name more people”. Fung denied all the allegations.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周五(14 日)在高等法院踏入第 34 天審訊。有份調查本案的警員馮保羅稱,轉任控方證人的黃振強,被捕時激烈掙扎,警員遂環抱、按頭部和腳部等方式制服他,但不知黃事後投訴被警員施襲。
辯方另指,被告賴振邦曾在警署內被要求脫剩內褲,著在牆角踎低,被喝罵為「曱甴」,指馮威嚇稱「只要話識佢哋,我就放你走。唔係我一定整到你坐十幾碌,唔好以為我哋冇辦法整到你坐監。」辯方指,因賴沒作招認,故警方向另一控方證人彭軍壕提議「篤多啲人出嚟」;馮一概否認。
14 Jun 2024獨媒#3694
【反修例五年】被捕逾7,000未起訴人士結案未?警方:正依法處理
Five years after the anti-extradition bill movement began, police figures show that, as of the end of March this year, 10,279 people had been arrested. Of these, 2,961 had completed or were undergoing judicial proceedings, and 2,328 had faced legal consequences, accounting for nearly 80% of those who entered the judicial process. More than 70%—around 7,300 arrestees—had neither been charged nor entered the judicial process. Police Commissioner Raymond Siu said several times in February last year that he hoped to announce how they would be handled within the month, and said in mid-March that work was proceeding “in full swing”, with completion hoped for within one or two months. However, Chief Executive John Lee said in May of the same year that setting a timetable without considering any evidence was “unrealistic and may not accord with the spirit of the rule of law”.
Siu did not subsequently mention another deadline for the announcement. In February this year, he only said that some cases had been handled, while others would continue to be followed up in light of the relevant evidence, as the cases were extremely complicated and investigations took time. When Independent Media asked the police whether they would set a deadline and make a formal announcement on how the cases would be handled, and how many people had been notified of their case progress, among other matters, the police did not respond, saying only that they were “handling the remaining cases in accordance with the law”. A person arrested in 2019 told Independent Media that they had still not been notified that they could retrieve their seized property. The person believed that, after so many years, the possibility of being charged again was small, but did not dare to contact the police proactively for fear that “bringing up the old matter again” would effectively prompt the police to “reopen the file”.
反修例運動爆發至今五年,根據警方數字,截至今年3月底,共有10,279人被捕,2,961人已完成或正經司法程序處理,當中2,328人須承擔法律後果,佔進入司法程序者近8成。至於逾7成、約7,300名被捕人士未被起訴及未進入司法程序,警務處處長蕭澤頤去年2月曾多次表示望月內公布處理方式,並於3月中稱正「密鑼緊鼓」,望在一、兩個月內完成;不過特首李家超同年5月表示定一個不基於任何證據考慮的時間表是「不切實際、未必符合法治精神」。
蕭澤頤其後未再提公布的限期,今年2月僅表示有些案件已處理、有些會繼續就相關證據跟進,因案件非常複雜,調查需時。《獨媒》向警方查詢,會否就案件處理方式設立限期和作正式公布、已向多少人通知案件進度等,警方均無回應,僅稱「正依法處理其餘案件」。有2019年曾被捕的人士向《獨媒》表示,至今仍未獲通知可取回證物,他認為事隔多年,再被控的機會不大,但不敢主動找警方查詢,擔心「舊事重提」會令警方變相「開檔案」。
13 Jun 2024法庭線#3684
反恐首案|辯方指稱李家田在廁所遭警施襲 搜查警:同僚稱廁所不屬搜查範圍 案件主管:沒指示不搜查
In the first case under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants have pleaded not guilty. The trial entered its 33rd day at the High Court on Thursday (13th). The defence previously alleged that, on the day of his arrest, defendant Lee Ka Tin, Christian was taken into a toilet inside the premises and assaulted by police officers. Under cross-examination by the defence on Thursday, the police officer who attended the search said a colleague had mentioned that “the toilet was not within the search area” when explaining the scope of the search.
The officer in charge of the case said he had never instructed officers that they did not need to search the toilet, and would not have allowed such an instruction to be given. The defence also raised whether defendant Eddie Pang Kwan-ho, after becoming a prosecution witness following a guilty plea, had asked police not to prosecute him. The officer in charge of the case responded that “the police have no say whatsoever” and that whether to prosecute was for the Department of Justice to consider.
On Wednesday (12th), the defence cross-examined police officer Yeung Lap-lung, who arrested Lee Ka Tin, Christian, alleging that Lee had been assaulted by police using methods including waterboarding, and threatened with the words: “It wouldn’t matter if we killed you; we could find a tree outside and hang you.” The defence also alleged that Lee was induced to give a statement according to a version provided by police officers, with the promise that he could be released on bail if he performed well. The officer denied all the allegations.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周四(13 日)在高等法院踏入第 33 天審訊。辯方早前指稱,被告李家田被捕當日,一度被警員帶入屋內廁所施襲。到場搜查的警員,周四在辯方盤問下稱,同僚交代搜查範圍時,曾提及「廁所唔喺搜查範圍內」。
時任案件主管則指,從沒指示警員毋須搜查廁所,亦不會容許作出有關指示。辯方另關注認罪被告彭軍壕轉任控方證人後,曾否要求警方不起訴他;案件主管回應指「警方係冇任何話事權」,起訴與否由律政司衡量。
辯方周三(12 日)盤問拘捕李家田的警員楊立隆時,指李遭警以「水刑」等方式施襲,威嚇「殺咗你都冇問題,就喺出面搵棵樹吊死你都得」,又利誘李按警員提供的版本錄取口供,稱若表現良好可獲保釋。警員一概否認。
12 Jun 2024法庭線#3680
反修例期間涉發表不當言論遭革職 官中教師司法覆核勝訴 公務員事務局提上訴
A female teacher at a government school was accused of posting inappropriate remarks on Facebook during the 2019 anti-extradition bill movement. Following a disciplinary hearing, she was found to have committed misconduct and was dismissed by the Civil Service Bureau. She won her judicial review in April this year, with the judge quashing the Bureau’s dismissal decision and awarding her costs.
The Civil Service Bureau confirmed in response to an inquiry from The Witness that, before the appeal deadline expired, it had filed a motion with the Court of Appeal seeking to set aside the judgment. The Bureau said it was not appropriate to comment publicly at this stage because judicial proceedings were involved.
The Bureau reiterated that the Government attaches great importance to civil servants’ discipline and conduct, has zero tolerance for civil servants who violate the law or disciplinary rules, and will handle disciplinary cases fairly, impartially and rigorously under the civil service disciplinary mechanism.
官校女教師被指 2019 年反修例運動期間,在 Facebook 發表不當言論,經紀律聆訊後被裁定行為不當,遭公務員事務局革職。她今年 4 月司法覆核得直,法官撤銷局方的革職決定,並獲頒訟費。
公務員事務局回覆《法庭線》查詢時確認,已於上訴期限屆滿前,向上訴庭提出動議,申請撤銷判決。局方又指,由於涉及司法程序,現階段不適宜公開評論。
局方重申,政府非常重視公務員的紀律和操守,對違法或違紀的公務員零容忍,會按公務員紀律機制公平、公正及嚴謹處理紀律個案。
12 Jun 2024法庭線#3681
反恐首案|辯方指李家田遭警以「水刑」等方式施襲 利誘按草稿錄口供可保釋 警否認
The first case under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance, involving seven defendants who have pleaded not guilty, entered its 32nd day of trial at the High Court on Wednesday (12th). The prosecution played a recorded interview with defendant Lee Ka Tin, Christian. Li said that after test-firing a gun, he learned that there was a plan to block roads and damage shops, luring police to the scene before opening fire. He considered the operation dangerous and therefore did not attend that day.
During cross-examination of the officer who arrested Li, the defence alleged that Lee Ka Tin, Christian was assaulted by police using “waterboarding” and other methods, and was threatened: “It wouldn’t matter if I killed you; I could find a tree outside and hang you.” It also alleged that he was told: “We could say you grabbed a gun and shoot you dead here … the same thing could happen to your mother.” The defence said police induced Li to give a statement based on a version provided by the officer, saying that he could be released on bail if he behaved well. The officer denied all the allegations.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周三(12 日)在高等法院踏入第 32 天審訊。控方播放被告李家田的錄影會面,李稱試槍後得悉將有計劃,以堵路及破壞店舖,引誘警察到場再開槍,他認為行動危險,故計劃當日沒出席。
辯方盤問拘捕李的警員,指李家田遭警以「水刑」等方式施襲,威嚇「殺咗你都冇問題,就喺出面搵棵樹吊死你都得」;又稱「可以話你搶槍,喺度開槍啪咗你都得 … 同樣嘅情況可以出現喺你啊媽身上。」辯方指出,警員利誘李按警員提供的版本錄取口供,稱若表現良好可獲保釋。警員一概否認。
11 Jun 2024法庭線#3671
反恐首案|被告李家田警誡下稱「去過西貢試槍」 曾取手槍「袋住喺身」
In the first case under the Anti-Terrorism Ordinance, seven defendants pleaded not guilty as the trial entered its 31st day at the High Court on Tuesday (11th). The defendant who pleaded guilty and became a prosecution witness, Eddie Pang Kwan-ho, completed seven days of testimony. During prosecution re-examination, he said the cost of military training in Taiwan was paid by “Daai Gwo” Walter Joseph Liu, who had previously stood for election as a district councillor, and that Lau knew of the plan to kill police officers. He also said co-conspirator Ng Chi-hung had disclosed that the operation would involve guns, and therefore believed the two matters were connected.
The prosecution also called the police officer who arrested defendant Lee Ka Tin, Christian to testify. The officer said that, under caution, Li stated that he had “gone to Sai Kung to test-fire a gun” and “returned the gun to Hung Jai afterwards”. Li also said that, during the test-firing, he had followed “Hung Jai’s” instructions to “fire one shot at an open area” and that “after firing it, [he] knew the gun was real”. Under examination-in-chief by the prosecution, the officer said he had not used force, threats, intimidation or inducements against Lee Ka Tin, Christian.
《反恐條例》首案,7 人不認罪,周二(11 日)在高等法院踏入第 31 天審訊。認罪被告、控方證人彭軍壕完成 7 天作供,他在控方覆問下稱,台灣軍訓費用由曾參選區議員的「大嚿」劉偉德支付,而劉知悉殺警計劃,同謀者吳智鴻則曾透露行動將用槍,故認為兩者有關連。
控方同日傳召拘捕被告李家田的警員作供,指李在警誡下稱「去過西貢試槍」、「之後支槍畀返鴻仔」,又指試槍時按「鴻仔」指示「向空地開咗一槍」、「開完之後就知支槍係真槍」。警員在控方主問下稱,沒以武力威脅、恐嚇或利誘李家田。
9 Jun 2024集誌社#3664
反修例五年 台灣 600人上街 關注47人案
Hong Kong Outlanders, the Taiwan-Hong Kong Association, the Judicial Reform Foundation and other groups today (the 9th) launched an event commemorating the fifth anniversary of Hong Kong’s June marches against the extradition bill. The “2024 Taipei March—Defending Democracy, Taiwan and Hong Kong Together” was held in Taipei this afternoon. The march proceeded from Liberty Square along Ketagalan Boulevard and Zhonghua Road to the Nishihonganji Temple. Its demands included continued attention to the situation in Hong Kong, improvement of asylum mechanisms, examination of the Chinese Communist Party’s threats, protection of Hong Kong people’s livelihoods, and attention to the Hong Kong 47 case. The organisers said the number of participants reached 600.
香港邊城青年、台灣香港協會與民間司法改革基金會等團體,今(9日)日發起紀念香港反送中六月遊行屆滿五周年活動。「2024台北遊行—捍衛民主 台港同行」遊行,在下午在台北市舉行。遊行路線從自由廣場往凱道、中華路遊行至西本願寺。遊行訴求為持續關注香港情勢、完善庇護機制、審視中共威脅,以及保障港人生活,關注 47 人案等。主辦單位指參與人數有達600人。
Translations are supplied by the source workbook. Consult the original reporting for context.